Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alt is violent, doesn’t solve the aff, and doesn’t even solve itself

DeCook 20 (Julia R. DeCook PhD - Assistant Professor of Advocacy and Social Change in the School of Communication at Loyola University, “A [White] Cyborg’s Manifesto: the overwhelmingly Western ideology driving technofeminist theory”, Media Culture and Society, 28 September 2020, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0163443720957891, MG)

The concept of the cyborg has been fundamental in informing multiple fields – most notably, science and technology studies, women and gender studies, communication, postmodernism, digital culture, and more (Glazier, 2016). Haraway’s influence on these fields and even beyond them is irrefutable – however, the ‘universality’ of the cyborg is the issue at hand. The concept of the cyborg has continued to allow for the centering of whiteness and white identity and a techno-utopic worldview where technology is seen to be emancipatory, rather than oppressive. Indeed, many problems in our society in the 20th and 21st century in particular have all had technology thrown at them as a way of ‘fixing’ the issue – everything from climate change to racism to even pandemics (Benjamin, 2019; Engler, 2020; Eubanks, 2012; Huesemann and Huesemann, 2011). But time and time again, all of these ‘fixes’ have rather revealed the limits of technology in solving human problems – however, this has not stopped the slew of apps, devices, and other technological attempts in an attempt to do so, with no regard for the people behind the screens. In studying global digital cultures, Haraway’s notion of the cyborg is deeply Western in its theorization, and leaves behind those who do not exist in Western conceptions of personhood.

Further research on my part revealed that the love affair with A Cyborg Manifesto had been fraught earlier than I had imagined or seemed to perceive within my own graduate program and peers – in an essay from 2001, Maria Fernandez and Suhail Malik wrote, ‘Cyborg theory is mostly a self-serving sexying up of critical liberalism through great gadgetry and concept-busting movements in the technoscientific organization of living material and extended systems. Tie-dye T-shirts are swapped for leather deathpants and ethnic beads for prosthetic hardware in a desperate bid for contemporaneity’, (Fernandez and Malik, 2001). Even going so far to refer to the notion of the cyborg as a form of dogmatism, Fernandez and Malik note that the concept itself is hypocritical. Haraway did encourage the embrace of new technologies as a means of liberation – however, time and time again we have seen the ways that technology only continues to reify existing power structures, notably white supremacy and misogyny (Benjamin, 2019).

Cyborgs, then, useful as they are in conceptualizing a departure from traditional notions of identity, reify the very technological institutions which they were meant to disrupt – one that privileges certain bodies and identities and embodiments above others. Even the idea of the cyborg itself is borne out of a Western philosophy of selfhood and technology, further adding to its limits in dismantling categorical conceptions of the self. As Holland notes, we are not capable of living without categories of difference (Holland, 2012), and perhaps although the cyborg metaphor holds so much potential in breaking down our ideas of how the body – and the self – are constructed, this reconstruction of the embodied self through the metaphor of technology indeed has its limits. The purpose of this essay is not only a collection of my reflections, but serves to point out the limitations in conceptualizing cyborg as identity category and form of embodiment, and provides some directions in which we can begin to build upon and challenge the potential – and the potential of its limits – of the cyborg.

Potentials of its limits: who gets to be a cyborg?

The identity of cyborg is indeed a privileged one that invokes certain issues surrounding categorization and of embodiment. The cyborg body is one that is littered with not only epistemic violence in regard to the foundations on which it is grounded (a Western philosophy of the self as well as Western views of science and technology), but also in regard to class, race, sexuality, and ability. Technology and the desire to create and control machines is a realm dominated by Man, and thus technology itself may inherently be patriarchal (Wajcman, 2004), yet women have always been present and have indeed always had a presence in the design and use of these technologies as well. In particular, the rise of the networked society and the ability to shift and shape identity in cyberspace as well as the rise of the Internet of Things makes the idea of the cyborg woman more possible than ever before. However, is women’s participation in cyberspace and the technological sphere disruptive of the very basis on which technology is built? Or is it merely, as Audre Lorde puts it, a futile attempt to ‘dismantle the master’s house with the master’s tools’? (Lorde, 1984). How much potential do science, technology, and the cyborg identity really hold for women, for people of color, for the disabled, and for queer persons?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.