Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The pandemic flipped the script – the world has gone digital and their alt obscures settler colonial violence as well as making collective indigenous political struggle impossible absent the aff

Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 3-6, October 2021, MG)

Ironically, the winter months preceding the pandemic were just the opposite of isolation and social distancing. As part of a collective political struggle during the winter, many of us in British Columbia (BC) and elsewhere were involved in an active alliance with youth and elders involved in Indigenous resurgence and environmental activists to protest the armed occupation of Indigenous territories by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) in support of aggressive pipeline expansion. Like an epochal rip in the fabric of normal time and space, the provincial Parliament Buildings in Victoria, BC, were surrounded by a large Indigenous youth encampment, vibrant with the lighting of sacred fires, drumming, inspiring speeches, and a field of red dresses symbolizing murdered and missing Indigenous women, all carried out with a spirit of love, not violence, and with very courageous, very determined resolve on the part of the Indigenous youth and elders. I may have been teaching a seminar on the politics of race and power by day, with that haunting trilogy of Black Skin/White Masks, Red Skin/White Masks, and Brown Skin/ White Masks, 2 but by night many students were at the encampment in active solidarity with Indigenous youth, while others responded to frequent appeals during the night-time hours to come to the Legislature to help protect the Indigenous youth from possible police violence. What I witnessed over the winter was a glimpse into the possibility of a more just future traced out in all its social creativity, political courage, and profound ecological understanding by Indigenous thought and practice, and by strong alliances between Indigenous youth and many other young people conscious of the historical injustices of settler colonialism.

Then, the pandemic struck, with all its globalized panic fear and political cynicism. The darkness of the pandemic spring was just the opposite of the lightness of winter politics. Watching President Trump’s daily televised orgies of unconstrained narcissism and spasms of self-pity interspersed with mean-spirited scapegoating and cynical lies, all applauded by an enormous popular following howling the deep rage of their discontent, I was reminded of Deleuze and Guattari’s description of the continuing power of seductive appeals to the suicidal death drive of fascism.3 Here the political virus of right-wing populism, fuelled by panic fear and intense anxiety over the loss of jobs in the very real-life context for many people in the contemporary economy of work or starve, seeks to attach itself to the host cell of the television audience, releasing its genetic instructions and then waiting as the host cell reproduces the virus, whether expressed in the form of angry white male hysteria, scapegoating of Asians, border violence against asylum seekers, or studied popular silence concerning the cynical hijacking of relief funds by large corporations in the United States and by carbon-heavy energy companies in Canada.

The immediate consequences of viral contagion are dire: the eclipse of the social and the death of politics. And there’s something else as well – something now present as a faint intimation of things to come on the horizon of perception but then quickly inflating into a really existent reality. That reality is bio-fascism. The signs are everywhere. A friend from New York texts me to express her concern about how quickly people are eager to surrender civil liberties in the face of the pandemic. She points to the Wall Street Journal with its reports on the alliance between Apple and Google in perfecting contact tracing. It’s definitely a useful medical tool at the present moment, but after the pandemic, contact tracing is potentially a vast extension of the power of corporate surveillance over individual privacy for purposes of targeted relational advertising and, for the national security state, an emblematic breakthrough in power over the bodies of its citizens. Moralized first in the name of public health but later likely to be made permanent in the name of national security and virtual capitalism, contact tracing could well turn out to be a leading talisman of bio-fascism, with the workplace future likely to become an experiment in bio-politics – segregation of the population, temperature taking, sudden quarantines, rule by emergency decree. It’s all of these things, while the virtual capitalism of the ruling financial corporations views this moment as a convenient time to actualize what has already taken place – the shedding of unnecessary living labour once commerce has fully transitioned to remote labour in the age of the gig economy. Here, surging gun sales and panic hoarding are only symptomatic signs of the death of the social and the eclipse of politics, and all of this disintegration moves to the background music of the coming of age of Bob Dylan’s dirge, “Murder Most Fowl.”

Along with these developments is the assumption that one lasting consequence will be to suddenly accelerate technological tendencies that, until now, have remained masked in society. Certainly, the impact of social distancing and physical isolation has volatized the appeal, if not everyday necessity, of online services: for shopping, shipping, and surfing. It’s as if the social economy has suddenly split in two, with face-to-face businesses shuttered, slowed down with requirements for social distancing, or literally bio-pits for possible viral infections. The sudden silence in the streets of everyday business – stores, restaurants, malls, offices – contrasts sharply with the economic clamour in all the Amazons, Apples, and Googles of the digital world. Here, what appears to be happening is a decisive movement of the commodity form – the essence of all capitalist transactions – from the face-to-face market of the offline economy to the streamed services of the virtual economy. Following the doubled ideology of facilitation and command, virtual capitalism can so quickly triumph because, at this moment of very real social crisis, it easily facilitates the necessities and consumer choices of daily life, whether for food, services, banking, medicine, or entertainment. The question remains: after the pandemic, will what was so quickly and massively adopted by the population as a way of facilitating survival in the midst of social distancing become a new order of economy, less a matter of choice than a practical imperative imposed by the ruling virtual corporations? Will offices repopulate, or will business increasingly move essential services online? Will manufacturing plants seek to restore previous levels of employment, or will factories take advantage of this break in normal reality to speed up the transition long underway towards the automated future of labour promised by developments in artificial intelligence and robotics? In other words, what will be the future of life after the pandemic when the full adoption of technologies of the new real suddenly introduces us to a future as socially unexpected and unpredicted as it was technologically inevitable?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.