Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Bilat security coop solves interoperability – it exists now, but needs to be strengthened

Adgie et al. ‘22 - Mary Kate Adgie is a research assistant at RAND, with a focus in international development and national security, sub-Saharan African affairs, and socio-economic development; Jason H. Campbell is a policy researcher at the RAND Corporation, where he focuses on issues of international security, counterinsurgency, intelligence, and measuring progress in post-conflict reconstruction; Beth Grill is a senior policy analyst at the RAND Corporation specializing in national security policy and security cooperation; Jennifer Moroney is a senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation and manages many of RAND's security cooperation–related projects for DoD clients; Angela O'Mahony is associate dean for academic affairs at Pardee RAND Graduate School and a senior political scientist at RAND; Rachel Tecott is an adjunct researcher for RAND Corporation who has helped to inform U.S. security cooperation and security force assistance efforts around the world; David Thaler is a senior researcher at the RAND Corporation (RAND, “Prioritizing Security Cooperation with Highly Capable U.S. Allies”, 2022, https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RRA600/RRA641-1/RAND_RRA641-1.pdf )//RG

Allies such as the United Kingdom and Australia support and encourage interoperability discussions and new investments during senior-level interactions with the Army. For example, interoperability discussions have historically dominated the agenda for the U.S.-British army-to-army staff talks. The Multinational Fusion Cell in the HQDA brings together assigned personnel from multiple allied countries (the United Kingdom, Australia, Japan, Germany, France, and others) to focus on interoperability and to develop U.S.-allied bilateral interoperability roadmaps. Standing organizations, such as ABCANZ, also exist to work through interoperability issues at the operational level. Large-scale exercises, such as the aforementioned biannual Talisman Sabre series between the United States and Australia, are very much focused on addressing interoperability challenges identified from recent operations and planning for future operations. NATO defines interoperability along three dimensions—human, procedural, and technical—which is a helpful way to categorize interoperability challenges.34 We find general agreement among our interlocutors that SC with highly capable allies to support human, procedural, and technical interoperability is advancing at the operational and tactical levels, but there is concern about a lack of multiyear funding and programming to guide longer-term planning for multinational interoperability exercises.35

Despite this focus, interoperability initiatives at the strategic level have been relatively ad hoc from allies’ perspectives. The Army’s Interoperability Campaign Plan frames and institutionalizes interoperability efforts internally and operationalizes it with designated partners. Allies support the Army’s focus on interoperability writ large, but the links between interoperability planning and ongoing SC activities needs to be stronger. As an example, the GORT, a bilateral event between the United States and the United Kingdom at the three- and four-star level, is not explicitly linked to the discussions that occur at the one- and two-star levels. According to key allied officials, issues raised at the GORT level should be automatically addressed at the subsequent Army staff talks (ASTs) and drive the discussions at the lower level working groups. Interoperability issues and priorities raised at the GORTs/staff talks should also be linked to other key bilateral SC activities, creating a real battle rhythm for interoperability.

Moreover, allies have suggested that although bilateral vision statements for interoperability—such as the emerging one with the United Kingdom—are positive steps, their language could be made stronger and clearer. They suggest dropping the term vision and making bilateral campaign plans. In addition, aspirational verbs in Army plans, such as institutionalize, should be replaced by stronger verbs, such as guarantee.36

Both British and Australian officials talk about wanting to be the United States’ partner of choice; the United Kingdom has in place an explicit strategic communications campaign plan that focuses on improved access and science and technology collaboration. For the United Kingdom, this partnering includes such areas as energy; antisubmarine warfare; hypersonics; network command, control, and communications; and nuclear collaboration. For Australia, areas include intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance; radars; and other high-technology systems. The emphasis on being a partner of choice refers to being capable, likeminded, and committed. It is understandable why key allies desire to have the strongest language possible in interoperability planning documents.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.