NATO 2030 agenda and recent commitments to combatting China’s rise are effective and have broad support – solves China deterrence.
Brauss ’21 -- Senior Associate Fellow At The German Council On Foreign Relations (Dgap) and Former Nato Assistant Secretary General For Defense Policy And Planning (Heinrich Brauss, 6-17-2021, "Judy Asks: Is NATO Ready for China?," Carnegie Europe, https://carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/84798, accessed 6-24-2022) -- nikki
At their recent meeting in Brussels, NATO leaders agreed an ambitious transatlantic agenda for the future: NATO 2030. The alliance is determined to address global developments relevant to its security by strengthening and broadening political consultations; further enhancing resilience; fostering technological innovation; tackling the implications of climate change as a threat multiplier; and increasing cooperation with partners, including in the Asia-Pacific. The vigorous implementation of these commitments will help NATO to deal with the strategic implications of China’s rise to world power status. For the first time, NATO acknowledges that China’s ambitions, strategy, and behaviour present systemic challenges to alliance security. It is determined to “engage China with a view to defending the security interest of the Alliance.” At the same time, Russia’s aggressive actions continue to constitute a threat to Euro-Atlantic security. Its growing cooperation with China carries the risk of concurrent strategic challenges in the Euro-Atlantic and Indo-Pacific regions. The United States considers China its primary strategic competitor and is shifting its strategic focus to the Asia-Pacific. NATO must therefore ensure Euro-Atlantic stability. Credible deterrence and defense against Russia remain its priority task. The new Strategic Concept must address all these challenges, ensure a shared strategic vision, and strengthen alliance cohesion. KATE HANSEN BUNDTSECRETARY GENERAL OF THE NORWEGIAN ATLANTIC COMMITTEE NATO’s joint statement on China as a systemic challenge to the rules-based international order and the summit’s approval of the NATO 2030 reform package were necessary steps in NATO getting ready for China. But this was far from saying that China is a challenge that will trigger conventional military use or out-of-area operations for NATO. NATO needs to confront China in areas where it poses a challenge to the alliance. Facing cyber, technological, and other asymmetric threats, such as disinformation campaigns and attempts to influence political decisionmaking processes, calls for action. And clearly, out-of-area does not apply to these threats. China is becoming a global power in terms of high technology. Chinese companies are already center stage when it comes to surveillance technology. And in the race to control and influence the global digital infrastructure, China is playing an increasingly bigger role in the development of technological standards. It is also expanding its nuclear programs. Together this is challenging alliance security and democratic values. In addition, China has been growing as a global economic superpower through its direct investments in European infrastructure, which also calls for allied awareness. If NATO members are to protect their common values, it is vital that they stand up against authoritarian forces that want to undermine the allies. Following the summit this week, NATO member states have jointly agreed that this is a battle they want to take on together. RALUCA CSERNATONIVISITING SCHOLAR AT CARNEGIE EUROPE The rise of China and the evolving Sino-U.S. great power rivalry are the defining geopolitical features of our time. They will unquestionably have a defining impact on NATO’s 2030 agenda and its new Strategic Concept. China’s rise as a high-tech great power and systemic challenger should be seen as an opportunity to remember NATO’s very purpose as a high-level political and military organization. But NATO requires the United States and the EU to come together and improve joint strategic awareness, encourage a coherent Euro-Atlantic approach for the Indo-Pacific, and recommit to the defense of common democratic values and a rules-based international order. A first step in the right direction was NATO leaders taking a tougher line on China at the Brussels summit. Details about a specific NATO China policy in the communiqué were sparse. But an emphasis on China shows that the alliance’s traditional and still almost exclusive Russia focus is slightly shifting. China’s military reach is getting closer to the Euro-Atlantic area. It will likely challenge the alliance’s ability to build collective resilience, safeguard critical infrastructure, address emerging and disruptive technologies, and protect sensitive supply chains. Such wide-ranging challenges are complex. They will require a comprehensive EU-U.S. NATO approach and a shared vision as well as a constructive dialogue with China where possible. The alliance will also need to overcome substantial and potentially show-stopping intra-alliance political and military organizational hurdles. Closer cooperation with the EU, given its regulatory, economic, and technological innovation instruments, would also enable NATO to respond to the multifaceted risks and threats of this new era. MARTA DASSÙSENIOR DIRECTOR OF EUROPEAN AFFAIRS AT THE ASPEN INSTITUTE If “ready” means that NATO is able and willing to consider China as a potential security challenge, NATO is ready. China will figure prominently in the new Strategic Concept, to be approved in 2022. For the first time in a NATO communiqué, China’s military buildup is considered to be a systemic challenge to alliance security. And NATO’s new global agenda entails commitments in critical fields, amplified by or related to China’s rise: from value chains’ vulnerabilities in strategic sectors to the need to preserve a technology edge in defense; from countering cyber attacks—mostly from Russia but also from China—to reinforcing resilience of democratic societies. If, however, “ready” means that NATO will engage military in the Asia-Pacific region, this is not the case: NATO is not turning into a Sino-centric alliance. And Washington is not asking NATO to support the United States militarily in Asia. Joe Biden is suggesting, instead, a new transatlantic bargain: NATO, with renewed American commitment, will focus mainly on Europe and collective defense—and here Russia remains the main military threat for the alliance. At the same time, European allies will support Washington in containing China, first of all in diplomatic and economic terms. Is Europe ready to sustain its part of the bargain? This is the key question, to which Europeans still reply with some ambiguity.