Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Instrumental activism causes a perverse fascination with new and more destructive modes of technological management, which can only result in the suicidal nihilism of artificial war

Kroker 4 [Arthur, Chair in Technology, Culture and Theory, Professor of Political Science, and the Director of the Pacific Centre for Technology and Culture (PACTAC) at the University of Victoria, The Will to Technology and the Culture of Nihilism: Heidegger, Nietzsche, and Marx, University of Toronto Press: Toronto, Buffalo, and London (2004), p. 5-10]

Suiciding Itself to Virtual Life It would be inaccurate to say that ours is merely a civilization of technological hubris. Nietzsche was more insightful. For him, we are a "gamble," a "going-across," a "glance," a "gathering storm." Or perhaps Jean-Francois Lyotard for whom we are an "incommensurability," an impossibility that cannot be unrealized because we are perhaps never capable of full self-consciousness. Whatever the case, it can never, and probably will never be said of us, that we have not worn the membrane of technology as our deepest primal, that the horizon of technology is not the gamble upon which we stake the meaning of life itself. While it is a matter of strict epistemological warfare between social constructionists and hypermoderns to make much of the cultural issues attendant upon the meaning of the "post" - post-society, post-culture, post-gender - I do not think that we have yet grasped deeply into the interstices of our thought just how graphically, how bleakly, we truly have become a culture of the post. I do not mean this lightly. When the United States used nuclear weapons on Japan it precipitated a threshold event of the greatest cultural magnitude. History literally ended. If by history we mean the traditional cultural understanding of history as an indeterminate sense of unfolding time, an open future never fully under human control, then that sense of history decisively ended in the bio-flash of Nagasaki and Hiroshima. And again, Lyotard was right, but perhaps not in the sense he would wish. Post-history has been "driftworks," an indeterminate and increasingly violent series of technological experiments on the horizon of existence itself: the acceleration of space under the sign of digital culture until space itself has been reduced to a "specious present," and the social engineering of time into a micro-managed prism of empty granularities. Is it possible, just possible, that what Nietzsche described as ressentiment, this furious reaction formation at our own distorted instincts, now makes a new appearance at an exclusively cultural level? Is the real meaning of post-history the cultural road stories of a civilization suiciding itself to virtual life? Just as nuclear warfare gutted history, so too genetic engineering vacates the body. Suddenly and unpredictably, a new master discourse under the triumphant sign of biology as destiny has installed itself as the epistemological lynchpin of a global alliance of the so-called life sciences and the life industries. Cloaking itself in the antiseptic, technical language of genetic engineering, hyping itself as a "bible of life," institutionalizing itself as the Human Genome Project, here promising a future medical cornucopia of gene therapy, there warning against the dysgenic effects of unmodified organisms, everywhere dreaming anew of the genetic perfectibility of the human body, the language of biology as destiny marks the appearance of what I call "third wave eugenics". Having successfully immunized itself from the overt fascism of the second-wave eugenics of National Socialism and once having distanced itself from an open affiliation with its Darwinian and Mendelian origins, third wave eugenics projects itself into the future as the spearhead of the will to technology. Nihilism today speaks the language of biology as destiny. The culture of third wave eugenics is only awakening to its possibilities. We are, I believe, entirely unprepared for this transformation. Culturally, it is as if we are living through the cultural trauma of two abrupt, and ethically unfathomable, shutdowns: the ending of a progressive sense of history and an indeterminate sense of time with the climactic events of WWII; and the ending of an understanding of the body as something more than its genetic code. We are the victims of two Manhattan projects: one resulting in the extermination of history, and the other in the cryptography of the body. Might not cultural trauma of this pervasiveness not also serve simultaneously as both a precondition for the seduction of genetic determinism and an anticipatory sign of its coming triumph? Viewed ethically, shouldn't such 'big science' as the Human Genome Project not also be considered in the psycho-ontological language of trauma: the certain outcome of a world culture that once committed to the language of technology as destiny now finds itself exhausted, fatigued, feeding on its own referentials, while all the while warming itself in the sun of technicity? Heidegger, Marx, and Nietzsche, then, as trauma theorists diagnosing in advance the cultural preconditions necessary for the triumph of the will to technology as well as its nihilistic fallout. Artificial War "I think that space, in and of itself, is going to be very quickly recognized as a fourth dimension of warfare." General Ronald R. Fogleman, USAF, Ret Not just artificial life, but also now artificial war. Consider, for example, the recent war in Afghanistan where in an epochal break with traditional military strategy, RQ-1 Predator Drones equipped with Hellfire antitank missiles were utilized both as stationary platforms for long-term optical surveillance and as remotely controlled missile launchers. Real-time proximity (surveillance of the caves of Afghanistan) combined with strategies enhancing virtual control (those video screens in Washington displaying action on the ground in a remote battlefield)-- this technological mediation of the hyper-modern technologies of the twenty-first century with medieval tribal warfare of the third-century--suddenly migrates war to the planetary, digital dimension for purposes of space-based information warfare. With this, the age of Artificial War has begun. In its manifesto for the future of cyber-war, Vision 2020, the newly created United States Space Command theorizes a future battlefield of "full spectrum dominance." Abandoning the earth-bound dimensions of land, sea air, USSPACECOM projects a new era of artificial war in which the battlefield occurs in the "4th dimension" of space. Befitting a "space-faring nation" such as the United States, third-dimensional warfare is surpassed by a vision of future war in which "battle managers" are, in essence, computerized editing systems running on automatic, absorbing fluctuating data fields concerning attacks and responses, monitoring satellite transmissions from 20,000 miles in deep space, sequencing missile launches, integrating "dominant maneuvers" in space with "precision engagement" on the ground, sea and air, providing "full-dimensional protection" to "core national assets" and focusing logistics" for a virtual battlefield that stretches into an indefinite future. As USSPACECOM theorizes: the control of the seas in defense of commercial economic interests and the war of the western lands in defense of the expansion of the American empire to the shores of California has now migrated to a war for the "control of space" befitting a "space-faring nation" like the United States, this spearhead of technology. Consequently, a future of artificial warfare in which space itself is weaponized. 