Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Procedural constraints preclude authentic learning

Waghid 14 [Pedagogy Out of Bounds: Untamed Variations of a Democratic Future, Yusef Waghid, Stellenbosch University, Matieland, South Africa, 2014, ebook, EDUCATIONAL FUTURES, RETHINKING THEORY AND PRACTICE, Volume 63, p. 59-63]

For Greene, authentic learning has the task of arousing students’ imagination, which ‘allows us to break with the taken for granted, to set aside familiar distinctions and definitions’ (1995, p. 3). When students are provoked to use their imagination they are ‘stirred to reach out on their own initiatives’ (Greene, 1995, p. 5). The point about authentic learning is that it is considered as releasing the imagination of students with the intention to cultivate ‘a community always in the making – the community that may someday be called a democracy’ (Greene, 1995, p. 6). In other words, the emphasis Greene places on positive freedom as a condition for authentic learning is quite obvious in the sense that students are encouraged to break the chain of causes and effects, of probabilities in which they usually find themselves entangled, and to come to be themselves. In other words, authentic learning involves students taking initiative and looking at things as if they could be otherwise, as has been mentioned previously in this book (Greene, 1995, p. 16). So, tapping into imagination as a way of enacting their positive freedom, students ‘become able to break with what is supposedly fixed and finished, objectively and independently real. It is to see beyond ... and to carve out new orders in experience ... to glimpse what might be, to form notions of what should be and what is not yet (Greene, 1995, p. 19). Consequently, authentic learning always reaches beyond itself towards a completeness that can never be attained. As aptly stated by Greene (1995, p. 28), releasing students’ imagination ‘is not to resolve, not to point the way, not to improve. It is to awaken, to disclose the ordinarily unseen, unheard, and unexpected’. This makes authentic learning a perpetual ‘narrative in the making’ (Greene, 1995, p. 5) – a democratically educative experience ‘that is always in the making’ (Greene, 1995, p. 39). It is for the latter reason that authentic (positive) learning is concomitantly linked to a democratic education in becoming, where ‘[n]o one can predict precisely the common world of possibility we will grow to [co]inhabit, nor can we absolutely justify one kind of community over another’ (Greene, 1995, p. 167) – that is, pedagogical encounters remain out of bounds. A democratic community of possibility in which individuals co-exist, says Greene, is one that embraces pluralism and does ‘not fly apart in violence and disorder’ (1995, p. 167). Such a community of possibility engages individuals to ‘speak with others as eloquently and passionately as ... [they] can about justice and caring and love and trust’ (Greene, 1995, p. 167). In a way, Greene’s call for a democratic community of possibility – a democratic community in becoming – intimates that teachers and students become more responsive to societal injustices, such as people being subjected to insecurity as a result of crime and violence; those suffering under corrupt governments and dictatorships; and others stunned by lives in refugee camps. Therefore, teachers ‘need to be attentive and vigilant if ... [they] are to open texts and spaces, [and] if ... [they] are to provoke the young [students] to be free’ (Greene, 1995, p. 121). Greene places vigilance at the centre of the concept of authentic learning and suggests some interesting distinctions that further expand the concept. Authentic learning therefore gains a new meaning that perhaps is beyond current human understandings if thought of in relation to vigilance. In the first instance, to be vigilant is ‘to awaken’ in students an awareness of the ‘ordinarily unseen, unheard, and unexpected’ (Greene, 1995, p. 28). To be vigilant is to be cautious and suspicious, yet attentive and open to something different and new. This view of vigilance is corroborated by Applebaum (2013, p. 19), who states that vigilance ‘involves listening not simply to confirm what is already known but listening to hear something new ...’. More importantly, vigilance implies being able to listen to the voices of the marginalised when they suffer injustices – that is, vigilance insists that teachers and students show their ‘outrage at injustices’ (Greene, 1995, p. 42). In this way, vigilance does not only involve listening to what is beyond recognition, but also that teachers and students remain in discomfort about the injustices and ‘identify moments where the new can emerge’ (Applebaum, 2013, p. 34) – that is, where new authentic learning can occur. Such a notion of vigilance intimates the possibility that students take an ethical and political stand. And when students act ethically and politically they listen with an openness so that there is always more to learn – they are stirred ‘to wide-awakeness, to imaginative action, and to renewed consciousness of possibility’ (Greene, 1995, p. 43). When vigilance interrupts the minds of students they become ‘conscious’ – that is, pursue a kind of thinking that always involves a risk, a venture into the unknown, and thus become open to new ways of looking at things, what Greene refers to as ‘the making of a democratic community’ (Greene, 1998, p. 126). A potent example of authentic learning in which vigilance is at play, and of the notion of a democratic community in becoming, is poignantly illustrated in the film In the land of blood and honey , directed by Angelina Jolie in 2011. Against the backdrop of the Bosnian war in the 1990s, when Serbs committed atrocious genocidal acts against Bosniaks (Bosnian Muslims and Croats), Danijel, a soldier fighting for the Serbs, falls in love with Ajla, a Muslim. The romantic relationship soon garnered the dissatisfaction of Danijel’s ruthless father – a Yugoslav People’s Army general, and Danijel and Ajla were confronted with the unfamiliar, the unexplored, and the unexpected. Ajla, once used as a human shield by Serbs against resistant fighters, also witnessed the genocidal killings and sniper assassinations, and the torturous rapes of women (including herself) in prison camps. Danijel, although in many ways sympathetic towards Bosniak killings as a consequence of his love for a Muslim, could not look beyond his parochialism towards pluralism and accept that every person had a legitimate right to life, irrespective of one’s hatred for them. Only when he himself eventually killed Ajla did he realise the senselessness of the Bosnian war and surrender to the United Nations forces as a criminal of war. Now for Danijel to have acted vigilantly and with the human freedom to enact justice towards those whom he disliked would have harnessed his learning in an authentic way. It is not that he did not learn from his dogmatic blindness and prejudice towards unjust Serbian atrocities. Of course he did, otherwise he would not have acted unjustly. However, such learning is frivolous or useless, as he acted freely under coercion from his father’s external influence and the suspicion he harboured towards the Bosniaks, who made an attempt on his life by bombing a church that he attended. What Danijel failed to do, unlike Ajla, was to have ventured into the unfamiliar, the improbable, where there always was the possibility to think differently about his situation. Ajla knew that her love affair with Danijel upset the Bosniaks, yet she did not let the hatred of the Bosniaks blind her to recognise even her torturers’ (Serbs) right to existence. Unlike Danijel, Ajla was prepared to embark on a new beginning (with Danijel), in which they could have opened themselves up to the possibility of human co-existence by writing the texts of their democratic community in becoming. If a democratic community in becoming provides the space in which human action is disclosed in potentially unexpected and unpredictable ways, it makes sense to bring into the discussion Danjel’s predicament after he killed Ajla. If Danijel wanted to reverse his act of having killed Ajla – the one he loved – he would have had to consider two things: to seek the forgiveness of Ajla’s community, and to promise not to repeat his acts of violence towards other Bosniaks. Therefore he gave himself up as a war criminal. In other words, forgiving and promising are never enacted in solitude or isolation, but rather, as stated by Hannah Arendt (1998, p. 237), in the ‘public realm through the presence of others ... for no one can forgive himself and no one can feel bound by a promise made only to himself ...’. By implication, for human freedom to ensure rebeginnings it has to embark on action informed by forgiveness and making promises. Forgiveness implies the unexpected public acknowledgement of one’s act of evil (even if possible, just retribution might ensue), considering that one would be unable to undo the past, whereas promising implies committing oneself in the presence of others to put an end to something, such as heinous crimes that would go on endlessly if there were no interference. In the words of Arendt, ‘only through this constant mutual release [of forgiving and promising] from what they do can [wo]men remain free agents, only by constant willingness to change their minds and start again can they be trusted with so great a power as that, to begin something new’ (Arendt, 1998, p. 240). The issue of forgiveness and making promises not to repeat unjust and undesirable human action has implications for authentic learning. Firstly, teachers and students always act in community. They are dependent on one another ‘without intimacy and without closeness’ in that they treat one another with respect, irrespective of the distance that the space of the world puts between them (Arendt, 1998, p. 243). If students were to be guilty of committing an unexpected and undesirable act – such as bullying another student, abusing drugs, or threatening a