Nutrition Labels solves disinformation. Yum!
Crovitz 22 [L. Gordon Crovitz, a former publisher of the Wall Street Journal, is co-CEO of NewsGuard, which rates news websites based on their journalistic reliability, 04-29-2022, Opinion, https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/03/29/law-counter-putins-propaganda-unused-00020805] Eric
The first invasion by Russia was not dispatching his military into Ukraine. It was the malignant propaganda the Kremlin skillfully deployed to poison public opinion in the U.S. and Europe. The Biden administration — specifically Attorney General Merrick Garland — should now enforce a longstanding law requiring that propaganda from hostile foreign governments be labeled as such so that Americans know who’s feeding them the news. Silicon Valley should atone for its role as Putin’s long-time enabler by pledging to give users the information they need to know when they see propaganda in their social media feeds and search results.
Russian falsehoods about its role in Syria, American bioweapons and Ukraine reached millions of people in Western democracies, including through Facebook, Google, YouTube, TikTok and Twitter. Moscow myths included that Ukraine politics is dominated by Nazis (reported by Russian government sites RT and TASS), that the government in Kyiv committed genocide against ethnic Russians in its Donbas region (Sputnik News and TASS) and that Western governments staged the coup in 2014 that led to the resignation of Ukraine’s pro-Russian president (RT and Sputnik News). This disinformation continues to find an audience in the U.S. and Europe and is being far-right and far-left commentators. The Kremlin seeks a moral equivalence between Moscow and Washington, hoping to undermine Western resolve to defend Ukraine.
Since Stalin, the Russian government has used dezinformatsiya as the spear tip of its foreign policy. What’s changed is that the internet now provides Moscow with an enormous distribution network and even revenue opportunities for its efforts — and that the U.S. no longer enforces disclosure requirements for foreign propaganda.
The Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) was created in the 1930s to counter Nazi propaganda by requiring distributors in the U.S. to disclose the nature of the source. Pamphlets and magazines sent from hostile foreign governments were required to be labeled, such as with a stamp added by the distributor indicating that the organization behind the propaganda was a registered foreign agent. In introducing the law in 1937, this would ensure Americans knew Nazi propaganda when they saw it: “The passage of this bill will label such propaganda just as the law requires us to label poison.” The House Judiciary Committee said, “The spotlight of pitiless publicity will serve as a deterrent to the spread of pernicious propaganda.”
The U.S. continued to enforce the labeling requirement through the Cold War. Magazines such as Soviet Life came with warnings stamped on them by distributors alerting readers that the publisher was an agent of Moscow.
Russian disinformation websites were under FARA during the Trump administration, but the attorneys general under several presidents have failed to update for the internet. (FARA gives the attorney general discretion to update how FARA’s broad rules are applied.) The modern equivalent of a stamp in every copy of a pamphlet paid for by the Nazi or Soviet government would be a detailed disclosure included in every article or video from the Kremlin that appeared in anyone’s social media feed or search result.
Instead of updating FARA, over the past few years there have been calls to dilute the law as an outdated relic of the Cold War. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is a forceful reminder why the kind of disclosure required by FARA matters. To its credit, the Federal Communications Commission invoked the invasion to when a foreign government has paid to distribute its propaganda, but no such rules are being applied online. Twitter on its own has at least started to identify some Russian disinformation sources as “state affiliated” in tweets, but this provides readers with limited information. (Meanwhile, Putin began requiring labeling of all Radio Free Europe and Radio Liberty stories on the web in Russia in 2020, for non-compliance by the U.S. sources.)
Labeling through extensive disclosure is more practical on the internet than in print or through broadcasts, where space is limited. Disclosures online can be detailed enough to give readers all the information they need to decide how trustworthy to consider a source. My analyst colleagues at NewsGuard often write “Nutrition Labels” for news sites in the thousands of words, with numerous citations, to explain why sites like RT and Sputnik News fail basic criteria of journalistic practice and differ fundamentally from government news sources with effective independent charters such as the BBC. Microsoft makes NewsGuard’s detailed ratings and reviews of news websites available to its users, but the other large platforms don’t yet provide this kind of transparency to their users. And labels work: Gallup research found that when given access to apolitical source ratings, a became less likely to believe or share news from websites rated untrustworthy and more likely to believe and share news from websites rated trustworthy.
Joshua Geltzer, who is now on the staff of the National Security Council, has argued for more disclosure (though not specifically through FARA), writing on : “The spread of disinformation is the rare type of national security threat for which informing the public actually can diminish the threat: if Americans know what to look out for online and what not to accept at face value on social media, the power of disinformation deliberately spread by hostile actors is reduced.”