Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

RWG – AT: Space Col

At best, colonization takes centuries – at worst, it causes conflict.

Deudney ’20 [Daniel; Associate Professor of Political Science at Johns Hopkins University, PhD in political science from Princeton University, MPA in science, technology, and public policy from George Washington University; March 2020; “Chapter 10: Solar Space, Island Earth, and the Ends of Humanity”; Dark Skies: Space Expansionism, Planetary Geopolitics, and the Ends of Humanity; Kindle; TV] *Edited in brackets for ableist language.

A crucial additional parameter of this scenario is temporal: How much time will be required to realize these steps? Optimistic expansion timetables presuppose large and sustained investments in space, which are unlikely. 5 But it seems plausible that these steps might be accomplished over several centuries. However, this schedule assumes that the Earth will be willing and able to provide significant initial support for colonization. The question of how rapidly self-sufficient colonies could be established has direct implications for their ability to serve as hedges to terrestrial catastrophic and existential threats.

Based on the earlier analysis of technological feasibility, the solar expansion success scenario is probably possible, with critical uncertainties about health and artificial biospheres. But this scenario is also very improbable for many strong reasons. Inaction, failure, or debilitating conflict are more likely than success. Colonization may not be attempted because it is too difficult and expensive, or because of growing Earth problems and troubles. Off-Earth living could be too unhealthy for humans, and reproduction and child growth in low-gravity environments may be infeasible, confining viable habitat to spinable artificial bodies. Potent pathogens might evolve in novel space environments. Artificial ecosystems could be too difficult to create and sustain. People may not want to live on Mars or an asteroid, for the same reasons they do not live in the middle of the Sahara or Antarctica. Or colonization might be attempted and quickly fail, like Norse Vineland in Newfoundland or Scot Darien in Panama. Or a colony might be only minimally successful and linger as a remote, climate-stunted backwater, like early modern Iceland. Space colonies might be like the many failed societies analyzed by the geographer Jared Diamond in Collapse. 6 The small population of a space settlement might succumb to disease or debilitating internecine conflict. Conflicts over the limited number of metal-bearing asteroids might start early. 7 The sponsoring Earth agent might abandon its colony due to shifting priorities, insufficient resources, or diverting conflicts. If interstate rivalry propels colonization it will happen more rapidly but will also be more likely to involve violence sooner. If rivalrous states establish colonies, conflict between them might beggar and hobble [hinder] all. There may be a vast gap between a colony that can be kept operational with continual inputs from Earth and one that is capable of persisting without any Earth support. If, as Sagan proposed, large-scale settlement is delayed until after major terrestrial problems have been solved, the prospects for success rise, while the rationales weaken and the time frames lengthen. And as colonization becomes imminent, doubts of the sort voiced here may lead to organized opposition.

The success scenario, and much of space expansionist thinking, operates with the implicit assumption that space settlement will be propelled by numerous capable agents committed to advancing the long-term success of humanity. This is a dubious assumption, given that the Earth’s growing problems have yet to stimulate the emergence of numerous powerful agents committed to advancing even the species’ short-term success. And if powerful actors were motivated by long-term species interest, colonization would be much less necessary.

The success scenario also assumes that different space ventures build on each other when they The success scenario also operates with what can be called the Benign Parent Model of Terra-Colony Relations. In this approach, Earth lavishes resources on its space colonial offspring and benignly supervises their development until they are able to direct and support themselves. Constitutions for space polities embodying the best of Terran political wisdom are established. This model, however, is almost entirely at variance with the historical experience of terrestrial colonization and the incentives of relevant self-interested actors. To the extent states or corporations invest in space colonies, they will want to maintain control and reap the benefits of their investments. To the extent they anticipate colonial independence, they will not invest; if they do, they will try to keep colonies small and dependent.

