Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Technology regulation causes NATO to pursue a “broad and shallow” approach that overextends and dilutes the alliance.

Moller and Rynning 21 [Sara Bjerg Moller is Assistant Professor in the School of Diplomacy and International Relations at Seton Hall University. Sten Rynning is Professor in the Center for War Studies at the University of Southern Denmark.; “Revitalizing Transatlantic Relations: NATO 2030 and Beyond”; The Washington Quarterly; March 23, 2021; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0163660X.2021.1896133?journalCode=rwaq20#:~:text=If%20the%20allies%20are%20not,before%20it%20has%20even%20begun.]//eleanor

If the allies are not careful, domestic contentions and international disputes over trade and technology regulation could consume their political energy, breaking the promise of transatlantic renewal before it has even begun. To stave off this dim prospect, NATO is embarking on a strategy of transatlantic renewal, the centerpiece of which will be a new Strategic Concept—its first in a decade. NATO’s current Strategic Concept dates back to 2010 and reflects NATO’s thinking on how to cope with the divisive nature of the War on Terror, and it is inadequate for a changed world of great power rivalry. A new Strategic Concept has long been on the agenda in the corridors of NATO diplomacy, but no one dared open this Pandora’s Box during the Trump presidency. Following the November 2020 US presidential elections, NATO’s Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg stepped forward to sketch a calendar for strategic change: a mandate for a Strategic Concept review from the NATO heads of state and government in mid-2021, leading to their agreement on a new Strategic Concept in mid-2022.2 The virtue of this calendar is that it runs with the positive momentum of change inherent in the Biden presidency and concludes after German (October 2021) and French (April–May 2022) elections, with the timing ending before Stoltenberg’s mandate as Secretary General expires in September 2022. Stoltenberg has in fact been building up this momentum for change through 2020, having gained a mandate from a NATO Leaders Meeting in December 2019 to frame a “forward-looking reflection process” to strengthen NATO’s political dimension and consultation mechanisms.3 The reflection process—run by 10 experts under Stoltenberg’s guidance—was rebranded as the NATO 2030 initiative last March, complete with a slick new promotional campaign to spur public debate and interest in the alliance’s work. The experts’ report was made public in early December 2020: it too called for a review of the Strategic Concept, including a significant upgrade to NATO’s “political dimension.” 4 NATO is thus confronted with the choice of whether to merely update its old Strategic Concept from 2010 or do a 360 degree top-to-bottom review of it. A simple update would entail a broad focus on a growing range of “core tasks” running on parallel tracks. Stoltenberg has indicated a preference for this option, which is reflective of a complex and unwieldy security environment.5 But more of the same carries a risk of diluting NATO both politically and militarily: it would fragment NATO’s political focus, leave the deterrence of Russia incomplete, and fail to define collective defense interests in regard to China. In other words, there is a real risk that NATO will seek the wrong kind of renewal: going “broad and shallow” by taking on more tasks and/or elevating existing missions, like counterterrorism, to sit alongside collective defense, crisis management, and cooperative security as “core tasks” of equal importance, as it did when it elevated the latter two mandates in 2010.6 NATO should instead go “narrow and deep” on collective defense, recommitting itself to its original purpose of deterring and defending against systemic rivals.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.