Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Framework is equivalent to Robot Prison Guards – monitoring debaters for outward psychic rebellions that break the norm and responding with rage, psychic violence, and exclusion

Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Page 129, October 2021, MG)

Quickly migrating beyond the use of robots to physically guard prisoners, this prototype project represents that moment when robots first began to evolve beyond their purely mechanical function as prison guards to the more complex task of carrying out psychiatric assessments of the behavioural patterns of prison inmates. While it could be expected that robots would first enter prisons in the traditional roles of surveillance and control, the three robots involved in the demonstration project have a very different task: namely, to mingle among a captive population as only a five-foot robot can do and, while “looking more friendly to the inmates,” conduct an active search for signs of suicidal and violent behaviour. It’s not so much, then, a demonstration concerning the feasibility of using robots in prison environments but actually an experiment with very general applications for perfecting an operating system allowing robots to conduct complex psychiatric examinations of prisoners. At this point, we move beyond cinematic images of prisons of the future with robotic guards in towers carefully monitoring prison populations to that moment when technology actively penetrates the human psyche in search of “risky behaviour.” Here, robots are no longer mechanical devices, but artificial psychiatrists equipped with 3D vision, motion detection, and programmed operating systems, all aimed at discerning visible signs of melancholy, rage, despair, desperation, fatigue, and hopelessness. While it is not evident from media reports how robots are to fulfil complex psychiatric examinations – other than the mention of the demonstration robots monitoring abrupt changes in the behaviour of individual prisoners – the intention is clear: for prison guard robots to cross the boundary between surveillance from the outside of captive bodies to internal explorations of psychic behaviour. Guided by a prescriptive doctrine concerning the parameters of “risky behaviour,” what is really being tested here is robots as avatars of the new normal, conducting frequent visual examinations of a chosen, and necessarily captive, population in order to determine which bodies fall inside and outside of the normative intelligibility determined by the artificially defined ethics of “risky behaviour.” In this case, it is the responsibility of those bodies placed under surveillance to provide no outward signs of either visible dissent (violence) or refusal of the state’s power over life (suicide).

While at first glance it might seem that guard robots are not programmed with levels of artificial intelligence and, perhaps, artificial affectivity necessary to detect otherwise invisible signs of powerful emotions internal to the psychic life of prisoners, what may be brought into political presence here is an entirely new conception concerning how power will operate in the robotic future: not so much the great referentials of power over death, or even power over life, but power over visible expressions of human affectivity – a form of robotic control that assumes the psyche is not a form of internal being but a kind of external doing; that is, the psyche is not something we have but something we do. In this scenario, what is important about the human psyche for purposes of the society of control is less the complexities of hidden intentions – the cultural acedia associated with feelings of melancholy, resentments that activate rage, total powerlessness that motivates despair – than those visible, outward manifestations of the rebellious psyche, that moment when the bodily psyche moves from the long, silent gestation of hidden intentionality to overt declarations of its intention to act, whether through violence or suicide. At that point, at least according to this prototype demonstration, robot guards will be waiting along the watchtower of the society of control, quickly targeting immanent signs of psychic rebellions against the order of normative intelligibility, relaying warnings to central command, all the while standing by for further instructions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.