Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No war—Iran and Israel are both risk averse, which limits likelihood of escalation

Miller, 15 – vice president for new initiatives and a distinguished scholar at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (Aaron David, 7/24. “Why War Isn’t Inevitable If Congress Rejects the Iran Nuclear Deal.” http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2015/07/24/why-war-isnt-inevitable-if-congress-rejects-iran-nuclear-deal/

Why go to war? The theory that conflict with Iran is inevitable rests on several highly arguable contentions. First is the assumption that Iran is willing to accelerate its nuclear program and to either break out or sneak out to a weapon and thus court a military response from Israel or the United States. The second big assumption is that Israel is just itching for an opportunity to unilaterally strike Iran with or without Washington’s approval. In the wake of a no vote by Congress, neither of these developments are certainties. Israel is implacably opposed to the deal, but Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is pretty risk-averse; he would have to think long and hard about launching strike in which Israel is operating at the margins of its capacity, particularly without a reason that would justify the severe international consequences.

And why would Iran want to provide such a reason as long as it could play the Security Council card and pocket the political and economic benefits that would flow from being cooperative? For Tehran, the smarter option in the wake of Congress blocking the accord would be to exploit the appetite for international investment and pick up as many chits as possible on the global stage by blaming the failure and missed opportunity on Washington. This isn’t a perfect outcome, but it’s a more compelling choice for Iran’s leadership than a headlong plunge into war. That course stands to bring Iran few benefits and many risks. Tehran is also aware that its ally Hezbollah is bogged down in Syria as part of Iran’s campaign to support Bashar al-Assad, which limits Tehran’s regional assets to use against Israel in the event of a military strike. If Congress blocks the nuclear agreement, the mullahs will take their time and consider all of Iran’s options. Courting a major strike from Israel and the U.S. isn’t necessarily one of them.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.