Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU Solves SSA.

Phillip A. Slann 16. Research assistant to the Emerging Securities Unit and the Biopolitics of Security Network Website, as well as the publicity editor for the In-Spire Journal of Law, Politics and Societies, BA (Hons) from Keele University in History and International Relations, MRes in International Relations at Keele. “Anticipating uncertainty: The security of European critical outer space infrastructures.” ScienceDirect. Feb 2016. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0265964615300163

The Space Surveillance and Tracking segment of the European SSA is arguably contributing to preventive action on the issue of space debris. In terms of outer space security, while preventive security measures may be oriented towards threats with an ‘objectively given existence’ [40], the element of surprise is still important. Whereas the measures included within the Code are directed at reducing future debris generation, the monitoring of existing debris clouds and the contributions to a European debris catalogue by the Space Surveillance and Tracking segment serve to provide detailed orbital trajectory information to satellite operators with the objective of forewarning operators of impending collisions, enabling them to make avoidance manoeuvres should they feel the need to do so. It could be argued that, in terms of anticipatory security, the Space Surveillance and Tracking segment is seeking to enhance the statistical calculability of the danger posed by the existing space debris population. The focus then is on securing the present through the mitigation of surprise, although there may be further applications in the future should feasible space debris remediation technologies be developed and deployed. The second SSA area involves the forecasting and monitoring of space weather events. These include solar flares, Coronal Mass Ejections and Solar Energetic Particle bursts that can cause significant damage to terrestrial and extra-terrestrial infrastructures. The largest recorded space weather event, known as the Carrington Event, took place in September 1859 and began with a ‘solar flare so strong that it could be seen with the naked eye’ [69]. The solar flare was followed by a huge Coronal Mass Ejection which disrupted telegraph systems on Earth, to the extent that ‘[o]perators were able to disconnect their batteries and continue to send messages using only this induced current’ [70]. More recently, in 1989, a notably severe CME caused a failure of the power grid in Quebec, leaving around six million people without electricity for 9 h, whilst transformers in the UK and the US were also damaged [71,72]. The space weather segment of the European SSA contains both preventive and preemptive elements. On the one hand, it involves the forecasting of imminent extra-terrestrial phenomena produced by solar activity in order to warn satellite operators of fluctuations in the solar and near-Earth environments, making it a reactive security mechanism enabling calculable probabilities based upon pre-existing solar activity. However, there is a preemptive aspect to its operations insofar as the solar activity which produces space weather events cannot be predicted. Moreover, the segment includes research undertaken into significant space weather events for which there is little historical data. A number of studies have considered the effects that a severe event on a similar scale to, or larger than, the Carrington Event might have on terrestrial and extra-terrestrial infrastructures [73]. In addition, and although not strictly part of the SSA Space Weather segment, sensors have also been placed on board the Galileo satellites to monitor radiation levels in Middle Earth Orbit. As well as contributing to the development of more robust satellites, this research is also serving to condition those working with vulnerable infrastructures to the possibility and danger of a severe space weather event, improving their resilience if faced with an event of similar magnitude to the Carrington Event. These studies and practices are contributing to the development and refinement of imaginaries concerned with the impact of future significant space weather events. Nothing can be done to prevent or stop space weather phenomena, but increased levels of awareness amongst those who deal with the consequences may lead to more effective damage limitation and recovery. In terms of critical infrastructure security, space weather acts as a pertinent example of the need for resilience as well as protection. If a space weather event were to disable active space objects e overcoming the component hardening and shielding that some satellites carry e the capability to resume operations rapidly through redundancies becomes vitally important. The third area of the European SSA is focused upon the detection of Near-Earth Objects. These are natural hazards such as asteroids with the potential to cause significant terrestrial damage. The risk of these objects hitting the Earth is arguably one of the more widely-known extra-terrestrial environmental factors, with visible geological evidence of historical events and numerous films using the scenario as a foundation. Although there is very little risk of asteroids or meteoroids causing damage to satellites, the segment of the European SSA dedicated to the detection of these astronomical phenomena is nonetheless reflective of an anticipatory security logic and thus worthy of inclusion within this discussion. Of all the segments of the SSA, the area devoted to near-Earth objects is the most preemptive in nature. The risk of an asteroid colliding with the Earth is relatively small, yet there is substantial financial and political backing for the detection of these astronomical phenomena. To this end, the near-Earth object segment of the European SSA is charged with searching for objects with a trajectory which may lead to them impacting the Earth, as well as contributing to the research and development of methods to deflect them [74]. The development of deflection technologies is particularly preemptive, as it deals with a threat that will remain unclear until a near-Earth object is identified as being on a collision course with the Earth. The European SSA is a preventive and preemptive anticipatory security mechanism; the Space Surveillance and Tracking and space weather segments are predominantly oriented towards forewarning of imminent threats posed by space debris and space weather through the use of statistical probability calculations. In this manner, they work to mitigate the element of surprise caused by unanticipated collisions or radiation by informing satellite operators of significant risks, allowing them to make avoidance manoeuvres if necessary. Regarding preemptive measures, although research is being undertaken into the possibility and consequences of cascading debris generation or large-scale space weather events, it does not appear to be a central component of the European SSA. This said, space surveillance is intrinsically a passive security mechanism focused upon imminent dangers and, until the technologies and governance structures are in place for space debris remediation, the Space Surveillance and Tracking segment will have limited application in terms of preemptive actions. It is feasible that SSA programmes will be able to identify particularly hazardous debris if and when space debris remediation becomes viable but until then, it will remain a security mechanism dedicated to providing collision warnings and monitoring debris populations

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.