Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

DCAs are mutually exclusive with and distinct from alliances – alliances focus on conflict, and DCAs focus on routine activities

Kinne ‘19 – Associate professor of political science at the University of California, Davis whose research explores international networks in the areas of militarized conflict, intergovernmental organization, and bilateral cooperation (Brandon, The Journal of Conflict Resolution, “The Defense Cooperation Agreement Dataset (DCAD)”, June 1, 2019, https://escholarship.org/content/qt9w01x2xp/qt9w01x2xp_noSplash_55bbf5575b57f411fe9f941715ebb307.pdf )//RG

Browsing the “military matters” category of the UNTS reveals agreements on military cemeteries, radar stations, tobacco use by military personnel, and various other topics. Even seemingly trivial defense agreements are numerous. Accordingly, I distinguish DCAs from those defense agreements that have previously received scholarly attention, such as nonaggression pacts, mutual defense pacts, strategic partnerships, and status-of-forces agreements (SOFAs).

Defense pacts and nonaggression pacts have been heavily studied (e.g., Gibler 2009; Mattes and Vonnahme 2010; Walt 1987). Leeds, Ritter, Mitchell, and Long (2002) place both agreement types under the broader definition of a military alliance:

Alliances are written agreements, signed by official representatives of at least two inde- pendent states, that include promises to aid a partner in the event of military conflict, to remain neutral in the event of conflict, to refrain from military conflict with one another, or to consult/cooperate in the event of international crises that create a potential for military conflict.

Alliances focus primarily on conflict, especially of the interstate variety. By contrast, DCAs exclusively address issues of cooperation. Of course, these substantive focuses may overlap. Alliances may require cooperation in order to achieve their goal of minimizing or preventing conflict. Indeed, some alliances promote forms of cooperation—working groups, exercises, training and exchange—that overlap with DCAs. Yet, while conflict-related obligations are a necessary condition for alliances, additional provisions regarding cooperative activities are not. DCAs, on the other hand, are defined precisely by their goal of institutionalizing routine cooperative defense activities. Indeed, DCAs overtly exclude the mutual defense commitments that define alliances as such.15

Even when alliances discuss cooperation more generally, they do not engender umbrella frameworks for the full range of states’ defense activities. Provisions on peacetime cooperation are in fact uncommon outside of ambitious alliances like NATO. Leeds et al. (2002) find that while about half of alliances involve mutual consultation, less than 15% mandate interpersonal contact during peacetime. And while many alliances encourage “economic cooperation, protection of minorities, scientific or cultural exchange, environmental protection, etc.,” these activities are overtly non- military (Leeds 2005: 30). By contrast, routine activities like joint exercises, officer exchanges, procurement and acquisition, joint weapons collaborations, and defense industrial cooperation are the core purview of DCAs.

The distinction between alliances and DCAs is straightforward. The primary goal of an alliance is to specify obligations contingent on armed conflict. The primary goal of a DCA is to establish generic frameworks for routine cooperative defense activities. The two agreement types are mutually exclusive. Alliance and DCA obligations are also empirically distinct. At the dyad-year level, the correlation between DCAs and alliances is typically less than 0.2. The vast majority of DCA partners lack a direct alliance of any form.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.