teacher – there is always the possibility that their transgressions will be subjected to the correctives of forgiveness and making promises. Condemnation and exclusion perhaps would not be possible, as forgiveness and making promises will engender possibilities to begin anew. A common example in South African schools is the rising incidence of pregnancies in teenage girls. The girls, upon informing the school of their pregnancy, often find themselves in a situation where their continuing attendance of school becomes extremely problematised by unsupportive school structures, perhaps even judgemental teachers, and they would encounter great difficulty in re-accessing the school after they have given birth. In many respects, their appeals for compassion and forgiveness either to their schools or their respective communities are met by exclusion, rather than forgiveness and acceptance. Secondly, making and keeping promises has the potential to undermine the spurious condition of sovereignty (Arendt, 1998, p. 245). In fact, making promises in the presence of others binds a person in a non-sovereign way to others and, for once, teachers’ views might not be considered as the sovereign and predicable calculations in pedagogical encounters. Making promises has some connection with the inability of individuals just to rely on themselves ‘as isolated islands of certainty’ (Arendt, 1998, p. 244). Rather, by making and keeping promises, teachers and students are connected in a non-sovereign way, so that the mastery and predictability of human action becomes self-defeating. There will always be more to learn and it would be impossible for teachers and students to remain ‘unique [sovereign] masters of what they do’ (Arendt, 1998, p. 244). Thirdly, human action that takes the risk to forgive and be forgiven should make any pedagogical encounter concerned with the possibility ‘to start anew ... in an ever-recurring cycle of becoming’ (Arendt, 1998, p. 246). This means that an authentic pedagogical encounter is always an interruption and a beginning of something new, especially in the light of human unpredictability and unreliability in a world marred by conflict, transgressions and suffering. The point about authentic learning in a positively free manner, unconstrained by the sovereignty of the other, is the fact that learning has no end and that what is to be learned will always be strange to the one who learns otherwise, learning will have reached its becoming. Authentic learning in becoming is always open to the new, the unexpected, the strange – a matter of retaining the un-bounded and strangeness of both teaching and learning. Authentic learning, therefore, includes being confronted with incidents of bullying, discrimination, teenage pregnancies, teenage suicide and homophobia – since these are all constitutive of our societal condition and cannot be wished away. Authentic learning requires of teachers to be willing to deal with the aforementioned in an open and unbiased fashion so that what emerges are forms of engagement that move towards recognition of otherness and PEDAGOGY AND DIALECTIC OF FREEDOM 63 forgiveness of transgressions. It is to a discussion of teaching as strangeness that I now turn. TEACHING AND STRANGENESS Authentic learning, as has been argued for thus far, has the best chance of being realised if teachers in pedagogical encounters are attentive and vigilant, provoking students to ethically and politically open up the texts of their lived experiences. Such pedagogical encounters would invariably remain open to the unfamiliar, the unpredictable, the unexpected – that is, the possibility of rebeginnings would be enhanced through such democratic spaces in which nothing remains certain and where there always is the possibility to begin anew. In this way, learning would be authentic and informed by positive human freedom. Such an account of authentic learning invariably depends on a particular way of teaching, which Greene suggests should be associated with strangeness (1995, p. 92). The teacher as stranger enacts her rupture as a way of finding herself in relation to others (her students) as she cultivates a pedagogical encounter. A teacher does not arrogate students, but comes to experience students through the eyes of a stranger in order ‘to see’ the unfamiliar, the unheard of (Greene, 1995, p. 92). In a way, teachers as strangers suspend both what they desire to see and try to control students’ desire. As aptly stated by Jo Anne Pagano (1998, p. 260): Most students come to the texts we teach as strangers. Greene teaches us that we must also come to those same texts as strangers, even though the syllabus is ours and filled with our questions, loaded with our desires. To teach our students to read so as to teach [positive] freedom and to choose freedom of humane action, we need to open landscapes to admit their questions, to change the landscape by honoring the identities they bring to the series of indentifications they will make.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.