Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only the aff solves – focusing on the material form of capitalism ignores the virtual capitalism that structures the world today – Marx votes aff

Kroker 4 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, “THE WILL TO TECHNOLOGY AND THE CULTURE OF NIHILISM: HEIDEGGER, NIETZSCHE, AND MARX”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 142-145, March 2004, MG)

Or is something else at work in the contemporary era? Not simply the Capitalists’ ability to supervise and discipline labor,27 but just the opposite, technology’s ability to supervise and discipline Capital. Just as the Capitalist ‘will always seek to extend the duration and intensity of work,’ the will to virtuality necessitates the extension of the duration and intensity of Capital. The process of Capitalist production is not allowed to pause: consequently, the twenty-four-hour stock market pacing the celestial movements of the earth as it rotates around the sun, after-hours trading as a way of disturbing the rhythms of daytime trading, streamed capitalism as the final triumph of extensiveness over duration, of dead (technological) space over the time of living Capital.

Whereas in the industrial Capitalism of the twentieth century, the decisive political struggle was between labour and Capital, in the virtual Capitalism of the twenty-first century, the key historical contradiction lies between Capital and virtuality, between, that is, the will to Capitalist accumulation and the accumulative instincts of the will to virtuality.

In a fantastic intensification and abstraction of the historical drama between living labour and dead Capital charted in all its theoretical precision and economic granularity by Marx’s Capital, virtual Capitalism means, in its essentials, that in the twenty-first century Capital will, and does, occupy the same position as labour in the modern era. Just as the worker in relation to the Capitalist appropriation of surplus-value creates a ‘value alien’28 to himself, namely the valorization of the Capitalist process of production, so too Capital in relationship to virtuality also creates a value alien to itself. Incorporated into the digital process of production, at first as its necessary condition of historical development and later as its spectacular product, Capital now creates a surplus-value of virtuality, a speed and magnitude of digital technology that is not reducible for its explanation to the laws of Capital accumulation, and on behalf of which Capital is forced to serve as its historical incubator. While in industrial Capitalism, Capital in its fateful contestation with labour was the leading historical force, in virtual Capitalism, Capitalism declines into a residual historical category, a transitional state between the historically particular absorption of labour into the machinery of Capitalist accumulation and the global appropriation of Capitalism into a dynamic medium for the valorization of the technological process of (digital) production.

The Genealogy of Virtual Capitalism

Consequently, the great value of reading Marx’s Capital retrospectively, not from the vantage-point of the modern century on the cusp of the supposed post-Capitalist future but from the perspective of the muchvaunted digital future looking backwards, is that Marx provides both a brilliant genealogy of the birth of Capitalism and an equally insightful ‘futurology’ of its eclipse. Not, however, the eclipse of Capitalism by its ‘objective’ historical opponent – living labour – but the overcoming of Capitalism by its historical transformation into its pure (metaphysical) form, what Marx glimpsed from afar as the ‘circuit of circulation’ and what we now experience directly as the will to virtuality. Shedding the necessity of actual production, transcending the model of consump- tion, transforming distribution into networked vectors, and accelerating the language of exchange into mathematics of a ‘three-tiered digital architecture,’ the will to virtuality exists now as the pure form of the circuit of Capitalism that Marx first prophesied, and which in its first tentative steps announces itself, at first hesitatingly and then gathering strength from its global momentum, as the triumph of the will to virtuality.

Relentlessly focused on the political struggle of Capital and labour, socialization and privatization, collective consciousness and individual accumulation, Marx’s thought is primarily about labour, only secondarily about Capital, a matter of dialectics, not code. Thus the great irony. It is not to the dialectics of living labour and dead labour that we are compelled, finally and critically, to look for the sources of the overcoming of Capitalism, but to the metaphysics of Capitalism itself. Capitalism will not, and does not, survive its transformation from content to form, from its material-form to its value-form, from a circuit of production to a pure circuit of circulation. And why? Because Capitalism as a ‘circuit of circulation,’ in its contemporary representation as a pure form of valorization, is only apparently the value-form of Capital accumulation, but concretely the value-form of virtuality. At the heart of Marx’s Capital is less a haunting analysis of the dialectics of labour and Capital than a prophetic diagnosis of the hidden code of virtuality. Because that’s what Marx’s language of the ‘value-form’ of Capitalism really concerns, not Capital accumulation in its strict economic determination but the accumulative energies of the ‘circuit of circulation’ in its dynamic technological determination. Set in motion by the historical alibi of market-driven Capitalist accumulation, by the market-subordinated language of production, consumption, distribution, and exchange, the ‘circuit of circulation’ cannot, and does not, resist valorizing itself as its own value-form. Not the value-form of Capital which now occupies a position with respect to it previously assumed by (industrial) labour in relationship to Capital, namely use-value, but the value-form of virtuality. Once stripped of its use-value of Capital, Marx’s ‘circuit of circulation’ is the (technological) successor of Capitalism, the matrix of the will to virtuality. Ironically, just when everyone thought that Marx had been safely dispensed by historical events, in this period when the revolutionary fires of the early socialism of living labour-power have been withered away by the autocratic policies of official state socialism in the East and by official (trade) unionism in the West, at this precise moment the labyrinth of history reverses itself. The pages of Capital open to the section on the ‘circuit of circulation’ and we suddenly exit Marx’s theological narrative of (living) proletariat and (dead) Capital, falling into the future of the will to virtuality in its first appearance as the pure value-form of the circuit of circulation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.