A relational approach to digital sovereignty centering the national Self and its Other is key
Budnitsky 22 – PhD in Communication from Ottawa’s Carleton University. He also holds degrees in Nationalism Studies from Central European University and in Journalism and Media Management from Moscow’s Higher School of Economics. (Stanislav, “A Relational Approach to Digital Sovereignty: e-Estonia Between Russia and the West”, 3/1/22, International Journal of Communication 16(2022), https://ijoc.org/index.php/ijoc/article/download/16896/3744, Accessed 7/19/22)//mackerel
What is to be gained from a relational approach to digital sovereignty? This article argued that centering the relationship between the national Self and its Others in the analysis of national digital sovereignty elucidates why and how it emerges and develops. This argument bridges two established claims from constructivist theories of culture and technology. One is that national identity as articulated and propagated by governing elites guides the state’s technological program. Another is that identity is an inherently relational category that is maintained through continuous boundary making between the Self and its Others. Taken together, these claims indicate that it is analytically productive and sometimes imperative to attend to relational dynamics between the national Self and its Others to grasp the logics of digital sovereignty. To illustrate this proposition, this article traced how Estonia’s cultural constructions of its Russian and Western Others shaped the contours of its digital sovereignty. It showed that Estonia’s digital initiatives, which are often couched in technofuturistic postnational discourse, are meant to reaffirm Estonia’s sovereign territorialized existence within the Euro-Atlantic community.
Whereas this article examined digital sovereignty as an elite political project manifested in highlevel official discourses and institutions, the relational lens’s theoretical and methodological versatility opens the door for diverse scholarly approaches to digital sovereignty. Ethnographies of infrastructure, for example, can investigate Self-Other dynamics in the everyday workings of digital sovereignty, what cultural anthropologist of technology Alix Johnson (2021) conceptualizes as the “mechanics of sovereignty.” This approach treats sovereignty as a process of material construction and explores its constitutive people and practices. Lorraine Kaljund (2018), for instance, draws on participant observation and interviews with the developers of a recent e-Estonia initiative, data embassy, to explore how this team embeds ethnocentric Estonian statehood into the project’s software, code, and policy.
Another dimension to consider is domestic power struggles over competing constructions of Otherness and technology. Analyses of debates and decision making surrounding digital sovereignty, particularly the use of Othering to legitimize one’s technological agenda, illuminate how and why some ideas but not others become state rhetoric and policy. The official e-Estonia narrative retroactively frames Estonia’s digital turn as a self-evident response to Soviet occupation and a reflection of ethnic Estonians’ natural predisposition toward technology. Yet, when Estonia’s ruling coalition first promoted the project of digital transformation in the early 1990s, as part of their Western-oriented ethnocentric platform, it was not uniformly supported across the political spectrum. How did e-Estonia become political dogma, the questioning of which is seen as tantamount to undermining Estonia’s Euro-Atlantic credentials and benefiting Russia? Detailing national technopolitical struggles would help show digital sovereignty as always a product of political contention, including over membership in the national imagined community.
Further, sociological approaches might explore how Self-Other dynamics manifest within the circles directly involved in the making of digital sovereignty. Historically, dominant ethnic and political elites excluded their Others from creating and enjoying technological innovation on par with the privileged group (Edgerton, 2006, pp. 131–136). Scholars of e-Estonia note that the country’s digital elite—entrepreneurs, developers, policy makers—remain almost exclusively ethnically Estonian (Kattel & Mergel, 2019, p. 147) and that national digitization does not benefit the social and professional standing of ethnic Estonians and Russians equally (Drechsler, 2018, p. 13). In Estonia and elsewhere, future research could employ the relational lens in examining the structural barriers to participation in the making of digital sovereignty and the consequences of such representational imbalances.
Specific manifestations of Self-Other dynamics on digital sovereignty will vary across national contexts. The analytical task of the relational approach is to discover and conceptualize Others and then empirically demonstrate their material significance for digital sovereignty. Beyond the nation-state, the relational approach potentially applies to other types of digital sovereignty conceptualized by scholars, such as municipal, personal, indigenous, corporate, and others.