Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Decline will be slow and peaceful – all of their impact claims are rooted in cognitive dissonance

Fettweis 2018 - Associate Professor of Political Science at Tulane University Christopher J, Psychology of a Superpower: Security and Dominance in U.S. Foreign Policy, Columbia University Press, p.172-173

Not all declines have gone so smoothly for the people who experienced them, of course. Sudden and sharp collapses, whether accompanied by marauding Goths and Vandals or not, are usually unpleasant experiences. The Soviet empire collapsed all at once, as did those of the Habsburgs and Ottomans, which led to instability, economic stagnation, and violence. No such rapid collapse is likely in the United States' future, however. Even the most inveterate pessimists do not envision a sudden reversal of fortunes and end of the unipolar system. All declinists predict a gradual, if inevitable, relative weakening, largely as the result of rising wealth and power elsewhere.38 The American experience is much more likely to resemble the gradual, graceful decline of Spain or Great Britain than the catastrophic collapse of Rome or the Soviets. And some scholars have even proposed that Chinese leadership would be accompanied by a greater degree of international stability, given Beijing's general disinterest in promoting revolutionary democratic change.39

The end of unipolarity will have positive aspects as well. Perception is likely to improve in Washington, for one thing, at least in certain areas. Researchers have found that the kind of overconfident self-assessments that impoverish the decision making of unipolar powers can be diminished if power is reduced.40 Once their dominance ends, over time the U.S. public might come to perceive the world in a more accurate way and craft better policies to deal with it. Or at least one can hope.

The unipolar order will end slowly, quietly, even imperceptibly, striking a blow to the U.S. ego, perhaps, but not its interest. When modern great powers fade, they tend to do it in ways that leave the people no worse off-and sometimes far better-than they were at the height of empire. To the extent that unipolarity contributes to pathological misperceptions, its end, whenever it arrives, may well improve the strategic thinking in the United States.

Most people devote little time to the finer points of grand strategy, however, and images of decline can create quite negative emotions. Accusations that Washington is allowing the United States to become less great somehow are powerful political tools. Individuals live vicariously through the exploits of their nation. When their country loses, they too are losers; when something good happens, they bask in reflected glory. The benefits of unipolarity are not merely-or even mostlyconfined to tangible increases in security. There is little evidence to support the belief, no matter how widely held, that the United States is safer in a world it dominates. A large part of the reason why so many Americans reflexively support their status is emotional and somewhat irrational: They simply enjoy being the best, the greatest, the numberone country in the world. They like to feel like winners.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.