Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Trying to overcome capital outside of the cybernetic sphere is rooted in the language of technicity and the will to technology – either the alt fails or the perm solves

Kroker 4 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, “THE WILL TO TECHNOLOGY AND THE CULTURE OF NIHILISM: HEIDEGGER, NIETZSCHE, AND MARX”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 145-147, March 2004, MG)

For Capital, it’s bitter irony. The emergence of the will to virtuality out of the economic disguise of the circuit of circulation implies not only that labour is factored out of (Capitalist) production, but Capital itself now is factored out of (virtual) reproduction. The cycle of history, with its stories replete of the rise and fall of all the dominant signs – power, war, labour, Capital, sex – breaks with the ossified structures of modernist myth, setting in motion the latest historical play, that of virtuality to be the once and always hoped for unifier of the siren of history. However, to speak of virtuality and history in one breath, to see in the circuits of virtuality a terminus ad quem of historical indeterminacy, is already to escape the present dialectic of Capital and virtuality, to say that in the valorization of the value-form of Capital lie not only the origins of the will to virtuality, but the future as the metaphysics of technicity. To say this is impossible, because to speak of the overcoming of Capital in the language of technicity, to announce Marx’s famous ‘circuit of circulation’ for what it is, the basic code of the fully realized technological future, would be also to brush Heidegger against Marx, to speak, that is, of the hidden presence in Marx’s Capital of Heidegger’s will to technicity. But we all know that Marx was a prophet of the left and Heidegger a tombstone of the right, so this encircling, indeed this declension of the invisible Heidegger in the visible Marx, is not permitted. Unless, that is, the equally famous ‘forgetting’ in Heidegger’s ontology of being is not the withdrawal of the gods from the ‘desolation of the earth,’ but another more proximate forgetting: the withdrawal of the visible signs of Capitalist accumulation from the (virtual) circuit of circulation. Marx, then, as the precondition of Heidegger, and Heidegger as the epiphany of Marx: a historical incompossibility.

From the ‘Circuit of (Capitalist) Circulation’ to the Circulation of (Digital) Circuits

In circulation, the Capitalist and worker confront each other only as the vendors of commodities, but owing to the specific, opposed nature of the commodities they sell to each other, the worker necessarily enters the process of production as a component of the use-value, the real existence, of Capital, its existence as value. And this remains true even though that relationship only constitutes itself within the process of production, and the Capitalist, who exists only as a potential purchaser of labor, becomes a real Capitalist only when the worker, who can be turned into wage-labor only through the sale of his capacity for labor, really does submit to the commands of Capital. The functions fulfilled by the Capitalist are no more than the functions of Capital – viz. The valorization of value by absorbing living labor power – executed consciously and willingly.29

When capitalism finally breaks with the materiality of production, entering its metaphysical stage as a pure ‘value-form,’ then the classic Marxian model of the Capitalist ‘circuit of circulation’ gives way to the circulation of circuits. While the circuit of circulation is the basis of the original Capitalist model of production, the circuit of circulation is the new model of the virtual model of production. This is a predictable outcome of the Marxian model. Everywhere in Marx’s writings lurks the spectre of circulation. There is no Capitalist, only a ‘Capitalist function[ing] ... as personified Capital, Capital as a person, just as the worker is no more than labour personified.’30 Everything and everyone is a function of their relationship to the value-form of Capitalist circulation. No autonomous labour, only labour valorized as use-value; no independent Capitalist, only the bourgeoisie valorized as a command function for the extraction of surplus value from living labour power; no terminal production, only production as a twofold sign of the beginning and ending of the circuit of Capitalist circulation; and certainly no autonomous processes of consumption, exchange, and distribution, only a general circuit of circulation that requires for its growth that the (economic) phases of production, consumption, distribution, and exchange align with one another in that spectacular circular flow, that speed and magnitude of circulation, that valorization of the pure valueform of Capitalism. What was previously the fate of the individual Capitalist – his reduction to ‘Capital personified’ – and the destiny of the worker – ‘use-value’ submitting to the ‘commands of Capital’ – quickly becomes the ruling axiomatic of virtual capitalism. Pure circulation, pure speed, pure value-form, pure technicity.

Indeed, if Marx could speak so hauntingly in Capital of the relationship between labour and capital as that of ‘animals and machines,’ perhaps that is because his image of the circuit of capitalist circulation is deeply biological. Capital, then, as an extended biogenetic description of the original, governing cellular matter of the DNA of Capitalism. In this case, Marx’s searing vision of workers as use-value objectified and Capitalists as Capitalism personified quickly generalizes into a biologi- cal theory of the circuit of circulation (production-exchange-distribution-consumption) as the original economic genome, not only for the historical development of the process of Capitalist production, but as the cellular material for mixing, splicing, recombining circuits of virtual clones. When not only labourers and Capitalists but also the circuit of circulation itself is violently thrown into circulation, when production is blasted apart by the globalization of manufacturing, when consumption is consumed by the circulation of signs, when exchange is digitally networked, when distribution is resequenced as a digital nervous system, then at that point we can speak of recombinant Capitalism as the destiny prefigured by Capital. Circuits of (virtual) consumption, circuits of (technical) production, circuits of (networked) distribution, circuits of (fast) exchange, all of which are simultaneously linked in a global model spearheaded by the circuit of virtual circulation, but all of which also immediately condense into the fourfold logic of the original circuit – production, consumption, distribution, exchange. Faithful to their cybernetic expression as the final value-form of advanced Capitalism and, consequently, the original prototype of virtual Capitalism, what matters are not the terminals of production, consumption, exchange, and distribution but the speed and magnitude of the process of circulation itself. Here, everything enters into circulation, and no one is allowed to refuse circulation; everything is circuited, no one can abandon the power of the circuit. Pure circulation then as the precondition and product of the virtual model of the circulation of circuits.

That’s the real effect of the technological process of production. Not simply a circuit of (Capitalist) production, but other circuits as well: circuits of production, circuits of consumption, circuits of distribution, circuits of exchange. All linked and overlapping, all autonomous and indeterminate in their origins.

The classic model of the circuit of circulation can give rise to a process of multiple circulation of circuits because the ‘value-form’ can be cloned, replicated, reproduced, re-circuited. No longer embedded in the facticity of material production, circulation is about speed, magnitude, and vectors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.