The success scenario also assumes that different space ventures build on each other when they might subvert and impede one another. The two central projects, Mars colonization and asteroidal resource extraction, might be quite antagonistic. Wealth generated from space resources will most probably be repatriated to Earth, not plowed into space habitat construction. Asteroidal exploitation is likely to be capital- and robot-intensive, with a minimal human labor force rotating through small off-world bases, as on off-shore oil rigs. If resources from asteroids are the bonanza some anticipate, the beneficiaries of this wealth will not want colonies to contest their access and possession and can be expected to actively oppose colonization. The more space mining benefits terrestrial actors, the greater their incentive to impede space settlements. And once the bombardment potential of asteroidal orbital alteration technology becomes obvious, the dangers of independent space colonies might be sufficiently obvious to thwart their realization.

A long list of powerful barriers stand between colonization visions and accomplishment. Given the many obstacles that render successful space colonization at scale very improbable, it is extremely imprudent for humanity to view space colonization as a hedge against catastrophe or extinction. With low probabilities of success and significant moral hazards and opportunity costs, space colonization should not be considered a viable response to severe Earth problems and troubles.

Space colonization causes existential wars---secessionist movements, reactionist colonies, and inter-colonial conflict outweigh every terrestrial war in history.

Kovic ’21 [Marko; February 2021; independent researcher and PhD at Institute of Mass Communication and Media Research, University of Zurich; Futures, “Risks of space colonization,” vol. 126; kp]

Imagine, for example, the large, self-sustaining habitat on Venus that consists of 2 billion people that I mentioned in a thought experiment before. That hypothetical habitat is truly self-sustainable, in the sense that survival on Venus is not contingent in any way on resources or other kinds of support from Earth. If prior human history is an indication, it is conceivable that the Venusians could at some point seek to change their political status. They might want to no longer be governed by Earth or Earth-based governements and instead have sovereignty to autonomously and freely shape Venus’ future. They might, in other words, seek to seceede and become an independent political entity.

Given prior human history of secession and independence movements, such a claim to independence in the context of space colonization could easily result in violent conflict, and given the scale of the conflict parties in this scenario, the bloodshed could be much greater than all the wars that happened in Earth’s history so far. Of course, we do not know what the dominant political philosophy of the future will be. Perhaps popular sovereignty and the wish for autonomy will be fully respected and met with unconditional, enlightened understanding. But that prospect is, at best, uncertain, and the prospect of catastrophic violent conflicts seems at least possible.

5.2 Reactionary colonies

Let us assume for the sake of argument that the risks surrounding secession- ist claims of extraterrestrial colonies will eventually have been overcome and that there are colonies which have attained a country-like or world-like status. What should the political systems in and the moral foundations of those independent colonies look like? Ideally, they would be at least as democratic, liberal, and generally morally progressive as the most democratic, liberal, and morally progressive countries today. More specifically, independent fu- ture colonies should have socio-political systems that do not lower average wellbeing or create (disproportionately) more suffering compared to their pre-existing peers such as Earth-based countries (Or whatever the dominant polity on Earth in that future might be.). However, there is no guarantee that independent colonies will meet that socio-political and moral bar. It is possible that there will be colonies whose socio-political systems are regressive in one way or another, marked by a relative moral decay compared to the baseline of political systems and moral frameworks. I call such potential undesirable entities reactionary colonies.

The emergence of reactionary colonies might seem implausible given that humankind has, very roughly speaking, so far morally improved over the course of its history8. But reactionary colonies might actually be a fairly common future development. If humankind at some point achieves the tech- nological means for creating colonies with relative ease, creating new colonies might be an attractive option for extremist groups and beliefs. Imagine, for example, a religious group that believes in the fundamental superiority of men over women. Such a religious group might find it difficult adhering to their flawed moral principles in a pluralistic society. Opting for colonial exodus might represent an attractive opportunity for that religious group to build a society from scratch which is based on their notions of female inferiority and subjugation.

