Turn --- including tech discussions key to effective concept and building deterrence
Ringsmose and Rynning ‘21
(Jens Ringsmose and Sten Rynning are both professors of war studies at the University of Southern Denmark.“NATO’s Next Strategic Concept: Prioritise or Perish,” Survival Global Politics and Strategy Volume 63, 2021 - Issue 5 pg Taylor and Francis //um-ef)
Intensifying internal political–military dialogue It is clear that NATO’s broad engagement with a range of amorphous crises following the end of the Cold War eroded its own internal political–military dialogue. The art of managing such crises was new to the Alliance, and it relied more on diplomacy and a host of other non-military means to do so, rather than on defence plans and military deterrence. Thus, as NATO – with some difficulty – built experience in crisis management from Bosnia and Kosovo to Afghanistan and Libya, the close communication that had once existed between the North Atlantic Council and SACEUR withered, becoming more contingent in nature. The Strategic Concept should help to rebuild this relationship. By prioritising collective defence and building a narrative of values, the Strategic Concept would invite a dialogue on the compatibility of a broad set of values with a focused military strategy to keep Russia at bay in the Euro-Atlantic area. The challenge will be to sustain this dialogue. The Reflection Group appointed by Stoltenberg rightly emphasised the need to enhance NATO’s political consultations,but gave scant attention to political–military dialogue.48 NATO should consider putting military technology front and centre in this dialogue. Military technology has come a long way, offering vastly enhanced processing power rooted in artificial intelligence (AI), faster loops from decision to strike, and the high speeds of hypersonic weaponry. Of course, rapid change can cause problems that need political framing and guidance. New technology complicates not only inter-service or joint warfare but also multinational warfare and, not least, the civilian decision-making that is meant to lie at the heart of strategy.49 Thus, military technology can be found at the juncture between the NATO priorities of values (democratic control) and defence (at high speed). Technology has already captured high-level political attention in and around NATO. President Biden is set to focus on ‘technologies vital to longterm economic and military power’ in the United States’ competition with other powers, primarily China.50 Britain’s March 2021 Integrated Review aims to ‘grow the UK’s science and technology power in pursuit of strategic advantage’.51 France has been investing heavily in closing the AI gap with China and the United States, and recently undertook its first exercise in space warfare.52 Finally, Stoltenberg’s February 2021 ‘Food for Thought Paper’ identifies NATO’s ‘technological edge’ as a priority.53 NATO should seek to build a sustained political–military dialogue on the strategic implications of new technology in order to bolster its collective-defence posture and its dialogue with like-minded countries.