Retrenchment is necessary to prevent a US-Sino war
MacDonald 2018 - Associate Professor of Political Science @ Wellesley College Paul K and Joseph M. Parent, Twilight of the Titans: Great Power Decline and Retrenchment, Cornell U Press, p. 199-200
International relations thinkers are rightly obsessed with rise and fall, war and peace. To date, most of them have looked at the historical record and not seen much cause for optimism. As new powers rise and old powers fall, the prospects for peace diminish because aggression pays and domestic politics is rife with dysfunction. Long placid periods are punctuated by thunderous bursts of war and change. Fear, honor, and greed come to the fore, and the tragedy of great powers politics repeats once more.
In this book, we developed a dissenting view. Starting from standard assumptions, we reasoned that the world is harsh enough to discipline domestic faction but not so harsh as to regularly demand aggression. Leaders have an array of policy tools to react in their own ways to shifting conditions, and states can seize control of their fates. Decline encourages retrenchment, but this is no bad thing and seldom a belligerent one. Past policymakers have done an admirable job keeping their ships of state from running aground, and today’s policymakers have better ships, better gauges, and better weather.
There is no sense in exacerbating decline by indulging delusions of everlasting grandeur, coddling ossified institutions, and living in the past. The United States has been the world’s largest economy for over a century. It has seen off numerous challengers before and can do so again. But the best chances for success are to keep one’s perspective, patience, and prudence intact. The United States is declining, but not much, and China is preoccupied by its own rise. This is no reason for preventive war or gratuitous malice. The odds are good for peace and prosperity, but there are non-negligible risks that domestic politics or unexpected crises could derail events. If the United States gives the mistaken impression that it is seeking to contain a rising China, whether through a rapid military buildup or intransigent diplomacy, this would empower hardline factions, stoke fears of falling dominos, and raise the stakes of minor crises. It is the American rejection of retrenchment, and the alarm this inspires in China, that could make war appear inevitable.