The specific risk posed by reactionary colonies ist twofold. Reactionary colonies would by definition lower the average happiness and wellbeing of humankind and create unnecessary, preventable suffering. Reactionary colonies would also represent potential rogue actors that could greatly amplify the aberration risks described in section 4. For example, a dictatorial regime that causes great suffering to its population might be tempted to expand its dictatorial ideology to other colonies. Or that dictatorial colony could be led by a psychopathic elite that enjoys letting sentient simulations suffer as much as possible. The potential catastrophic and even existential multiplicator effects of reactionary colonies are, unfortunately, numerous.

5.3 Inter-colonial conflict

Let us, again for the sake of the argument, assume that the previous problem of reactionary colonies has somehow been solved or avoided. Humankind has continued its path of technological development, and it has established several large clusters of colonies beyond the Solar system. Assuming that the fundamental problem of faster-than-light communication has not been solved yet, communication between the clusters lags months or even years, and physical contact between the clusters is rare since travel takes even longer than communication.

The inevitable consequence of such a splintering of human civilization is that the different clusters of colonies would over time develop distinct cultures, and with only scarce and delayed contact with other clusters, a form of intergroup bias [40], the moral preference of one’s own in-group over the out-group, would likely start to manifest. Over time, that us-versus- them heuristic could help create distinct and solidified social identities within the colony clusters [41], and the beliefs and preferences about the outgroup colonies could become more overtly negative. Given enough time and great enough idiosyncratic development within each colony cluster, the cultural and moral connections between the colony clusters could further erode, and in their place, a sense of dread and looming danger about the others’ goals and preferences could take hold. Over a long enough period of time and great enough separation, the perception that other colonies are a threat could grow; so much so that taking preventative action and attacking and suppressing them might seem like the most rational course of action [42]. Given the scale and the likely technological sophistication of future weapons systems, a violent conflict between advanced colonies and colony clusters would create suffering on an astronomical scale.

Of course, the prospect of inter-colonial conflict is somewhat speculative [43]. But given humankind’s past experiences, violent conflict clearly seems within the realm of the possible. That does not mean that such an almost immeasurably terrible conflict is unavoidable. Even the slightest probability of such conflict, however, means immense potential expected disvalue.

Chance of asteroids very small.

Robert Walker 16. Software Developer of Tune Smithy, Wolfson College, Oxford. 12-14-2016. "Why Resilient Humans Would Survive Giant Asteroid Impact." Science 2.0. https://www.science20.com/robert_inventor/we_wont_go_extinct_after_a_major_asteroid_impact_even_96_of_species_extinct_0_chance_of_humans_extinct-187383

Although there is a risk of “mass extinction” if a large asteroid hit Earth, “mass extinction” there doesn’t mean “extinction of humans”, we are such a resilient species that we would certainly survive a giant asteroid impact. We are not “due” an extinction at all. Next giant impact is most likely to happen many millions of years into the future. As we'll see, there is almost zero chance of a giant impact in the next century. There is however much we can do to protect ourselves from smaller asteroids. As a result of extensive asteroid surveys over the last couple of decades: We can be pretty sure (as in perhaps 99.999999% sure) that there isn’t an extinction level asteroid headed our way in the next century. We know the orbits of all the Near Earth Asteroids that could do this and none will hit Earth over that timescale. That leaves comets, and the chance of that is something like 1 in 100 million per century, as a very rough guess (since 99% of the impacts are thought to be from asteroids). This risk has been pretty much retired due to the automated asteroid searches by the likes of Pan STARRS.

