Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Erosion of democracy collapses NATO

Wallander 18, resident and CEO of the U.S. Russia Foundation and Senior Adviser at WestExec Advisors. From 2013 to 2017, she served as Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for Russian and Eurasian Affairs at the National Security Council (Celeste, “Enemies Within: How Democratic Decline Could Destroy the Alliance,” Council on Foreign Relations, 97.4)//BB

NATO today faces multiple challenges. Terrorists have attacked European capitals, migration is putting pressure on border and homeland security systems, Russia is both able and will- ing to use military force and other instruments of influence in Eu- rope, and U.S. President Donald Trump has threatened to scrap the alliance altogether. But the most serious problem is not one of these obvious threats; rather, it is the breakdown of liberal democracy within the alliance itself. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization has never been a typi- cal alliance. From its inception in 1949, NATO has not only deterred and defended against external threats; it has also advanced the principles of liberal democratic governance. Although its cohesion initially rested on the common threat of the Soviet Union, NATO was more unified than most multilateral organizations thanks to the common character of its members. Nearly all were democratically elected governments that were accountable to their citizens, bound by the rule of law, and dedicated to upholding political and civil rights. Article 2 of NATO's founding treaty committed members to "strength- ening their free institutions." Countries facing a common threat have often banded together for defense and survival, but most alliances don't last long once that threat is eliminated. That is why so many observers feared that NATO would disappear with the end of the Soviet Union. But thanks to the internal cohesion created by its democratic values, and the incentives its stan- dards created for aspiring new members, the alliance defied predictions. Instead of disintegrating, NATO adapted to new challenges and became a cornerstone of transatlantic security after the Cold War. Today, the Kremlin once again poses a serious threat in Europe and beyond. But unlike the last time the alliance faced down Russia, now NATO is in peril. Multiple members are dismantling the institutions and practices of liberal democracy that emerged triumphant in the Cold War, and things may get worse if autocratic demagogues exploit populist fears to gain political clout in other member states. Just when the alliance is needed as much as ever to meet challenges from with- out, the foundations of its power are at risk of crumbling because of challenges from within. THE PRICE OF ADMISSION After the fall of the Soviet Union, the liberal democratic credentials of NATO's members became even more important to the alliance. Al- though many experts and policymakers hoped that Europe would emerge from the Cold War whole, free, and at peace, others warned that without a shared enemy, the region might return to past cycles of instability and conflict fueled by revanchist, chauvinistic, and il- liberal European regimes. Far from being irrelevant, these observers argued, NATO would play a key role in bolstering liberal democracies and creating trust among countries that had spent centuries fighting one another. As if on cue, border disputes and simmering ethnic conflicts in eastern Europe began to threaten the peace almost immediately after the fall of the Soviet Union. And with the disintegration of Yugoslavia in the early 1990s, they ultimately broke it. In the face of these challenges, NATO sought to leverage the desire for member- ship to encourage political reforms by requiring that new members meet its standards for good governance. This decision was based on the belief that liberal institutions, practices, and values would pre- vent a return to the nationalist, nativist, extremist, and intolerant dynamics that had driven destructive conflicts in Europe for centu- ries. To foster security within Europe, NATO required that new members leave autocratic practices behind. Fulfilling these requirements was often politically contentious, and aspiring members did not always succeed. Countries that had spent decades under authoritarian communist rule had to root out the linger- ing influence of intelligence agencies, overturn politicized control of the military in favor of apolitical professional defense forces, establish legislative oversight for military procurement, and implement person- nel policies that would combat corruption. All of that has taken time: Montenegro set the goal of achieving membership in 2007 but had to wait ten more years to earn admission. And mere aspiration is not enough: Bosnia, for example, has yet to fulfill the criteria that the alliance set in 2010 for the country to be granted the Mem- bership Action Plan, a procedural pre- cursor to joining. These requirements may have slowed the process of NATO's expansion, but liberal institu- tions and practices are central to creating security and trust among Europe's diverse societies. Anything less would have weakened the alliance instead of strengthening it. Beyond its stabilizing effect on the broader continent, there is an- other reason NATO's liberal democratic character came to matter: in the absence of a shared external threat, the binding force of liberal democratic values and institutions has become essential to the alli- ance's effectiveness. NATO's ability to conduct security operations depends on its political cohesion as much as its members' military capabilities. Few question NATO's cohesion when Article 5 of its found- ing treaty is invoked—that is, when an ally is directly attacked. Com- mon external threats generate unified responses. After 9/11, for example, NATO members quickly joined the U.S. campaign against Taliban- ruled Afghanistan.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.