Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The libidinal economy has been cyberneticized – desire is now formulated through data and virtual capitalism which only the aff can solve

Kroker 4 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, “THE WILL TO TECHNOLOGY AND THE CULTURE OF NIHILISM: HEIDEGGER, NIETZSCHE, AND MARX”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 135-139, March 2004, MG)

Now, many working theorists have been this way before. Jean-François Lyotard recognized the death knell in the war machine of labour power, immediately calling for a recovery of a ‘libidinal economy,’23 a primitive pre-Marxism that would take labouring flesh back to an economy of pleasure and pain, an economy of sex and muscle, with the psychoanalytics of the suppressed id as the wild card in between. In The Mirror of Production, Jean Baudrillard was less utopian, more severe.24 In a twentieth-century reprise of that earlier meeting of French revolutionary thought of 1848 with the philosophy of the German Enlightenment, Jacobins with Hegel, the Paris Commune with German conservative reactionism, Baudrillard diagnosed Marx’s sleight of hand at the splitting of labour and labour-power for what it was: the foundations of a ‘structural law of value’25 in which Capitalism was to be cyberneticized in the form of the ruling axiomatic of signifier (use-value) and signified (exchange-value). More than Lyotard, who placed his theoretical bets on drawing out the differend in Marx’s theory of labour, Baudrillard wrote The Mirror of Production as Marx’s avenging angel, always insisting that the labour theory of value, far from inaugurating a new possibility of proletarian, let alone universal, emancipation, only functioned to install the ‘rational terrorism of the code’26 as the ruling order of the Capitalist axiomatic. For his fateful insights into the happy complicity of Marxism and Capitalism in sharing exactly the same episteme of the structural law of value, Baudrillard has suffered the usual fate: denounced everywhere as a cynic, this the most political of all thinkers, the most rigorously and naturally Marxist of all the post-Marxists, banished to an early twilight of thought on the (Parisian) margins.

If the twin gestures of Lyotard’s Libidinal Economy and Baudrillard’s The Mirror of Production cannot be assimilated into conventional Marxism, perhaps that is because Marx himself is the first post-Marxist, the first theorist, that is, who, unsettled by the ambiguities of identity and difference disguised here as the language of labour and labour-power, there as the supposedly warring poles of use-value and exchangevalue, wrote out his labour theory of value as a secret prolegomenon to a stage of Capitalism not yet existent. A code waiting for a material form, a theory of value awaiting its definite historical conditions of labour. Marx’s Capital, then, not so much an analysis of the definite conditions for the socialization of labour, although that too, but a secret history, written much in the tradition of the cabal, of a future Capitalism that would represent, as Marx theorizes in the third volume of Capital, the really existent history of ‘dead labour.’ It is, of course, around the corpse of Marx’s ‘dead labour’ that Libidinal Economy and The Mirror of Production circle, sometimes settling in the desert sands for a feeding frenzy of delirious theory, sometimes startled by the approach of passing armies of the night, taking flight, almost like a permanent evocation of ecstasy that was the Paris Commune and the slow decline of the German bourgeois restoration. Whether by way of Marx, who studiously wrote out the codes of the (industrial) Capitalist axiomatic only to write ‘dead labour’ as its epitaph and future, or by virtue of the chilling lightness of being of the French mind in the form of Lyotard and Baudrillard, who always and only begin with the last rites of dead labour, the spectre of post-labour haunts the Capitalist axiomatic.

