Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

“The” NATO means the group as a whole

United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts 2003 (“Vlt Corp. v. Lambda Elecs.,” 01-CV-10957-PBS, Lexis)//BB

1. It Depends On What the Word "The" Means The first skirmish involves the word "the." The claim language states "circuitry for recycling the magnetizing energy stored in said transformer to reset it." (Emphasis added). Lambda asserts that the word "the" means all of the magnetizing energy in the transformer. Vicor contends that the claim allows for the possibility that some of the energy may be recycled [**10] to reset the core while other energy is delivered to the load. In other words, it argues that the word "the" can mean "some of the," and explains that the word "the" was used to distinguish "the magnetizing" energy from the more general term "energy" that is used earlier in the preamble. Nice linguistic jousting, but the use of the word "magnetizing" alone would have been an adequate adjective to single out the kind of energy intended for recycling. If only some of the transformer's energy needed to be recycled, the word "the" would not have been used. Lambda's argument that the word "the" connotes all the magnetizing energy is persuasive because it gives ordinary and common sense effect to the word "the" in the claim language. See Merriam-Webster's [*352] Collegiate Dictionary 1221 (10th ed. 1993) (giving one definition of "the" as: "used as a function word before a noun . . . to indicate reference to a group as a whole"). This claim thus describes an invention that recycles all of the magnetizing energy to reset the transformer core.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.