Reproduction on a colony is impossible

Lerner 18 (Steven Lerner. Staff writer @ Tech Times. 5-31-2018. "Having Sex On Mars Could Be Challenging And It Might Lead To A New Species." Tech Times. https://www.techtimes.com/articles/229073/20180531/having-sex-on-mars-could-be-challenging-and-it-might-lead-to-a-new-species.htm)

"Unfortunately, such an endeavour comes with titanic challenges in various disciplines, from space travel technology to medical, biological, social and ethical challenges," the researchers wrote. "We assume that human reproduction in a Mars settlement will be necessary for the long-term success of an outer-space mission." The researchers hypothesized that if humans were to successfully conceive and give birth in space, it could potentially be a new species because of all of the unique circumstances outside of Earth. Challenges Of Reproducing On Mars Although the researchers are optimistic about reproducing on Mars, there could be numerous challenges that might make sex nearly impossible. The biggest challenge is with the gravity. Mars has roughly one-third the gravity of Earth, which could endanger the likelihood of getting pregnant. It is well-documented that prolonged time in space could alter a human's biological makeup and it could change the shape of a person's brain. This is how a new species might get created. Lower gravity could lower a person's blood pressure, which is needed for engaging in sexual intercourse. Scientists also know that low gravity can cause vision problems and lead to a weakened immune system, which would be dangerous for pregnant women. In addition to the lack of gravity, there are also other complications. There is more solar radiation on Mars, which would reduce a man's sperm count. More importantly, there is no documented evidence that a woman could have a full term pregnancy without any problems. The researchers wrote that these challenges could increase "the risks of infection-induced abortions and facilitate the dissemination of diseases among pregnant and non-pregnant individuals."

Neither governments nor the private sector will commit.

Konrad Szocik 19. University of Information Technology and Management in Rzeszow, Department of Philosophy and Cognitive Science. 01/2019. “Should and Could Humans Go to Mars? Yes, but Not Now and Not in the near Future.” Futures, vol. 105, pp. 54–66.

6. Public opinion Public opinion is, at least in the near future, the main sponsor of space research and space exploration. Bertrand, Pirtle, and Tomblin, (2017) show that the public is interested in human mission to Mars. The most preferred space mission is a crew in orbit and a robot mission on Mars surface. In other words, public criteria is low risk and low cost. The German space agency follows public opinion and social interest because is focused on duty for society and oriented to social purposes as “climate change, mobility, communication and security” (Zypries, 2017). Politicians are prone to reduce space budgets or to not invest in long-term human settlement missions due to public opinion. Consequently, progress in space technology is still retarded. State of art in space transport means did not change qualitatively since the Space Race between the US and the Soviet Union. Impact of public opinion may differ in various countries. Max Grimard (2012), p. 6) shows how important is space program for public opinion in the US. Public sympathy for American presence in space is counterbalanced by the unpredictability of politician authorities, the tensions between presidents and the Congress (Grimard, 2012, p. 12), and the important role played by competition with Russia and China (Grimard, 2012, p. 6). Grimard adds that Russia is similar case but it is currently entire focused on stability of space programs, including renovation of old infrastructure than on new space exploration programs. According to Grimard (2012), p. 13), this fact excludes Russia from being the leader of international collaboration in space policy despite its historical advantages. China, according to Grimard, repeats space policies of the US and Soviet Union. By contrast, in Japan and Europe, prestige does not play role. Japan and Europe are focused on scientific and technological contexts. Space program is not a part of national policy. Due to its costs, politicians may decide to not risk negative approach of public opinion. But public opinion does not threaten private investors which can consider space as object of their investment. 7. Commercial exploration of space is not a workable alternative Risk of funding the wall might be avoided by commercial exploration of space (Crawford, 2016). According to Crawford, some space projects such as next generation of large telescopes or crewed mission to Mars are non-profitable. While they are a governmental duty, they could be funded partially by profits from commercial exploration of space (for instance, space mining). Hope for private exploration sounds reasonable but is counterbalanced by commercial focus on profits. Because mission to Mars has only scientific profits, only public sponsors will be invested in this project. James S. J. Schwartz (2014) adds that two of the possible reasons for human space mission, such as improving human welfare and progress in scientific exploration, are well beyond interests of private companies. Newman and Williamson (2018) quite similarly expect that private space exploration will be focused on financial profits more than on environmental sustainability. Private investors are not obliged to act altruistically and to sacrifice their business for uncertain idea. W. Henry Lambright (2017) adds that private companies at least at first stages of Mars space program will not be able to fund it. For this reason, Mars space program requires multi-generational effort and political stabilization. The challenge of safety works against private investors in space program. Public space agencies have achieved high standards of safety. They behave in careful and conservative ways. Commercial, private projects do not have the same advanced technology, the large number of scientists and support staff, and the generous budgets. Catastrophe would likely break a private space program. The lack of experience of private companies in space exploration is partially responsible for higher risk of technological failures even in relatively easy tasks as crash of Momo-2 rocket launched by Japanese start-up on 30 June 2018 several seconds after launch. This does not mean that private investors are not able to explore space, but they are able to do that only when they receive profits. In scenario of commercial exploration of space, we should wait for some point in the future when a human space base appears as byproduct of commercial activity. A human base on Mars might be a by-product of hotels on LEO or space mining. Some investors who want to build space hotels may try to settle space regions beyond LEO and build hotels on the Moon and/or Mars. From touristic point of view, staying in the Moon or Mars hotel may be more attractive than on LEO. Investors working in asteroid mining may extend their business to the Moon and/or Mars. Both enterprises even if focused on purely commercial purposes, will not be easy (perhaps impossible) to achieve by private companies alone. Elvis (2012), p. 549) argues that asteroid mining will be challenging due to, among others, difficulties in detection of appropriate asteroids. He shows that among about 1200 analyzed meteorites only 13 of them contain high level of platinum profitable for their exploitation. Elvis suggests that NASA should reorient its strategy from focus on exploration to support for commercial utilization of space. Exploration will appear as a consequence of commercial profitable activity (Elvis, 2012, p. 549). Estimated profits of asteroid mining10 are counterbalanced by high costs of exploitation and possible decreasing of price of currently rare resources (Genta, 2014).11

