Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

2ac perm

Permutation do both – undertaking an intercommunal perspective incorporates the useful political programs of the alternative with the orientation and planning of the affirmative

Narayan 17 -- John Narayan (2017) Department of Sociology, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK The wages of whiteness in the absence of wages: racial capitalism, reactionary intercommunalism and the rise of Trumpism, Third World Quarterly, 38:11, 2482-2500, DOI: 10.1080/01436597.2017.1368012

Conclusion: dealing with the end of the wages of whiteness This article has attempted to retrieve Huey P. Newton’s seemingly forgotten theorisation of imperialism’s transition to reactionary intercommunalism, not only to achieve some form of epistemic justice, but also because Newton’s thought speaks urgently to our present. It has taken over 40 years for the contours of a truly global capitalism to match up with Newton’s proto-theorisation of neo-liberal globalisation. But Newton’s theoretical prescience also centres on his appreciation of how such changes would be refracted through issues of race and whiteness that underpin the US state and its economy. In conclusion, I want to reflect on Newton’s thought and why we should return to his ideas to understand the era of Trumpism. It is my contention that Newton’s reflection on what the future may hold under reactionary intercommunalism may in fact be words about our present. In a 1972 discussion with sociologists Franz Schurmann and Alberto Martinelli, Newton outlined his theory of intercommunalism and the future’s likely political trajectory. Newton’s main point to Schurmann and Martinelli was that the changes associated with reactionary intercommunalism, chiefly its technological displacement of jobs and the global spread of capitalist social relations, meant that Western imperialism’s wages of whiteness, where imperial conquest led to a bargain between capital and the white working and middle classes in the metropole, were effectively over. Indeed, as Newton told an audience at Yale in 1971, he hoped white America would unite with ‘those people who are already unemployable’, but whether this did or didn’t happen that ‘material existence will have changed. The proletarian will become the lumpen proletarian’.60 Newton’s interview with Schurmann and Martinelli saw him declare that either the white US population would come to terms with this reality, and embrace the objective class relations between themselves and the vast array of humanity, or they would start on a path towards world war three: The people here have to realize that they live at the expense of the world, and this includes the workers. Either the people will oppose the reactionary circle for survival, for peace, or else they will go into the third world war. So our basic problem is educating and organizing.61 Returning to Newton’s ruminations on the impossibly of resupplying the wages of whiteness highlights how dangerous the death of the wages of whiteness may actually be for us all today. Trumpism’s attempt to resupply the wages of whiteness through racism, nationalism and xenophobia, places humanity on a likely path towards war. Despite Trump’s claim that ‘jobs will return, incomes will rise and new factories will come rushing back to our shores’,62 Trumpism is unlikely to supply any jobs and material wages to its supporters because it is not designed or capable of doing so. Just as Du Bois highlighted at the start of the twentieth century that the wages of whiteness were designed by the elite to split class unity along racial lines, Trumpism’s wages of whiteness appear designed to split class unity for elite ends at the start of the twenty-first century. Trump’s economic plans, dubbed ‘Trumponomics’, essentially repackage neo-liberal ‘trickle-down’ policies with the promise of Keynesian stimulus. Trump has proposed massive infrastructure spending combined with huge tax cuts for the rich and corporations and further deregulation in the hope of generating investment and jobs. The 30-year track record of neo-liberalism has shown that these policies are unlikely to illicit investment in the economy and such a strategy seems incapable of addressing how technology, as Newton realised, will eliminate ever more jobs.63 As such, Trumpism will likely continue the processes of enriching elites and corporations at the expense of all members of the working and middle classes.64 This failure to supply the economic wages of whiteness will in turn likely be supplemented with the overtures to trade protectionism (Border Tax), racist and xenophobic polices such as (Muslim) travel bans, illegal migrant deportations, border wall building and military actions that aim to supply the psychological aspects of the wages of whiteness. This will simply be the supplying of the wages of whiteness in the absence of wages. There thus appears more chance that we shall see a race war in the US than any potential class struggle. However, the changes brought about by reactionary intercommunalism have also changed the nature of geo-politics and made such resurgent nationalism a more likely conduit for war on the international stage. The quest to remake the world in the American image, or rather in its interests, has enriched non-Western elites and empowered nations in the Global South in ways even Newton could not have foreseen. Although the ‘neo-liberalism with southern characteristics’ of the BRICS bloc does not yet mark an ideological and geo-political alternative to US and wider Western power, it does mark a world of increasing multi-polarity.65 What chance that a trade war or imperial proxy war induced by Trumpism could lead to what Newton called the third world war? Yet, Newton’s thought also offers us a vision of an alternative approach to dealing with the end of the wages of whiteness and perhaps herein lays the true value of returning to Newton in the age of Trumpism. Newton’s discussion with Schurmann and Martinelli revealed his frustration with the Western left’s fixation with the ‘factory as a phase that does not go through transformation’.66 In Newton’s eyes the left couldn’t simply repeat the fantasy of returning to the post-war settlement between