RWG – War inevitable
War is inevitable—-BUT, the longer we wait, the worse it gets.
Baum and Barrett ’18 (Seth D. Baum and Anthony M. Barrett, A Model For The Impacts Of Nuclear War. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute Working Paper 18-2) stowPCB
On the other end of the spectrum, the norm could be weaker. The Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings provided a vivid and enduring image of the horrors of nuclear war—hence the norm can reasonably be described as a legacy of the bombings. Without this image, there would be less to motivate the norm. A weaker norm could in turn have led to a nuclear war occurring later, especially during a near-miss event like the Cuban missile crisis. A later nuclear war would likely be much more severe, assuming some significant buildup of nuclear arsenals and especially if “overkill” targeting was used. A new nuclear war could bring a similarly wide range of shifts in nuclear weapons norms. It could strengthen the norm, hastening nuclear disarmament. Already, there is a political initiative drawing attention to the humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons use in order to promote a new treaty to ban nuclear weapons as a step towards complete nuclear disarmament (Borrie 2014). It is easy to imagine this initiative using any new nuclear attacks to advance their goals. Alternatively, it could weaken the norm, potentially leading to more and/or larger nuclear wars. This is a common concern, as seen for example in debates over low-yield bunker buster nuclear weapons (Nelson 2003). Given that the impacts of a large nuclear war could be extremely severe, a shift in nuclear weapons norms could easily be the single most consequential effect of a smaller nuclear war. Norms about nuclear power can also be highly consequential. Fear of ionizing radiation from nuclear power inflates public concern about nuclear power relative to the actual medical risk (e.g., Slovic 2012). Some of this fear appears to derive from perceptions of nuclear weapons, especially Hiroshima and Nagasaki (e.g., Cwikel 1997). A new nuclear attack could strengthen general fears of nuclear radiation, further reducing support for nuclear power. Reduced support for nuclear power can in turn have major consequences to energy systems and the environment. Energy analysts are divided on the details, with some warning that increased use of fossil fuels.