It’s an S-risk.

Phil Torres 18. Project for Future Human Flourishing. 06/2018. “Space Colonization and Suffering Risks: Reassessing the ‘Maxipok Rule.’” Futures, vol. 100, pp. 74–85.

Finally, we should note that the present paper compliments the conclusions of several other scholars who have approached the topic from different angles. Most notably, Brian Tomasik worries that terraforming Earth-like planets or spreading life via “directed panspermia” (as Claudius Gros, who founded the Genesis Project, advocates) could significantly increase the total amount of suffering in the universe—an especially bad outcome if one espouses a “suffering-focused” ethics (Tomasik 2016, 2017a, 2017b). There could also be massive simulations running on exoplanets that have been converted into computronium in which billions of sentient simulants suffer immense agony. Given the huge number of future beings who could exist if we do colonize space, it stands to reason that someone somewhere would run such simulations (perhaps from within a simulation), create new biospheres in which wild animals are subject to Darwinian misery, and so on. As Tomasik (2017a) speculates, “if I had to make an estimate now, I would give ~70% probability that if humans choose to colonize space, this will cause more suffering than it reduces on intrinsic grounds.” The result could be an s-risk. Thus, the present paper offers a complimentary reason for rejecting the normative ideology of space expansionism.

Also multiplies S-risks – outweighs extinction.

Kovic ’21 [Marko; February 2021; independent researcher and PhD at Institute of Mass Communication and Media Research, University of Zurich; Futures, “Risks of space colonization,” vol. 126; kp]

4.3 Astronomical suffering

Space colonization means that humans and human actions will spread beyond Earth and possibly cover, relatively speaking, vast areas of the reachable universe. This will potentially create immense positive value, but it also makes possible a form of existential risks that are astronomical in scope and hellish in severity — that are, in other words, orders of magnitude worse than anything humankind has caused or encountered so far. This subset of extreme existential risks is referred to as suffering risks [35].

