Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU separation from NATO is impossible – interest in close cooperation and lack of independent capabilities

Hidayet Çilkoparan 18, Master of Science in the Department of International Relations at the Graduate School of Social Sciences of the Middle East Technical University, “EUROPE’S SECURITY CHALLENGES AND TRANSATLANTIC RELATIONS”, October 2018, Middle East Technical University, https://open.metu.edu.tr/bitstream/handle/11511/27654/index.pdf /lg

NATO has strong and deterrent military capabilities, and no one is in doubt that when there is political will and solidarity among its members, the Alliance is able to respond any threat coming from an external source. 

On the other hand, the EU is still in a soul-searching process in terms of its military role in the current European security architecture; still seeking to achieve strategic autonomy from NATO, it has been caught unprepared for the US President Trump’s approach to NATO and European security. 

Despite the progress achieved in the past decades, the EU integration process in the field of security and defence has not moved ahead as fast as progress in other areas. The reasons behind this are diverse, and include the UK’s reluctance to invest in the EU efforts as it considered the NATO the primary organization in charge of European security, the USA’s unclear position towards European integration in the area of security and defence, and differences of opinion among the major EU countries on how to deal with the RF.137

In transatlantic relations, ensuring close co-operation and synergy between NATO and the EU in areas of common concern is important. These two key institutions have a common objective, namely ensuring peace and stability in the Euro-Atlantic area. Through regular meetings and contacts, they work together and co-ordinate closely to ensure that their activities are complementary and mutually reinforcing. NATO appreciates the EU’s increased efforts to enhance its defence capabilities through new initiatives like EDF and PESCO, which will also contribute to the strength of NATO; the EU, on the other hand, values NATO’s ongoing efforts, undertaken in a spirit of alliance and collective security, to ensure the defence of the Euro-Atlantic area, including through its fight against terrorism. In this sense, the two organizations are aware of each other’s important roles and contributions to the maintenance of security and stability in their respective areas of responsibility.138

In the opinion of NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, the cooperation between NATO and the EU on military issues has never been closer. At the NATO Defence Ministers meeting held in Brussels at the end of July 2018, Secretary General Stoltenberg mentioned that in 74 areas, which range from cybersecurity to joint naval operations and the fight against terrorism, the EU and NATO have been working together and making significant progress.139

In the context of the EU’s military projects, which are aimed at enhancing the EU’s defence capabilities and supplementing NATO assets, the EU Commission proposed to invest 6.5 billion Euro over the next decade in Europe’s highways so that armed vehicles could be transported easily around the continent. The priority given to military infrastructure results from lessons drawn from deployment of military vehicles from across Europe to the Baltics in 2018.140

As they face common threats and challenges, pursue similar strategic objectives through close co-ordination and co-operation, NATO and the EU have achieved a significant level of complementarity in planning and developing their defence capabilities. It is thus fair to conclude that the relationship between the two organizations is characterized more by synergy than by rivalry

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.