Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Comparatively, Congress can better mediate tensions and encourage burden-sharing.

Sahay 21 [Usha Sahay is a Belfer IGA fellow and a first-year MPP candidate at HKS. Prior to Harvard, she was the managing editor of War on the Rocks, where she remains editor-at-large. She has been an editor at the Wall Street Journal and HuffPost, and a Scoville Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation., 2021, “Revitalizing NATO A Role for the U.S. Congress,” Harvard Kennedy School Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Revitalizing%20NATO%20-%20A%20Role%20for%20Congress%20-%20Sahay.pdf] Eric

Transatlantic tensions over burden-sharing: Burden-sharing is the area of NATO policy where Congress has traditionally been most active. Congressional pressure, calibrated effectively, can give the executive branch leverage with allies. The legislative branch, as the representative of the American taxpayer and the overseer of the U.S. defense budget, is well-equipped to play this role.

However, Congress should consider several caveats. First, the issue of burden-sharing is especially sensitive after the Trump presidency. With allies wary that future U.S. administrations will treat burden-sharing the way Trump did,88 congressional pressure could easily become a source of friction. Second, while Congress may find it politically valuable to crack down on “free-riding” allies, ultimately the executive branch does the negotiating.89 A heavy-handed congressional approach that isn’t coordinated with the executive could disrupt ongoing diplomatic efforts on a variety of issues.

With these obstacles in mind, members of Congress can contribute to a better burdensharing debate by keeping in mind Stanley Sloan’s idea of “constructive pressure.”90 Members can signal their continued wish for more equitable allied contributions without weaponizing the issue (particularly in public). At the same time, they can make an important concession to allied concerns by showing that they understand the problems with the two percent metric and are open to rethinking it. In this way, Congress could help tackle the burden-sharing challenge as well as the “need for new metrics” challenge. 91 I recommend:

Ø Use carefully framed NDAA language to focus attention on burden-sharing. Congress should insert language about burden-sharing into the much-watched annual National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), one of the only pieces of foreign policy legislation that Congress consistently passes. The NDAA is one of Congress’ most important formal tools for influencing foreign policy, and the executive branch and foreign countries pay close attention to it.

In the spirit of “constructive pressure” and given lingering concerns about the Trump era, it’s important that any NDAA language on burden-sharing avoid a punitive or demanding tone. One approach might be to emphasize the importance of equitable burden-sharing while avoiding specific reference to the two percent metric, which carries some sensitivity because it has been wielded as a hammer in the past. This approach would also have the advantage of opening the door to new proposals for measuring contributions.

On this and other recommendations, congressional practitioners should keep in mind that their strengths are setting the agenda, shaping the narrative, and convening political support for priorities, not legislating specific alliance policies. Even fairly vague NDAA language can serve this purpose. Compared to more detailed provisions, general language is also likely to be more feasible for members to agree on and more helpful to the executive branch and to NATO.

Ø Encourage allies to meet their commitments, but be constructive. Several interviewees suggested that members of Congress should directly communicate to foreign counterparts that burden-sharing is important to them, while avoiding being overly punitive or calling countries out publicly.

Acknowledge other forms of contribution. Individual members can use hearings, briefings, statements to the media, and Dear Colleague letters to build a two-pronged narrative: Allies need to meet their defense spending commitments, but contributions to NATO consist of more than just military spending numbers.93 Again, members should remember that as narrative-shapers and agenda-setters, they can make a meaningful contribution to the burden-sharing debate by simply engaging with it. They don’t need to have a specific solution or policy proposal in mind before they can get involved.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.