And this is as it should be. Because whether expressed in the language of the ‘structural law of value’ or in terms of the ‘labour theory of value,’ Capitalism has never been about really existent labour, but always about the subordination of labour to the theory of value. Modern Capitalism, then, as an industrial semiotics. A critical point because it indicates that if contemporary Capitalism – digital Capitalism with its globalized markets and circular flows of Capital – can so easily escape the question of labour, can so swiftly disappear labour in the (domestic) form of ‘reductions in the work-place’ or in the (international) form of harvesting the world for perpetually new sources of cheap labour, that does not indicate that Capitalism has escaped the question of value. So then, two alternative theses. First, an epistemological thesis concerning the historical transition of the value-form of Capitalism: modern Capitalism might have been coded by the labour theory of value, but twenty-first-century Capitalism will be organized under the sign of the knowledge-theory of value. Digital Capitalism as networked knowledge, not a labour exchange. Certainly the safest (theoretical) route. It requires for its affirmation only an acceptance of the received wisdom that the epochal movement from industrial to cybernetic Capitalism, from modern Capitalism premised on the labour theory of value to postmodern Capitalism based on the knowledge theory of value, takes the form of a general historical movement to a knowledge-based society, with all its implications for the triumph of a class of networked specialists over traditional labour based in fading manufacturing and service sectors. Or, an opposing ontological thesis. A strange thesis concerning the ambiguity of labour and knowledge, that labouring activity is always knowledge-based activity, that the knowledge-based society has its deepest genealogical roots in the first worker who mastered the cybernetics of the machine age, and that if the fantastic knowledge of the worker was somehow lost sight of in the rush to the labour-theory of value that is not to say that it was not always labour-value, but knowledge-value, that was put into play by the Capitalist axiomatic. Out of this latter thesis, there emerges an enigmatic Marx. Not Marx as the nineteenth-century theorist of the approaching struggle of proletariat and bourgeoisie over the alternatively exploitative and emancipatory rites of the labour theory of value, but the spectre of Marx as the twenty-first-century theorist who, in diagnosing the objective historical conditions for labour-value, was in reality, a hundred and fifty years before its time, analysing the future-world of an advanced Capitalist society premised on the knowledge-theory of value. With the triumph of digital Capitalism, it may well be that the proletarianization of knowledge-work is only about to begin. If this is the case then Marx’s theory of class struggle may yet be awaiting its first moment of historical realization in a fateful struggle over the falling rate of (digital) profit and the exploitation of knowledge-value. From the exploitation of industrial labour to the struggle over knowledge-value, understanding the digital future is in its Marxian past.

From Dead Labour to Virtual Knowledge

Digital Capitalism is focused on the struggle over the emancipation of knowledge-value from embodied knowledge: its genealogy, its circulation as a generalized medium of cybernetic exchange, and its final appearance, in the residual form not of dead labour, but of dead knowledge.

In exactly the same way that labour functioned in industrial Capitalism both as an embodiment of use-value and as the dominant valueform of exchange-value, knowledge functions in digital Capitalism as a regulator of use-labour and exchange-labour. The dominant medium of exchange of digital Capitalism, knowledge breaks forever with its genealogical roots in individual consciousness, becoming instead the key value-form of cybernetic culture. Not living knowledge with its origins in individual subjectivity, embodied memory, or granulated knowledge of specific labour practices, but virtual knowledge as the dynamic medium of cybernetic culture.

Virtual Knowledge? That’s knowledge when it is first invested with the alien quality of value, when knowledge first ceases to a matter of individual consciousness, becoming instead a value-form, a circulating medium within whose deflationary and inflationary flows the world is cyberneticized, coded here with the binary logic of 0/1, there spoken of as a ‘digital nervous system.’ In the same way that labour was a measure of market value in modern Capitalism, knowledge is now a value of the measure of cyberneticity of digital Capitalism. It is around the question of knowledge-value that the fundamental class conflicts of digital Capitalism first organize, sometimes in the daily repressed form of the domination of human imagination by the performancerequirements of the virtual workplace, at other times by open rebellions of a rising tide of global counter-knowledge – environmentalism, collective labour rights, human rights – against the ‘free circulation’ of knowledge-value, which is to say of cybernetic Capital, so necessary for the continued functioned of digital Capitalism.

Far from abandoning the generic pattern of use-value and exchangevalue so endemic to the industrial mode of production, digital Capitalism perpetuates, even intensifies, this pattern, but at a higher level of abstraction and generality. Severing the bond of use-knowledge and individual subjectivity, digital Capitalism codes the question of useknowledge in its deepest interiority. What once may have accurately been described as psychological repression now takes the form of a gradual constriction of knowledge to a doubled code of use. On the one hand, knowledge that is instrumentally useful for the seamless insertion of human flesh into the high-performance speed of digital culture, and on the other, codes of use that are only apparently transgressive. Virtual knowledge and abuse knowledge, both contained as simultaneously explosive and domesticated tendencies in the same body. ‘Be serious’ and ‘be fake’ as the doubled sign of the knowledge-worker fully prepared for fast integration into the axiomatic of digital Capitalism. With instrumental (digital) knowledge, the body is plugged into the disciplinary network of careerism. With (cultural) abuse value, the body touches at a distance that which has been forgotten in the interfacing of human and machine flesh: libidinal pleasures, human memory, symbolic exchange. All these are simultaneously retrieved in a (cultural) way that immediately shuts down the anxiety of that which has been forgotten. It is ‘be fake’ culture: the appropriation of the original ecstasy spirit of rave culture by the corporate cultural axiomatic, the assimilation of sometimes ghetto, sometimes prison, rap culture for the ersatz entertainment of white suburban boys. Economically, useknowledge in the digital axiomatic binds human flesh to the digital nervous system. Culturally, digital use-knowledge is about the cynicism of forgetfulness.

Connectivity and forgetfulness: that is the paradoxical condition of virtual knowledge in the ruling capitalist axiomatic.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.