Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The new security state attempts to inscribe bodies in debate with cold information, chilling them to degree zero where they are nothing more than recombinant flows of information

Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 80-83, October 2021, MG)

Machines to Bodies (M2B): Smart Bodies, Cold Data, and “Five Eyes”

Are smart bodies in a culture of cold data the probable future of technologies of mass surveillance? In response to the challenge of bodily materiality, with its hidden passions, secret dreams, and unexpected – and often unpredictable – actions, the new security state is rapidly moving towards the deployment of a new generation of smart bodies located on the always searchable smart grid of technologies of mass surveillance. Since machine readability is enhanced by biometric identifiers, the aim would be to populate the skin surface with an array of sensors for improved machine readability. For the moment, the transition to smart bodies equipped with electronic skin tattoos, locatable media, and prosthetics facilitating easy biometric tracking is marked by technical, and then political, challenges, as the new security state works to filter, archive, and tag the immense data oceans of global communication. It is in this context that there can be such dramatic political encounters between passionate defenders of individual privacy and proponents of the new security state interested in the total awareness provided by networked communication.

However, this period is probably only a temporary transitional one, since the implacable movement of surveillance technologies is towards forms of automated surveillance of smart bodies – machine-to-body communications (M2B) – that would quickly outstrip privacy concerns in favour of continuous flows of individual bodily telemetry: its location, moods, nervous physiology, heart rate, affective breakthroughs, and even medical emergencies. Taking a cue from the pervasive networks of smart grids that have been installed in many cities as part of managing energy consumption, smart bodies, like domestic homes before them, are visualized as inhabited cybernetic systems, high in information and low in energy, emitting streams of machine-readable data. For all intents and purposes, GPS-enabled smart homes are early avatars of the smart body – data tracking megaphones doubling as digital communication devices. From the perspective of technological futurists, there is nothing really to fear in the emergent reality of a smart future with bodies enmeshed in dense networks of tracking machines, since those very same bodies will likely also be equipped with counter-tracking prosthetics  – digital devices capable of quantifying the extent and intensity of data emissions between bodies and the surrounding environment of surveillance trackers. For example, the technological futurist Kevin Kelly has stated that “we want to have coveillance rather than surveillance” so that we can control who’s monitoring us and what they are monitoring.19 Some may argue that the human body, with all its complex inflections and unbounded mediations, will never really be reducible to a smart body circulating within a global smart grid, but that argument is countered by noting the present migration of surveillance technology towards a greater invisibility through miniaturization, breaking the skin barrier with digital devices functioning at the interface of biology, computation, and electronics, and, in fact, layering the body with data probes designed with the qualities of human skin itself – soft, malleable, bendable, fluid, elastic, tough.

A future emerges, then, of cold information  – diffuse, circulating, commutative, dissuasive – with bodies chilled to the degree zero of recombinant flows of information. Morphologically, information has always been hygienic in its coldness, always ready to perform spectacular sign switches between metaphor and metonymy. What this coldness means for understanding technologies of mass surveillance is that the future of smart bodies will probably be neither the dystopia of total information dominance on the part of powerful interests nor the utopia of free-flowing communication by complicated individuals, but something else, namely friction between these warring impulses in the cynical sign system that is information culture. Sometimes flows of cold information will be contested locally, whether in debates concerning the policing of information and free speech in urban protests, environmental contestations, and Indigenous blockades of railroads, pipelines, and highways in isolated areas off-grid; or in the abbreviated attention span of mass media. At other times, information wars will be generalized across the planet, with lines of friction leaping beyond the boundaries of specific states in order to be inscribed in larger debates concerning issues related to surveillance and privacy, collective modulations of soft control and individual autonomy, which move at the process speed of instant, global connectivity across networked culture. Here, the essence of cold information lies in the friction, the fracture, the instant reversal of the always doubled sign of information.

Defining this essence brings us to the meaning of surveillance in the epoch of information as a flickering signifier, that point where all the referents are always capable of performing instant sign switches from villain to saviour, from active agents of generalized public scrutiny to passive victims of destructive overexposure. Wouldn’t this mean, though, that, in a culture of cold information, surveillance technologies must themselves also become flickering signifiers, simultaneously both predator and victim? Indications that this duality is the case are everywhere today. For example, the primary apparatus of contemporary mass surveillance in the West is performed by a previously undisclosed collaboration of state intelligence agencies, appropriately titled “Five Eyes,” because it coordinates sophisticated intelligence signals among the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. Based on intelligence sharing agreements developed during the Second World War, and strikingly similar in its pattern of operation to the later “Condor” program that was created by several Latin American governments during the dark years of the “dirty wars,” Five Eyes coordinates flows of information acquired by upstream and downstream surveillance among the governments involved. Currently justified by political rhetoric framing the War on Terror and consequently authorized by law or, at least, by loopholes in existing law, Five Eyes is network conscious, geographically specific, and action oriented. It tracks information, acquires individual targets, assembles complex profiles of targeted individuals, and acquires massive quantities of metadata limited only by the rule of the “three hops” – tracking, that is, email messages, cell phone calls, or fibre optic communication across the three hops of the originating message, the recipient, and networks of individuals and groups communicating with anyone and at any time in the first two hops. While Five Eyes has attracted widespread criticism from privacy advocates for its relentless attempts to establish an apparatus of total information awareness, it should be kept in mind that the original and continuing motivation of this secret apparatus of control has about it the sensibility of an injured victim – bunkered states living in really existent existential, even psychic, fear of having their bounded borders pierced, broken, and invaded by actual terrorists or by phantasmatically threatening breaches of their sovereign boundaries by “illegal” immigrants, the nomadic, the refugee, and the planetary dispossessed. For example, as recently as spring 2020, CSIS, Canada’s intelligence contribution to the Five Eyes program, publicly protested that proposed improvements to Canada’s privacy legislation would seriously hinder CSIS’s ability to gather intelligence in the national security interest. A perfect fusion of aggressive surveillance and injured sensibility, Five Eyes constitutes, in the end, a flickering signifier – a palpable sign of what is to come in the approaching culture of cold information and increasingly overexposed, smart bodies.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.