The will to technology controls the root cause of settler colonialism
Chew 15 (May Chew - Assistant Professor at the Mel Hoppenheim School of Cinema and Department of Art History at Concordia University, “BECKONING BODIES, MAKING SUBJECTS: INTERACTIVE AND IMMERSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN CANADIAN MUSEUMS, 1967-2014”, Queen’s University, 2015, https://qspace.library.queensu.ca/bitstream/handle/1974/12794/Chew_May_201503_PhD.pdf?sequence=1, MG)
This account provides an affective analogue to Innis’s political economy. Grant’s passage, like much of his other writing, reads as a threnody that reveals a resoundingly solipsistic moral imperative expressed through a consolidating settler perspective. This is also a fascinating passage for the way in which it elegiacally construes the forging of North America as an alienating “break” from “the old and the settled” and a necessary estrangement with “the extremes of the new land.” Because the land did not—and could never—belong to the new settlers, their identity had to be moulded in wilful opposition to the land, which was subsequently seen as needing to be continually conquered by the will of man. This inhospitable land thus serves an important symbolic function in the national imaginary; its wildness is that which needs to be perpetually (re)established, in order that it can provide an embryonic “wild” against which the will to technology (the rational-scientific imperative to tame and subjugate) can be emphasized through juxtaposition.
The outer world was not the only terrain fundamentally altered by the will to technology. A notion that comes up repeatedly through much of these thinkers' works is that technology fundamentally structures our psyches and determines the way we think and relate to others. For Grant, technology is neither a neutral nor separate entity with which we are able to choose how we wish to interact—an external "playground" or "orchard where we can always pick variegated fruit;" instead, technology "moulds us in what we are, not only at the heart of our animality in the propagation and continuance of our species, but in our actions and thoughts and imaginings" (Technology 15). While Grant was perhaps the most pessimistic in his understanding of the colonizing potential of technology, other thinkers shared his idea that technology had the force to shape consciousness for better or worse.
The Toronto School of Communication, an influential colloquium of interdisciplinary scholars at the University of Toronto whose core included Innis, McLuhan, and Eric Havelock, were joined by their intersecting interests on the ways that communication technologies shaped our psychology (de Kerckhove) as well as the “social and cultural infrastructure of societies” (Marchessault, Marshall 108). Innis, in as early as his 1923 history of the CPR, was already putting forth the idea that technology, far from being something externally located, was in fact "the necessary condition and lasting consequence of Canadian existence" (Kroker 94). While McLuhan is probably the most eminent of the group for his general postulations regarding the psychic/psychological impact of electronic technologies, he also traced the psychological impact resulting from the technological incursions into the landscape. In his posthumously published essay, "Canada and Counter-Environment," one of his rare undertakings of the Canadian question, McLuhan argues that the North American inheritance of the "war on empty wilderness" from its settler ancestors continues to shape the Canadian spirit. A century of life on the frontier produced a population defined by their antagonistic relations with the brutality of nature, relations that resulted in the forging of a particular type in whom was necessitated “initiative amidst solitude” (75). “Like Wordsworth and Thoreau,” McLuhan further states, "North Americans spend their time scanning the environmental mystery, taking spins in the country instead of spinning thoughts at home" (79). What we can glean from these theorists is that Canadians are invariably marked—in body and psyche—by the technologically conquest of the land. The colonization of the Indigenous inhabitants of this land, meanwhile, was not a matter that elicited equivalent consideration.
Aside from determining external and internal landscapes, technology has also come to be the often invisible lens through which Canadians see the "character" of the nation as well as each other. As Arthur Kroker argues, "Canadian identity is, and always has been, fully integral to the question of technology" (12). It is important to think about the functions served by the demonstration of Canadian identity through technology. Technological mediation allows the articulation not only of romantic settler-colonial attachment to idyllic landscapes, but also a determined will that is forged from the direct confrontation with the wild. This is a fortitude which conceives its own survival as indelibly linked to an overcoming of the landscape and its perilous indeterminacy. We can see this in, for example, Grant's assertion that the "almost indomitable" land incites a certain kind of (liberal) subject and societal character; "[t]he intense seasons of the continental heartland needed a people who whatever else were not flaccid. And these people not only forced commodities from the land, but built public and private institutions of freedom and flexibility and endurance" (24). Canadian myths of origin centre not merely on the wildness of the landscape in and for itself; rather, wildness serves as the verdant and receptive ground upon which to emphasize the exercise of over-determined technological will