Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hegemonic decline will be peaceful

Fettweis 2017 - Associate Professor of Political Science at Tulane University Christopher, "Unipolarity, Hegemony, and the New Peace," Security Studies, 26:3, 423-451, DOI: 10.1080/09636412.2017.1306394

Why has armed conflict declined to historically low levels? What accounts for the post-Cold War peace, and how long is it likely to last? Surely no questions are more important for either the theory or practice of international relations, and few are harder to answer. Only by understanding the causes of the New Peace can we extrapolate its likely future, however, and plan accordingly. Of the many possible independent variables, none is more controversial than the suggestion that hegemonic stability is at work. The possibility that the United States, wittingly or not, has essentially established a global Pax Americana is generally overlooked by the major scholarly works on the subject. This stands in stark contrast to the policy world, where the many positive aspects of unipolarity and/or US hegemony are articles of faith, rarely discussed and never seriously questioned. Scholar and public intellectual Michael Lind spoke for many when he wrote, “in my experience, most members of the U.S. foreign policy elite sincerely believe that the alternative to perpetual U.S. world domination is chaos and war.” 4 One of those is certainly Robert Kagan, who noted, “Pinker traces the beginning of a long-term decline in deaths from war to 1945, which just happens to be birthdate of the American world order. The coincidence eludes him, but it need not elude us.”5

This paper examines the theoretical, empirical, and psychological foundations of that widespread belief. The first section discusses the New Peace and its potential explanations; the second explains the difference between unipolarity and hegemony, and examines the logic of the hegemonic-stability argument; the third turns to the evidence, comparing both US power and grand strategy to conflict levels; the fourth examines the political psychology of hegemony and reviews some major findings that provide insight into how international order can be misperceived. Insights from that field are crucial in any discussion of the relationship between US power and global stability, which is built far more on belief and perception than evidence.

The New Peace does not appear to be the result of unipolarity or US hegemony. While that conclusion might not sit well with many US analysts, the news is not all bad, for if the current generation of declinists is right and unipolarity’s days are numbered, the odds are good that the world will not descend into the atavistic chaos that haunts the neoconservative imagination. The United States can adjust its grand strategy without fear in the Trump years, perhaps even letting the “unipolar moment” expire, because the New Peace may well be unrelated to its dominance.6

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.