4th Dimensional warfare is the technical language by which the American empire now projects itself into a future of Artificial War: a 4th Dimensional rhetoric of "global engagement," "full-force integration," "global partnerships," weaponized space stations, tracking satellites, reusable missile launchers, and on-line, real-time remotely controlled anti-missile systems. I emphasize this story because it is revelatory of the meaning of the will to technology. Here, technology is not only the chosen aim of technological instrumentality (weaponizing space), but also involves technologies of mythology (the well-rehearsed story of the unfolding American frontier where wagon trains evolve into Predator Drones, and sea-faring navies migrate into space-bound automated battlefield manager systems), technologies of thinking (the fourfold "tactics" of space war: dominant maneuver, precision engagement, full-dimensional protection, focused logistics), and technologies of (aggressive) judgment ("multinational corporations" are also listed in Vision 2020 as potential 'enemies' of USSPACECOM). More than futurist military doctrine for the 21st century, Vision 2020 represents the essence of the will to technology. Here, technology is both a space-faring means to the successful prosecution of artificial warfare and its sustaining ethical justification. The will to technology folds back on itself--a closed and self-validating universe of thinking, willing, judging, and destining--that brooks no earthly opposition because it is a will, and nothing else. As Nietzsche reflected in advance: "it is a will to nothingness." Or, as Hannah Arendt eloquently argues in her last book, The Life of the Mind, "the famous power of negation inherent in the Will and conceived as the motor of history (not only in Marx but also, by implication, already in Hegel) is an annihilating force that could just as well result in a process of annihilation as of Infinite Progress."[1] Could it be that the world-historical movement captured by the military logic of Vision 2020-- this command vision of America as the historical spearhead of the will to technology-- represents that which is probably unthinkable but consequently very plausible, a contemporary expression of the metaphysics of "not-being?" If "permanent annihilation" is the sustaining (military) creed of Vision 2020, then this also indicates that the world-historical movement, which it so powerfully strategizes, is driven onwards by the seduction of negation, another suicide note on the way to the weaponizing of space. Consequently, if the American novelist, Don DeLillo, can write so eloquently in his recent essay, "In the Ruins of the Future," that '(T)echnology is our fate, our truth" this also implies that in linking its fate with the "truth of technology," the United States, and by implication the culture of globalization, may have, however inadvertently, infected its deepest political logic with the will to nihilism. In the sometimes utopian, always militaristic, language of technological experimentalism, "Not-being" finally becomes a world historical project. Those who are only passive bystanders to the unfolding destiny of the contemporary American descendents of the Puritan founders can only look on with amazement coupled with distress as the "American project" embraces not only the weaponizing of space but also genetic experimentation with the question of evolution itself. While DeLillo goes on to say that (technology) "is what we mean when we call ourselves a superpower," his pragmatism sells short the point he really wants to make: namely, that by linking its fate, its truth, with the question of technology the United States has also enduringly enucleated itself within the larger historical, indeed if USSPACECOM is to be believed, post-historical, project of technology. Enucleated not as something other than the technological destiny which is its profession of faith, of truth, but enucleated in the more classical sense of the term, of being somehow interior to the unfolding destiny of the will to technology. The larger cultural consequence of this bold act of willing remains deeply enigmatic. In this case, is the will to technology an intensification of the pragmatic spirit upon which the American experiment was founded? Or has the will to technology, at the very moment of its historical self-realization, already reversed its course, becoming its own negation: Arendt's prophecy of "not-being" as a "process of annihilation." On the ultimate resolution of this question depends the American fate, the American truth, as the spearhead of technology. On the public evidence, what makes the American project truly distinct today is its enthusiastic abandonment of the pragmatic will for the uncharted metaphysical territory of "not-being." The will to the conquest of empty spatialization and the vivisectioning of the code of life itself has about it the negative energy of suicidal nihilism. Here, the language of "not-being"--the desiccating logic of what Heidegger memorably termed, "Nothingness nothings" as the historical form of the technological project of "permanent annihilation" --expresses itself vividly in two master commands: Space Command and Genetic Command. The first operates in the language of weaponized astrophysics where the curvature of space is manipulated for strategic purposes, and the other sequences the human genetic code itself. Thus, control of space is inextricably linked with control of time. The dynamic will to technology projects itself doubly in the macrophysics of a "space-faring nation" and the microphysics of a body-faring cellular biology. This is a collective demonstration of hubris that Greeks in the classical age would only admire, and then fear, for its (technical) audacity and stunning (metaphysical) innocence. Ironically, at the very instance that USSPACECOM projects an imperialist military future of "full spectrum dominance," 9/11 occurs and we are suddenly time-shifted into the age of viral terrorism. Similar to the incommensurability of technology itself where the reality of "permanent annihilation" is sometimes offset by other ways of thinking technology, the human imagination does not begin, cannot begin, with tactics of 'dominant maneuver' and 'precision engagement' and 'full-dimensional protection' and 'focussed logistics' but, with the terrorist side of fluid, earth-bound, real material warfare.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.