The will to technology is a doubled expression of hubris – it ends the human species and the cycle of life and death
Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 29-31, October 2021, MG)
On the surface, the rhetoric of this latest American revival movement is delivered in the deliberately arid form of technocratic ambition – an “Internet of Things,” the “quantified self,” “A Data-Driven Life” – but scratch the surface of the covering rhetoric and what springs to mind are all those unmistakable signs of the spirit of rapture. Everything is there: a theology of technology driven by an overwhelming conviction that the vicissitudes of embodied experience are subordinate to digital transcendence; the will to extend life either by uploading the human mind into its AI machinic successors or by passionate faith in the bornagain body of artificial DNA; the doctrine of data as a state of (codedriven) grace; and conversionary enthusiasm for the fully quantified life. While many different perspectives gather under the revival tent of technological rapture, one common thing remains: an abiding faith that technological society is quickly delivering us to a future inaugurated by a singularity event, that epochal time in which intelligent machines take command with promises of a mind merger with a data world that is fluid, mobile, relational, and indeterminate. Though sceptics standing outside the circle of technological rapture might be tempted to reduce its enthusiasm for data delirium to the larger figurations of the form of (technological) subjectivity necessary for the functioning of digital capitalism, that reduction would surely overlook the fact that the contemporary will to technology is itself driven by a more radical eschatological promise, namely that the will to data has about it the tangible scent of finally achieving what the project of science has always promised but never delivered – human relief from death, disease, and bodily decay. While Francis Bacon’s emblematic treatise Novum Organum may have been the first to so confidently link the project of science and the heretofore quixotic quest for immortality, it was left to a contemporary techno-utopian visionary, Raymond Kurzweil (The Singularity Is Near), to transform Bacon’s ontological ambition for science into a practical strategy for better – that is, extended – computational living.2 In Kurzweil’s promised land of blended reality, the sky is the limit, with traditional boundaries dissolving between nature and human nature, the material and the virtual, and the enduring vulnerability of the human body with its defining limits of illness and death finally transcended. Powered by advances in nanotechnology, artificial intelligence, and gene editing, the world as we have always known it will be in sudden eclipse, and all this change will take place under the rising sun of a technological ornucopia. As Kurzweil argues, “through the use of nanotechnology, we will be able to manufacture almost any physical product upon demand, world hunger and poverty will be solved, and pollution will vanish. Human existence will undergo a quantum leap in evolution. We will be able to live as long as we choose. The coming into being of such a world is, in essence, the Singularity.”3
At first glance, this vision is only the most recent expression of the Greek concept of hubris, the cautionary tale concerning the ineluctable balance between excessive pride of purpose and mythic punishment meted out by always observant gods. Adding complexity to this reinvocation of hubris as often-fatal overconfidence, that vision of singularity is, in actuality, a doubled expression of hubris. First, there is the sense of technological overconfidence involved in breaking beyond the traditional boundaries of the specifically human in order to speak of the new epoch of “man and machine,” that is, fully digitally interpolated subjects in which the specifically human merges with the extended nervous system of the cybernetic. Here, the merely human is replaced by the technologically enabled post-human as the fundamental precondition for the singularity. With the sovereign expression of technological post-humanism, the stage is set for the futurist release of all the pent-up excess of expressions of scientific determinism and technological fundamentalism that have been gathering momentum for some five centuries – transcending bodily limits, eradicating illness, ending poverty and hunger, and vanishing pollution. In its basics, this version of technological futurism, with its doubled sense of hubris and complicated alliance of recoded bodies, nanotechnology, genetic determinism, and artificial intelligence, is a creation myth – “the coming into being of such a world is, in essence, the Singularity.” With techno-futurism, we are literally present at a digital rewriting of the Book of Genesis with all that is implied in terms of (re)creating the body for smoother, and perhaps safer, passage through the often-turbulent event horizon surrounding the black hole of the singularity towards which (technological) society is plunging. While the DIY body may have the “Internet of Things” as its necessary digital infrastructure and the “quantified self” as its ideal expression, what drives it forward, animating its design and inspiring its constant creativity, is, in the end as in the beginning, the spectre of the coming singularity as its core creation myth. Curiously, in the same way that Heidegger once noted that the question of technology can never ever be understood technologically – that we must travel furthest from the dwelling place of technology to discover its essence4 – the concept of singularity, while evocative of the language of science and powered by digital devices, is something profoundly theological in its inception.
Given the sheer complexity of contemporary global society with its mixture of recidivist social movements, global climate change, fully unpredictable human desires, economic turbulence, and, of course, changing rhythms of bodily health and the many diseases of the aged and the sick, Kurzweil’s vision is startling, less so for its naivety than for its feverish embrace of an approaching technological state of bliss – transcendent, teleological, and terminal. His vision is transcendent because its overriding faith in machine intelligence, nanotechnology, and gene research is premised on the imperative of “overcoming our frail bodies with their limitations.” Here, unlike the Christian belief first articulated by St. Augustine in De Trinitate – with its division of the body into corruptible flesh and the perfect incorporeality of the state of grace – the newest of all the singularities is intended to lead to a new heaven of computation. It’s teleological because this vision of the new singularity invests the will to technology with a sustaining, indeed inspiring, purpose: overcoming the unknown country of death. And it’s terminal because it is also a philosophy of end times, certainly the end of the human species as we have known it but also the end of easily distinguishable boundaries between the “biological and the mechanical, or between physical and virtual reality.”5 In Kurzweil’s vision, the nanotechnology revolution is, in fact, revolutionary precisely because it will facilitate the creative construction of new bodies and technologically enhanced minds for life beyond the current “limitations of biology.”6 It is the end, therefore, of the biological body as we have known it and the beginning of something very novel: the merger of natural biology with its surrounding environment of technologies of the post-biological – artificial intelligence, nanotechnology, molecular science, and neurobots. As to be expected, in return for the sacrifice of a natural biological cycle of life and death, the creation myth framing technological rapture has promises of its own to keep: a fully realized future of “living indefinitely” with nanobots streaming “through the bloodstream in our bodies and brains,” telepathy in the form of “wireless communication from one brain to another,” and improved “pattern recognition” by overcoming the inherent limitations of natural cognitive evolution in favour of “brain implants”7 marking the inception, then triumph, of “nonbiological intelligence.” In effect, the vision of technological rapture is conceived as a marvellous, ready-made (AI) toolbox for constructing DIY bodies.