Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US renewables prevent rampant oil interventionism – we avoid global conflcits

Bolstad & Lee ’21 — Parker Bolstad, Military Intelligence Officer, United States Army, former research assistant at the Brookings Institution and the Congressional Research Service, graduate, Colorado School of Mines; Jordy Lee, Program Manager, Supply Chain Transparency Initiative at the Payne Institute for Public Policy; (July 26th 2021; “Energy Independence Doesn’t Mean What It Used To”; Foreign Policy; https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/07/26/energy-independence-climate-change-us-national-security/?tpcc=recirc_latest062921; //LFS—JCM) [***NOTE*** — paragraphs have been condensed for readability, no text changed, omitted, or altered]

For decades, U.S. policymakers failed to understand the full meaning of energy independence. Their definition centered on the need for a self-sufficient supply of cheap oil and gas. That understanding was so dominant it became a matter of national security—eclipsing nearly all other environmental considerations. U.S. President Joe Biden is making a different bet. Biden realizes two things. First, climate change is its own national security threat; second, real energy independence now means securing the resources and ideas needed for 21st-century energy technologies—among other things, solar panels, rare-earth metals, batteries, and wind turbines. Yet although the Biden administration has made great strides forward with this acknowledgment, its climate strategy has room to grow. As climate change continues to destabilize at-risk regions worldwide, threatening to draw the United States into more protracted, international conflicts, the administration needs to do more to treat climate change as a matter of national security rather than as just an environmental concern—and to move toward true energy independence in the process.

For too long, policymakers thought the oil and gas industry was the key to energy independence. They gave the industry special treatment, allowing it to operate with minimal environmental restrictions in an effort to boost the economy and unshackle the country from its reliance on foreign hydrocarbons. From one perspective, that made sense: The oil and gas boom that began in the early 2000s, with the advent of hydraulic fracturing (or fracking), made the United States the largest oil producer in the world. It provided a significant  to the economy and enabled the country to cut its reliance on foreign oil and gas .

However, this traditional promotion—and conception—of energy independence ignored the pressing issue of climate change. The United States  to effectively diversify its energy portfolio, and now, it lags behind other nations in renewables. This oversight has become a liability. Other countries are outright refusing to buy U.S. natural gas for being “too dirty”; carbon border adjustments, or tariffs on products with high carbon emissions,  to disrupt the competitive advantage U.S.-made products have; and now, sourcing the materials from abroad to build renewables has become  than it was before.

As hydrocarbons become less of a geopolitical priority, the meaning of “energy independence” is changing—in ways that have made it hard for the United States to keep up. It’s no longer measured by oil extraction, but by new, low-carbon energy technologies, such as solar panels, wind turbines, electric vehicles, and even responsibly sourced natural gas. China has the power to influence U.S. energy production, defense technologies, and other industries. Although U.S. policymakers dithered for the past 30 years, the country continued to lag behind the competition for these newer technologies and the critical minerals needed to build them. And China has rushed ahead. It’s now for more than half of the world’s solar panel module exports, and it , for instance, 80 percent of the world’s battery material refining and 77 percent of the world’s battery cell capacity. By now, Washington relies on other nations—especially China—for the critical mineral imports needed to build everything from electric vehicles to solar panels and wind turbines. Limitations on these minerals can make it harder to adopt low-carbon technologies and can leave Washington vulnerable to the whims and desires of those nations. China, essentially, has the power to influence U.S. energy production, defense technologies, and other industries that rely on the same critical materials.

Meanwhile, as the United States continues to be the second largest contributor of greenhouse gas emissions, climate change has amplified everything from humanitarian crises that drag Washington into protracted foreign conflicts to the growth of terrorist organizations that threaten domestic security. According to the , some nations, including Iraq, Pakistan, and Syria, could see more than a 20 percent reduction in their GDPs by 2090 due to climate change as they face deaths from heat waves, famines, floods, and crumpling infrastructure from storms and rising sea levels. The destruction wrought by these changes can be a catalyst for humanitarian crises, genocide, and terrorism. For instance, competition over depleting resources can worsen regional fighting, as it did in 1994 when arable land shortages contributed to the genocide in Rwanda. It can also spark conflict, as it did in Syria in 2007 when drought was to the nation’s protests and subsequent revolution. The last two decades have shown it is increasingly difficult for Washington to stay out of international conflicts—either because they pose a direct threat to the United States, as the stability of Afghanistan did, or because they make the country vulnerable to criticism that it is complacent in the face of international travesties, as it was during the revolution in Syria.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.