Suffering risks are risks that are far worse than humankind going extinct or entering permanent moral stagnation because they mean that the suffering that is created through these risks is far greater than all suffering that has existed on Earth so far. There are different vectors of potential astronomical suffering. For example, it is conceivable that future human generations will spread wildlife throughout the colonized space, either inadvertently or actively. Wild animals on Earth generally lead short, miserable lives full of sometimes the most brutal suffering [36]. In in the history of Earth, wildlife suffering has not really improved at all, so astronomical wildlife suffering would likely represent a constant source of disvalue.

Another vector for suffering risks are sentient simulations. Given growing computational power, it is conceivable that we will eventually be able to simulate sentience, and as soon as simulated sentience is possible, simulated suffering will be as well. This technological path is not necessarily depen- dent on space colonization, but a colonizing humankind might have greater capabilities for running such simulations, for example by tapping into the power of stars in different Solar systems. Instances of simulated suffering could create more suffering than has ever occurred in the biological universe, within fractions of a second.

The risk of astronomical suffering is more uncertain than other existential risks, but it is at the same time more severe. At stake is not just humankind’s total potential positive future moral value, but disvalue that is decoupled from humankind and is potentially many orders of magnitude greater than all the happiness and wellbeing that could be created by human colonization of space.

Space col exports astronomical wild animal suffering throughout the Universe---outweighs extinction

Bruers 18 – Stijn Bruers, Professor in the Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences at Ghent University, PhD in Physics and PhD in Moral Philosophy, “My Cause Prioritization”, 2-15, https://stijnbruers.wordpress.com/2018/02/15/my-cause-prioritization/

