Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Unilateral and NATO norms fail – only bilateral relations solve norms and deterrence

Goldman 20 [Emily, Director of the US Cyber Command; “From Reaction to Action: Adopting a Competitive Posture in Cyber Diplomacy”; Fall 2020 ; DOA: 7/20/22; http://dx.doi.org/10.26153/tsw/10950; Lowell-ES]

America’s approach to building cyber norms should adapt to the following realities. First, the United States is not in a hegemonic position to define the agenda for norms in cyberspace. For a single actor to set the public agenda and drive a convergence of behavior, it would need to have control over the primary incentives and disincentives within the system, which the United States does not possess. Nor is there a clear manner in which the United States could obtain such primary control, due to the highly diffuse nature of cyberspace. Second, what is and what is not currently acceptable varies greatly depending on national perspectives, even among liberal democratic states. Despite the stated desire of the United States to establish norms through international cooperation, such norms have not emerged. The result is intense competition to drive a convergence of expectations on behavior in cyberspace.

An alternative yet related approach to building norms is to model good behavior. Convergence of norms will occur over time as other actors see that more beneficial outcomes flow from modelled good behavior than from bad behavior. This approach presents several challenges. First, behavior that might be categorized as unacceptable still produces benefits that outweigh costs. Second, adversaries cite various allegations of American bad behavior in cyberspace — global surveillance and the Stuxnet hack of the Iranian nuclear program are two examples — in labeling the United States a hypocritical standard-bearer for norms. Third, as both state and nonstate actors continue to advance their interests through behaviors that the United States considers unacceptable, modelling can easily be misunderstood as tacit acceptance.41

A third approach is reaction to a massively disruptive or destructive event that galvanizes global attention. This is how norms against genocide were set after the Holocaust. This approach presents obvious challenges. Relying on disaster to set norms is not an acceptable strategy. Nor does it seem likely that cyber capabilities will generate the level of abhorrence that characterize attitudes toward nerve agents, for example, and which have led to self-imposed proscriptions on their use.42

A fourth approach is for convergence of expectations to organically evolve through interaction. Common law demonstrates how norms emerge through practice and mature through political and legal discourse. The process of norm convergence for cyberspace has been troubling, however. For the last 10 years, the United States has witnessed the emergence of de facto norms antithetical to U.S. interests, defined by massive theft of intellectual property, expanding control of internet content, attacks on data confidentiality and availability, violations of privacy, and interference in democratic debates and processes. These activities have become normalized because the United States did not push back on them persistently and early on.43 This has encouraged more experimentation and envelope-pushing short of armed conflict. Conversely, if the United States began countering such practices, it could help to counteract this trend and encourage a form of normalization more suited to meeting U.S. interests.

These pathways can be mutually reinforcing. The first two approaches have largely succeeded with U.S. allies and partners, but important differences with major competitors remain. Existing conditions do not allow the United States to dictate norm adoption: The opening decades of the 21st century are not the late 1940s, and no state is sufficiently powerful to dictate the rules of the road. Moreover, the third approach may be inoperable. Waiting for a disaster is politically and morally problematic. The fourth approach of “normalization” holds more promise for engaging with competitors and steering Moscow and Beijing toward preferred norms. Norms are constructed through “normal” practice and then become codified in international agreements. By persistently engaging and contesting cyberspace aggression, the United States can draw parameters around what is acceptable, nuisance, unacceptable, and intolerable. The United States should not abandon U.N. First Committee processes on responsible state behavior in cyberspace, or other avenues for socialization such as international institutions or cyber capacity-building programs. But to be more effective, explicit bargaining can be reinforced by tacit bargaining through maneuver with non-likeminded states in the strategic space below armed conflict.44 Diplomats have an important role to play in this process, by engaging directly with opponents and communicating and explaining U.S. preferences to allies and partners.45 Diplomats can also assist by mobilizing coalitions — of governments, industries, academia, and citizenry, at home and abroad — for competition with ideological foes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.