The neg oversimplifies feminist ir theory – the strict binary works to recreate the patriarchal hierarchy they seek to destroy
Stephan 14 (Rita, foreign affairs officer at the United States Department of State and a visiting researcher for at the Center for Contemporary Arab Studies at Georgetown University. “War and Gender Performance”. p. 5-7. International Feminist Journal of Politics. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14616742.2013.8 49969)
The question of incentives here certainly applies to some women who were rewarded for their consent. Complying with their gender roles made their evacuations safer and less traumatic. However, in most of the stories in this article, men and women fall along a spectrum between hero and victim, rather than entirely as one or the other. The protective masculine and vulnerable feminine model represents a broad view that sometimes abstracts the changes that are taking place on the global level. Patriarchy ought to be seen “not only as an arrangement of political institutions, but also, and perhaps even primarily, as a broadly understood value system that revolves around identity constructs which support and entrench gender-specific hierarchical visions of society” (Bleiker 2000, 32). Looking at the 2006 war from the micro level, I find that the binary relationship that international relations feminists claim in their model of patriarchal violence does not always apply, or applies only in a rigidly logical way. The stories in this study show that women, men and children were all victims of military aggression. However, in some cases, women were the only agents available to save the children; in other cases, representatives of the patriarchal order, such as fathers or fathers-in-law, were either left behind or uninvolved. While the men did protect the womenandchildren in some instances, women, who subscribed to their gender roles as mothers and wives, acted in instances when men were impotent to act, thus in a sense protecting the men also. While some would argue that these women’s performances lie outside the realm of gender norms, one could clearly see that such binary distinction is not possible.