Otherwise, lack of human rights considerations for SC partnerships in the squo risks state instability and collapse of rule of law
Dalton et. Al 18 – Melissa Griffin Dalton, assistance secretary of defense for homeland defense and America’s security affairs in the Biden Administration, senior fellow and deputy director of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, manager of the Nuclear Posture Review, M.A. in international relations from the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University, B.A. in foreign affairs from the University of Virginia (“The Protection of Civilians in U.S. Partnered Operations”, CSIS, 10/30/2018, https://www.csis.org/analysis/protection-civilians-us-partnered-operations) FGY
The United States’ national security and defense strategies, as well as trends in U.S. military operations around the globe, reflect a preference for working by, with, and through partners to achieve common security objectives. Partnership may enhance the capacity of a partner government to maintain effective control over territory. It can also signal unity in deterring or degrading a common adversary or threat, for example in the U.S.-led coalition and partnered approaches to confront the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS). As outlined in our policy brief, Civilians and “By, With, and Through,” security partnerships can take a wide range of forms, from support operations and advise, assist, and accompany missions, to direct participation in hostilities through “joint” or “partnered” operations and coalitions.2 Here, we report the practical experiences of policymakers and practitioners in security and humanitarian fields in positively shaping the conduct of armed forces partnering with U.S. forces. Their combined experience— supported by the available research—suggests that it is possible, with the right conditions for success, to affect the conduct of both state and non-state armed actors to minimize harm to civilians. Practitioner lessons also suggest that in some cases, the risk of harm to civilians may be too great and the options to control risk too few to continue the partnership in an accountable manner which both effectively spares civilian lives from the effects of conflict and respects human rights. This report outlines considerations and recommendations for policymakers, military actors, and humanitarian professionals, all of whom play a role in encouraging improved policies and practices of armed forces with whom the United States partners. Partnerships in armed conflict can aggravate or reduce the risk of harm to civilians, depending on the form and significance of the partnership and the technical and political attributes and tendencies of each partner. Effectively reducing the risk of harm to civilians and optimizing positive results depends on candidly assessing the most likely sources of harm and using available options to address them throughout a partnership (i.e., before, during, and after active fighting). Partnered military operations in armed conflicts expose civilians to a wide array of risks, including injury, death, trauma, displacement, and the destruction of homes, schools, infrastructure, and livelihoods. Harm may occur because of negligence or deliberate misconduct by state and non-state actors; harm may also occur in spite of cautious and purposeful attempts to avoid it. Hostilities in urban areas can particularly disrupt civilian life: water, health, electricity, and sanitation systems are often interconnected and interdependent, and the destruction of part of the system impacts the whole.3 When explosive remnants of war contaminate the area and infrastructure damage is significant, the consequences of conflict last well beyond the end of active fighting. These challenges are evident in Mosul, Iraq and Raqqa, Syria, both of which will take decades to rebuild after intense urban conflict. Breakdowns in services and social cohesion significantly impact stability, governance, and the security of populations, creating challenges for restoring the rule of law. When the United States partners with state and non-state forces, the United States must consider what costs these partnerships will inflict on civilians, security, governance, rule of law enforcement, and transitional justice. Whether a partnership is initiated in the context of an ongoing conflict or in preparation for one, the United States can and should institute adequate protections to minimize the risk of civilian harm. In order to effectively reduce harm to civilians from military operations conducted by U.S. partners, whether jointly or alone, the U.S. government must have internal clarity about desired outcomes, political and strategic commitment to those outcomes, adequate resources and technical competence, and coherence and coordination among government agencies. Adding more than one partner to an operation increases the complexity of these variables. Fighting collectively only serves to underscore the importance of defining desired outcomes, as the actions of one partner affect the efficacy, reputation, and legitimacy of the other. Many of these factors for success are seldom implemented. The following policy approaches and practical suggestions may help minimize harm to civilians in the context of security partnerships.