labour and capital. Not only was such a position unachievable due to the changes induced by reactionary intercommunalism, but also because such a position failed to see how the post-war era of embedded liberalism was itself a racialised imperial formation. Newton argued against nostalgic pleas for national forms of socialism, which had been used to imperially split humanity across the colour-line, and for a transnational politics he called ‘Revolutionary intercommunalism’.67 Revolutionary intercommunalism functioned off the recognition of the interconnected nature of the global economy and the need to deliver equality and justice for the entirety of the world’s communities. Above all else, revolutionary intercommunalism rejected the idea that nationalist settlements, whether Black, white or socialist, were the pathways towards liberation. In light of reactionary intercommunalism’s global dimensions, Newton argued that only a global form of justice that would equally share the productivity and resource gains of technology would now suffice: In order for a revolution to occur in the United States you would have to have a redistribution of wealth not on a national or international level, but on an intercommunal level. Because how can we say that we have accomplished revolution if we redistribute the wealth just to people here in North America when the ruling circle itself is guilty of trespass de bonis asportatis. That is, they have taken away the goods of the people of the world, transported them to America and used them as their very own.68 Revolutionary intercommunalism saw the BPP create alliances with a plethora of social movements both within and beyond the US. These included the student-led anti-Vietnam War and Peace movements, Latino groups like the Young Lords Organisation and poor white American groups like the Young Patriots Organisation and ‘peoples of world’ pursuing nationhood, such the National Liberation Front in South Vietnam (NLF), the Mozambique Liberation Front (FRELIMO) and Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO). 69 The aim of revolutionary intercommunalism was not only to create a united front of oppressed peoples against global capitalism, but also to create alternative forms of life to the capitalist way of life. This ethos was exemplified in the BBP’s ‘survival programmes’, community-based programmes that were set-up and run by the Panthers and wider community to provide services such as free healthcare, free breakfasts for school children and free clothing for the Black community and other communities who had been excluded from the spoils of US capitalism. As Singh has suggested, the practices of the BPP’s survival programmes not only filled these gaps in welfare but also provided a ‘projection of sovereignty’ that rivalled the ‘reality principle’ of the US state.70 This entailed a practical deconstruction of the idea of state power (policing, education, welfare) that reimagined spaces and practices along new intercommunal lines of self-determination and democracy. Through attempting to disrupt class relations, racial segregation and gender roles, the BPP’s survival programmes also attempted to offer alternative ways of life, both institutionally and ideologically, to the racially divisive, class exploitative and gendered structures of capitalist society.71 The value of returning to Newton’s thought today thus lays not only with his appreciation of how reactionary intercommunalism would be refracted through issues of race and whiteness, but also with how Newton’s vision of revolutionary intercommunalism demands us to link the project of anti-imperialist solidarity with the creation of alternative intercommunal ways of life to capitalist society. This especially pertinent given that Trumpism’s critique of neo-liberal globalisation ironically shares elements of the left’s own social democratic critique of neo-liberal globalisation.72 Although violently disagreeing on the means, both Trumpism and social democracy aim towards the end of taming global capitalism through reasserting national controls (whether this is through racist approaches to immigration or raising taxes) and alleviating economic insecurity through job creation (whether this is through deregulation and tax cuts or increased regulation and government spending). Newton’s work on intercommunalism leads us to question the very categories of labour, nation, capital and democracy that underpin both Trumpism and contemporary social democratic politics. For example, Newton’s theory of intercommunalism makes it clear that we must question the linking of wage labour and income in an environment where technology eliminates vast sways of jobs and labour markets are racially discriminatory. Moreover, we must ask this question with a global rather than solely a national inflexion. Newton’s thought thus demands that we consider a new politics that would create new institutions and ideologies that could serve and liberate communities both within and beyond the boundaries of nation states. Returning to Newton’s theorisation of reactionary intercommunalism, and his conclusion that both white supremacy and nationally bounded socialism were incapable of dealing with the contradictions of global capital, thus implores us to pursue a politics of intercommunal revolution rather than mere national reform. This may sound idealistic as we encounter the re-emergence of racist populism in the US and wider Western world.73 However, Newton’s work reminds us that the contradictions of racial capitalism under the machinations of reactionary intercommunalism also offer the possibilities of hope as well as horror. Newton saw a chance for intercommunal solidarity and the creation of alternative forms of life because he believed the effects of the dwindling wages of whiteness now meant that the white populaces in the US were ‘more ready to fight’ than ever before. The key was to answer the questions ‘who shall he fight? Who is your enemy? Who is your friend?’ Newton challenged the left in the West ‘to show [that] the other unemployables are not the enemy’.74 In our contemporary moment these words, and the anti-racist and anti-imperialist politics they commit us to, seem as urgent as the time they were first spoken.

