Internal problems don’t preclude US leadership, and retrenching wouldn’t solve them.
Hal Brands 21, Bloomberg Opinion columnist, the Henry Kissinger Distinguished Professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies, and a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, 1/9/2021, "Turning Its Back on the World Won’t Help America Heal", Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-09/trump-fueled-u-s-dysfunction-won-t-be-cured-by-isolationist-foreign-policy
The severity of the U.S. predicament has led some analysts to the conclusion that Washington must dial back its global ambitions until it conquers its internal demons. As Emma Ashford put it in Foreign Policy, “Ambitious foreign-policy goals are completely out of step with the realities of the country’s domestic political and economic dysfunction.”
That’s misguided. No true U.S. ally is advocating that Washington turn its back on the world (although many presumably worry about it), and for good reason. It’s not as though the need for American engagement has become any less pressing: As we have seen during Covid-19, the likely alternatives to constructive U.S. leadership are a breakdown of international cooperation on pandemics and other issues and a vacuum that less principled, less democratic actors such as China will fill.
Richard Nixon, another corrupt president who governed at another time of alarming domestic and geopolitical turmoil, warned that “if America were to become a dropout in assuming the responsibility for defining peace and freedom in the world … the rest of the world would live in terror.” Nixon’s own transgressions notwithstanding, a post-American world seems unlikely to be any more stable or benign today.
The premise of retrenchment is flawed in other ways, too. Unless foreign policy is a principal cause of America’s divisions and injustices, as it was during Vietnam, then it’s not immediately evident that a less ambitious foreign policy would help address those problems. Withdrawing from Europe’s strategic affairs after World War I didn’t allow the U.S. to avoid a wave of nativism and racism in the 1920s or the profound polarization of the Great Depression.
One can plausibly argue that the relationship runs in the other direction. During the Cold War, America’s commitment to combating Soviet influence globally helped motivate it to address its worst domestic sin, state-sponsored segregation.
Finally, domestic perfection has never been a prerequisite for purposeful international action. The U.S. protected the world from aggressive autocracy in two global wars despite being a deeply flawed society that fell far short of its founding ideals. It contained the Soviet Union, thereby supporting an unprecedented flourishing of democracy worldwide, while struggling with issues from racial injustice to economic turmoil to bitter political disputes. Had Americans instead insisted on resolving domestic problems before acting internationally, the result would have been a disaster for liberalism everywhere — including, ultimately, in America itself.
The U.S. should emerge from the Trump era with greater humility about its own shortcomings and the dangers they pose to its diplomacy as well as its democracy. Yet it cannot fall into despair about its ability to shape a healthy world. The domestic reckoning America requires should be seen as a complement to the American leadership the world still needs — not as a substitute.