Combining Congressional and executive action guarantees an ineffective policy – defers to executive security cooperation.
Sideris 18 [Vicki Sideris worked as a project consultant at the Social Impact Hub and as a contract administrator at Insurance Australia Group, 10-03-2018, American Allies and Congress: A Friendly Face in the Age of Trump?, Australian Institute of International Affairs, https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/resource/american-allies-and-congress-a-friendly-face-in-the-age-of-trump/] Eric
As the current US President challenges the post-war status quo on the American alliance system, Congress is increasingly stepping up as one of its most vocal defenders. While there are limits to how far Congress would challenge the President and how much difference this would make, cultivating closer congressional ties represents a useful opportunity for allies seeking stability in America’s alliance management.
America’s traditional and allies have been dismayed by the President’s challenging of the alliance system. While past presidents have had disagreements with allies over defence spending, , and , President Trump’s questioning of the fundamental value of alliances and the national they serve, a significant shift from the post-war consensus in Washington. “” portrays allies as taking advantage of the US, judges the burdens of alliances to be greater than the benefits and prefers more transactional relationships. Allies are increasingly that the President’s anti-alliance outlook may not be an aberration and that business-as-usual will not resume after his term.
Yet for now, the day-to-day management of alliances goes on and Congress has increasingly stepped in to fill the President’s void by supporting alliances. The US Constitution grants foreign policy powers to both the executive and legislative branches, with the system designed as an “.” Article I Congress’ powers over trade, declarations of war, approval of presidential appointments, treaty ratifications and oversight of departments, as well as their control over the budget. Most foreign affairs-minded congressional members to subscribe to the view of America’s alliances and recently have come their defence.
For example, Congress differs from the President over its support for NATO. Pre-empting the President’s visit to the July NATO summit in Brussels, the Senate overwhelmingly a bipartisan resolution expressing support for NATO. The NATO Observer Group was in early 2018 and saw its Senate membership after the Brussels summit; with its Republican leaders that Congress had the means and will to prevent the President from withdrawing the US from NATO. In , twenty senators organised a private meeting with NATO officials and European diplomats to reassure them of Congress’ commitment to NATO and downplay the President’s behaviour. While the President has not indicated that he will soften his of NATO, Congress’ support for the alliance system and their increasing willingness to get involved in foreign relations would be useful for allies seeking to prevent the President from taking drastic action, such as withdrawing from security treaties.
Australia has long recognised the value of cultivating relationships with Congress, using as a tool to build connections, gain information and advocate for Australia’s interests. Establishing its called the Congressional Liaison Office, the embassy’s congressional outreach has delivered tangible results, including the passing of the Australia-US Free Trade Agreement and E3 visa. The aftermath of the Turnbull-Trump phone call illustrated the of these efforts, as more than sixty members of Congress reached out to Australia’s ambassador to express their support for the alliance. Resolutions reaffirming the alliance were passed by both houses and a bipartisan “” caucus was launched. This congressional contributed to the President’s shift towards a approach to Australia — seen in its from steel tariffs — and suggests that in some cases, Congress can act as a moderating force on Trump’s alliance management.
Ultimately however, the President has the most power and influence over US foreign policy, including alliance management. In recent decades, Congress has to defer to the executive on foreign policy. In some cases, their of international agreements – for example the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea – undermines allied cooperation and their interests in a “rules-based order.”
Furthermore, the domestic political climate also limits Congress’ willingness to moderate the President’s anti-alliance leanings. Both parties generally the President’s initial decision to not exempt allies from tariffs and the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee drafted which would have made for national-security tariffs a legal requirement. Yet despite bipartisan support, the Republican Senate leadership has not this to be brought to a vote. This raises the issue that while Congress disagrees with the President over his treatment of allies and has made efforts to improve relations themselves, domestic political concerns mean that they have largely of using their constitutional foreign policy powers to overtly the President outside of symbolic motions and rhetoric. The upcoming midterm elections may only intensify Congress’ and partisanship, leaving allies’ interests on the periphery.
While allies cannot solely rely on Congress, congressional engagement would be a useful way to with President Trump. Yet they cannot ignore the President, and while Congress may restrain him from withdrawing the US from its alliances, his words and actions still allies’ confidence in US commitments. Though allies are from the US anytime soon, concerns about the possibility of longer-term anti-alliance sentiment in the US may force allies to on and their own .