Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US hegemony is not imperial – it facilitates cooperation and international decision making – but China and Russia are revisionist and would expand without the US

Deudney and Ikenberry 21 – Deudney is a Professor of Political Science at Johns Hopkins University and Ikenberry is the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University, 11/26/21 (Daniel and John, “Getting Restraint Right: Liberal Internationalism and American Foreign Policy”, Survival, Volume 63 Issue 6, accessed 6/22/2022)//jd

Within this balance-of-power alliance the United States may be dominant, but its writ stops far short of empire. It is a hierarchical order with liberal characteristics – a mixed and complex system built around institutions, bargains, partnerships, alliances and norms of diffuse reciprocity.41 What is distinctive about this type of order is that it is bargained, with the lead state providing services and frameworks for cooperation. In return, it invites participation and compliance by other states, starting with the subsystem of liberal democracies. In formal terms, there are three features of liberal hegemony that separate it from empire. Firstly, the leading state sponsors and operates in a system of negotiated rules and institutions. Power disparities still afford advantages to the hegemonic state, but the arbitrary and indiscriminate exercise of power is reined in to the degree required to keep the order going. Secondly, the leading state provides an array of public goods – or club goods – in exchange for the cooperation of other states. Historically, these have included security and support for an open trade regime.42 Thirdly, the hegemonic order provides channels and networks for reciprocal communication and influence. These informal ‘voice opportunities’ arise from informal access to the policymaking process of the hegemonic state and the intergovernmental institutions that make up the system.43 Alliances and multilateral institutions provide mechanisms for communication and ‘pulling and hauling’ between states within the order.44 While formal decision-making is not shared, the system works more like a pluralist domestic regime than an empire.45 The United States’ hegemony does afford it asymmetrical power. While this leaves partners with less influence, it also facilitates collective decision-making.46 Those exhorting America to ‘come home’, motivated by a critique of America as empire, are arguing for a world order which will advance and not retard empire in the international system. The Quincy prescription of radically reducing the US global footprint is an invitation to other powers to extend their imperial reach. Other great powers, notably China and Russia, have been quite explicit in their ambition to extend their domination of neighbouring peoples and to create regional and world orders that reflect and support their anti-democratic, anti-liberal and kleptocratic qualities. The liberal order among democracies, led by the United States, remains the best middle path between anarchy and empire. For the United States to abandon it would mark a historic decline in the prospects for individual liberty, democratic accountability and social justice.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.