Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

NATO already has multiple structural problems – overstretch is the squo.

West 22 [West, 6-12-2022, Behind Nato’s defensive ‘shield’ lies weakness and division. Ukraine will pay the price, Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/12/behind-natos-defensive-shield-lies-weakness-and-division-ukraine-will-pay-the-price] Eric

Why is Nato not doing more? Taken together, all the rationales and excuses for passivity and inaction produce a picture of an alliance  than its admirers pretend.

Initially backing Ukraine, albeit at arm’s length, gave Nato a boost. Its stock rose from the low-point of .

But if, as expected, the war grinds on, if both sides grow desperate, if the diplomatic impasse deepens, and if the threat of wider conflict rises, Nato’s long unaddressed weaknesses and vulnerabilities will become both more obvious and more hazardous for those crouching behind its battlements. Its post-Soviet bluff may finally be called.

It would be unrealistic to expect seamless political unanimity in so large an organisation. But the fact that each member has an equal say when, in terms of military capacity, they are absurdly unequal, hinders swift, bold decision-making. A , for example, would be likely to produce a paralysing cacophony of conflicting voices within Nato – and Putin surely knows it.

At the same time, there is huge over-reliance on the US, a military superpower without whose agreement nothing happens and behind whose might the laggards lurk, refusing to pay their way.

Organisationally and militarily, too, . It has three joint command headquarters – in Italy, the Netherlands and the US. But its top general is based in Belgium. Inter-operability of different countries’ weapons systems is lacking, as are joint training exercises, arms procurement and intelligence-sharing.

Nato is also increasingly overstretched, caught between a Russian threat in the Euro-Atlantic area and .

Leaders from Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand are expected in Madrid. Their shared nightmare:  with echoes of the 1939 Nazi-Soviet pact.

Nato is due to publish  on how to deal with all this, plus trans-national terrorism, destabilising climate change, cyber warfare and the rise of anti-democratic states. It’s a tall order.

Overdue, too, is the Biden administration’s , which had to be hastily recalibrated following the Ukraine invasion.

Yet if it is to move forward effectively on these numerous fronts, Nato must also look back, admit past mistakes and accept some responsibility for the current crisis.

By keeping Ukraine in membership limbo while failing to punish Putin for war crimes in Chechnya and Syria, his 2008 attack on Georgia, his annexation of Crimea and his post-2014 Donbas proxy war, complacent western leaders unwittingly paved the way for today’s catastrophe.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.