Welfare biology Because at least some people choose a conditional maximum as their reference preference, we have to give some weight to the person affecting view in population ethics. In that case, we have a priority to avoid the existence of individuals with lives not worth living. Here we face the problem of wild animal suffering. It is possible that some animals in nature have lives not worth living, because their lives are full of negative experiences due to hunger, diseases, injuries, parasites and predators. Especially the animals with an r-selection reproductive strategy have a problem: these animals have a lot of offspring (the population has a high rate of reproduction, hence the name ‘r-selection’), and only a few of them survive long enough to reproduce themselves. Most lives of those animals are very short and probably miserable. We are not likely to see the majority of those animals, because they will die and be eaten quickly. A better reproductive strategy in terms of well-being, is K-selection: having few offspring with long lives and high survival rates. If a life is long, it is more likely to be positive because it has proportionally fewer negative experiences of hunger or deadly diseases. Only humans are very close to a perfect K-selection: the average fertility rate of a woman is 2,5 children, and this rate is decreasing and expected to reach 2 children in the second halve of this century. When it reaches 2 children per woman, and when all children survive till they reproduce, the human population becomes stable. Every human can have a full live. (As lifespan increases, the fertility rate can drop below 2 children per woman.) According to the person affecting view, we have to give priority to avoiding r-selection and promoting K-selection. Perhaps with genetic manipulation (e.g. gene drives), we can turn every population into K-selection (where female animals have on average two offspring) and make sure that all animals have long healthy lives. But for the moment, only humans are about to reach the ideal K-selection reproduction. Healthy humans have other advantages: they have complex preferences and strong personal identities over time, which means they can have potentially high levels of lifetime well-being when their preferences are satisfied. So it is possible that humans can have larger relative preferences than non-human animals. Most humans can also clearly communicate their preferences: it is easier to determine the levels of well-being of humans who can self-consciously think and speak than the levels of well-being of non-human animals who can only communicate their preferences in very indirect ways through behavior. Estimating the well-being or relative preferences of wild animals is very difficult and may require accurate brain scans. We can be very confident that the lives of healthy humans are worth living, but not confident at all that the life of an average wild animal is worth living. The above implies that we can give a priority to saving and helping humans. This preference for healthy humans (increasing the relative number of healthy humans) is not speciesism, because the basic criteria to derive this preference (e.g. the level of personal identity over time, the level of communication and the level of K-selection) did not refer to species membership. The above discussion did not use the word ‘species’ at all. Given our current state of knowledge, a preference for healthy humans is most likely to satisfy the maximum relative preferences principle. Pros and cons of human population growth As explained above, helping humans means increasing K-selection in the world. The more individuals who belong to a K-selection population, the better. However, there are also problems with human population growth. More humans means more competition for scarce resources, more people who can invent dangerous technologies, more greenhouse gas emissions, higher likelihood of spreading of dangerous viruses. These things increase existential risks. But it can also mean more mutually beneficial situations through trade and cooperation, more inventions of good technologies, higher likelihood of resistance against dangerous viruses. However, there is one very big disadvantage of giving priority to humans: most humans consume animal products. Buying animal products gives an incentive to breed animals who have lives not worth living in e.g. factory farms. Fighting poverty and promoting economic development might increase animal suffering: a $1,000 increase in per capita GDP in the poorest countries implies an increased consumption of 1.7 kg of meat per person per year. Saving the life of a human omnivore means a consumption of about 30 kg of meat. It is difficult to estimate the total costs and benefits of further human population growth. Give the consumption of animal products, I tend towards the conclusion that decreasing human population growth is valuable, but only if it is done in a way that has other cobenefits. Avoiding unwanted pregnancies through family planning is the only strategy that has a lot of cobenefits in terms of women’s rights, health of newborn children, environmental impact reduction and poverty reduction. The benefit-cost ratio of family planning is high. This means that family planning may also be consistent with the total view in population ethics, even if fewer happy people might come into existence. Finally by reducing the fertility rate, family planning is a means to reach perfect K-selection. Therefore, I give a low priority to family planning by supporting organizations such as Marie Stopes International. Cause area: veganism and antidiscrimination As helping humans involves a risk of increasing animal suffering, I give a high priority to promoting veganism, animal rights and antispeciesism. According to some thought experiments, we can conclude that most animals in agriculture and aquaculture have lives not worth living, so creating those lives violates both the person affecting view and the total view in population ethics. Promoting veganism is a more neglected area than improving human health and well-being. Furthermore, veganism also has many cobenefits in terms of improved human health: less chronic diseases due to healthier diets, less health impact from climate change due to lower greenhouse gas emissions, less malnutrition due to lower food prices for the poorest people, and less health risks from pollution, zoonotic viruses and antibiotic resistant bacteria. Veganism also facilitates spreading the value of antidiscrimination. Speciesism is an example of discrimination. If people consume animal products, a cognitive dissonance prevents them from valuing animals as equal to humans. When they eat vegan, this cognitive dissonance diminishes and they are more open to the value of antispeciesism. The interspecies model of prejudice predicts that a decrease in speciesism results in a decrease in racism, i.e. a decrease of prejudice against other groups of people. Antispeciesism is also necessary to start scientific research about wild animal suffering and to find safe and effective means to intervene in nature to improve wild animal well-being. And finally, antispeciesism becomes important when it comes to the development of artificial general intelligence and superintelligence. If we create superintelligent AI machines and implement them with our own speciesist goals, even more animals can be exploited by AI machines for many years in the future. The cause area of veganism is also relatively neglected and tractable, which means effective altruists have a lot of high impact opportunities in this area. Effective vegan advocacy, perhaps with deep canvassing, is promising. But clean meat, and more generally tissue engineering, appear to be very promising as well. With these technologies, we can create animal products without using animals. It might also be a crucial technology for wild animal suffering reduction, as it can provide a food alternative for predators. The tissue engineering technology can also be used to extend life and replace a lot of animal experimentation. Therefore, I support the Good Food Institute and to a lesser degree the Methuselah Foundation. Catastrophic risks There are several possible extinction risks (X-risks) where everyone dies: asteroid impacts, supervolcano eruptions, pandemic viruses, runaway global warming, global nuclear war, dangerous nanotechnology. According to the total view of population ethics, extinction of sentient and intelligent life is a tragedy, because it means a lot of future preference satisfaction (well-being, happiness) is lost. Hence, extinction prevention (X-risk reduction) gets a top priority. From a person affecting view, extinction is less bad, because with extinction, non-existent future beings cannot complain and wild animals with lives not worth living will no longer be born, so future complaints will be avoided. Extinction is only bad for those of the current generations who value a continued existence in the far future, and especially for the last generation, because most extinction scenarios involve suffering when everyone dies. But there is a class of catastrophic risks that is even worse than X-risks: S-risks or suffering risks, where the future contains huge populations of sentient beings with lives full of misery. This is worse than extinction, because an S-risk is terrible both from a total view as well as from a person affecting view. An example of an S-risk is space colonization where we export wild animal suffering and livestock farming: the number of animals with lives not worth living will multiply when other planets are colonized. Before we start with space colonization, we should first adopt veganism and antispeciesist values such that we will not export and multiply animal suffering.