The perm represents “mature marx”- their indicts will reinforce theologic interpretations at the expense of scripture- apply epistemic modesty

ROBBINS, PhD Harvard, 13

(BRUCE, Old Dominion Foundation Professor in the Humanities, https://nplusonemag.com/issue-16/reviews/balibarism/)

AS A STUDENT OF ALTHUSSER IN THE 1960S, Balibar took to heart his master’s desire to detach Marxism from Hegel. Hegel was seen (a bit tendentiously) by Althusser and his disciples as a confident oracle of the End of History; and their aim was, through a close and even reverent reading of Marx’s texts, to expose a mature Marx who had been through an “epistemological rupture,” breaking with his early Hegelian faith, and who by the time he wrote Capital had embraced a more complex and open-ended model of history. History had to be interpreted the way Freud interpreted dreams — as motivated and structured, but with a quotient of randomness and openness to reinterpretation. Seeing history as analogous to dreams risked conceding that Marxism had something in common with wishful fantasy, but Althusser thought it made Marxism more scientific. In at least one sense it did: genuine science accepts the limits of its own knowledge. Balibar, not much interested in scientificity, was clearly enticed from the beginning by modesty about the limits of knowledge. Neither he nor Althusser put it this way, but their shared project might be described as a secularizing of Marxism. After Stalin, many thinkers were ready to abandon Marxism altogether. For those who wanted to save it — that was the grand but also defensive goal that Althusser announced to his students, Balibar among them, on the first day of the 1965 seminar that was to become Reading Capital — one option was to return to the founding texts of historical materialism and read them afresh, liberated from their decades of service to Party dogma. Like the Protestants of the Reformation, Marxists would get out from under the authority of the Church by appealing to the authority of Scripture. This of course would involve a resacralizing of Marx’s texts — something of an irony for a secularizing project. The secular always seems to need more secularizing. In this sense, Balibar’s series of studies from the 1980s (some of them collected in English under the title Masses, Classes and Ideas) was indeed secular and even detheologizing, a sort of Nietzschean–Rortyan experiment in thinking Marxism without its god-terms. For example, the concept of ideology went unmentioned in Marx’s Capital, Balibar observed, and this was because Capital had no need of it: if the fetishism of the commodity is working, it will do the job, mistakenly assigned to ideology, of making exploitation look like the breaks of the game. Balibar thus gently encouraged Marxists to make better use of their time than accusing others of false consciousness. Like ideology, the concept of the proletariat, so prominent in The Communist Manifesto, could also be jettisoned. According to the predictions of the mature Marx, the only class that would come to full political selfhood under the capitalist system is the bourgeoisie. The proletariat names a political potential that could well remain unfulfilled (as it has). This argument had the fortunate result of rendering unnecessary the proletariat’s predicted emergence as a self-conscious revolutionary subject; the usefulness of Marx’s analysis of capital could be demonstrated without it (as it has). Balibar was proposing in effect that Marx offered no providential assurance that things would work out in the end. This was Marxism without a Book of Revelation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.