Every second of no space colonization outweighs.

Torres ’18 [Phil; April 20; Affiliate Scholar at the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, and founder of the X-Risks Institute; Futures, “Space Colonization and Suffering Risks: Reassessing the ‘Maxipok Rule’,” vol. 100 p. 74-85; kp]

Abstract: This article argues that, contra Bostrom (2003), every second of delayed space colonization could be immensely desirable; indeed, the longer the delay, the better, with the best outcome being no colonization at all. The argument begins by hypothesizing that expansion into space will generate a wide variety of distinct species, many having their own cultural, political, religious, etc. traditions. Next, the paper offers reasons for expecting catastrophic conflicts between different civilizations, both near and far, to be the default outcome. Third, it examines some strategies for mitigating conflict, including (i) the establishment of a “cosmic Leviathan” that is capable of imposing law and order within the cosmopolitical arena, and (ii) the implemen- tation of policies of deterrence to prevent one civilization from attacking another. Both of these strategies appear problematic, though, due to (a) fundamental physical limitations on the speed of space travel and the transfer of information, and (b) the advanced weaponry that future civili- zations will almost certainly have at their disposal. The conclusion is that colonizing our solar system, galaxy, and beyond will engender a Hobbesian predicament in which all actors are perpetually in fear of being destroyed—that is, when they aren’t engaged in devastating wars with their neighbors.

Accidents create a 99.3% chance of conflict.

Torres ’18 [Phil; April 20; Affiliate Scholar at the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, and founder of the X-Risks Institute; Futures, “Space Colonization and Suffering Risks: Reassessing the ‘Maxipok Rule’,” vol. 100 p. 74-85; kp]

Here we should also not overlook the potential for accidents to cause conflicts when inter-civilizational tensions are sufficiently high. The disturbing historical fact is that “pure dumb luck” played a critical role in preventing nuclear war from occurring during the Cold War. Indi- viduals like Vasili Arkhipov and Stanislav Petrov more or less single-handedly averted nuclear holocausts, and an interpretation error in 1995 led Boris Yeltsin to become “the first Russian president to ever have the ‘nuclear suitcase’ open in front of him” (Cirincione 2013). Although intelligence is negatively correlated with accident proneness, and presumably our (post)human descendants will be cognitively enhanced to some extent, even a small probability of error could make disaster almost certain (see Author). For example, imagine that a mere 500 people have access to a “button” that, if pushed, would initiate a catastrophic first strike against the other civilization. If each of these individuals has a mere 0.01 chance per decade of accidentally pushing this button, the result is a staggering 99.3 percent probability that, within 10 years, the strike will occur. So, perhaps Earth and Mars—whose civilizations could potentially coexist for another 10 million centuries, until the sun burns out—won’t be quite as lucky as the US and Soviet Union were for the slightly more than four decades between 1947 and 1991.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.