Securitization of space is rooted in realist and masculinist politics, justified by the enlightened will to know, dominate, and colonize
Griffin, 2009 (Penny, PhD and professor in the dept of politics and IR, Univ New South Wales, “The spaces between us: the gendered politics of outer space,” in Securing Outer Space, Routledge, p. 68-69; spp)
This ‘warfighting’ discourse is not, of course, the only construction of outer space to possess discursive currency in the US. ‘Space exploration’, as Crawford argues, ‘is inherently exciting, and as such is an obvious vehicle for inspiring the public in general, and young people in particular’ (2005: 258). Viewed predominantly as a natural extension to the so-called evolution of military and commercial ‘arts’ in the Western hemisphere, human, technological expansion into outer space is justified in terms of scientific, commercial, and military global entrepreneurship. Conquering the final frontier of outer space is increasingly seen as crucial to a state’s pre-eminence in the global economy (cf. ‘Joint Vision 2020’). International alliances in the post-Fordist economy ‘have already consolidated the decision for future space exploration and colonization’ (Casper and Moore 1995: 315). In a particularly dramatic turn of phrase, Seguin argues that [m]ankind [sic] now stands at the threshold of long-duration space habitation and interplanetary travel’ (2005: 980). Similarly, Manzey describes human missions to Mars less as contingent future events, but as the inevitable consequences of technological progress (Manzey 2004: 781-790). Space, once defined as a power-laden site of Cold War military conflict, has also become a site of international political and economic cooperation. Often conceptualized in expansionist terms, as that which will make our world bigger, with space ‘discovery’ expanding human knowledge, space is also conceived of as that which will make the world smaller, in neo-liberal globalization terms, ‘by reconfiguring capitalism and nationalism’ (Casper and Moore 1995: 315). The US ‘warfighting’ discourse is also at odds with much so-called ‘space law’, in particular the Outer Space Treaty (1967), which defines space as the ‘province of all mankind’ and asks that states act ‘with due regard to the corresponding interests of States Parties to the Treaty’ (Brearly 2005: 16-17). Within the US itself, congressionally-led efforts to discuss and minimize the threats posed by human-made debris caught in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), of which there is somewhere in the region of 2,300 metric tons (ibid.: 9), appear ill-matched with any clear efforts by US government to increase the weaponization of space. The US cooperates, to a limited extent, in perpetuating a sustainable space environment for its satellite-based systems, to which space debris undoubtedly poses a threat, because of this direct individual benefit to US commercial interests. The US refuses, however, to ratify the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT), prohibiting all use of nuclear weapons in space, since this constitutes a restriction of its ability to develop and test ‘new’ weapons. US critics of the CTBT contend that ratifying the treaty would ‘undercut confidence in the US deterrent’ and thus increase ‘the incentive for rogue states to obtain nuclear weapons’ (Medalia 2006: 13). All this is not to argue that dominant ‘scientific’ and ‘commercial’ justifications for space exploration, which are perhaps less overtly related to the militarization of space (for example, concerning advances in medicine, molecular and cellular biology, geology, weather forecasting, robotics, electronics and so on), do not in their basic assumptions also embody a gendered sense of ‘man’s natural right to colonize so-called unknown territory (see, e.g. Morabito 2005). The ‘quest for knowledge’ remains deeply embedded in Western accounts of the need for space colonization (as Bush’s 2004 speech makes clear), rationalized from humanity’s so-called ‘natural’ desire to explore and conquer (cf. Bush 2004; Crawford 2005; Mendell 2005). Crawford in proposing a case for the ‘scientific and social’ importance of human space exploration, suggests that, there are reasons for believing that as a species Homo sapiens is genetically predisposed towards exploration and the colonization of an open frontier. Access to such a frontier, at least vicariously, may be in some sense psychologically necessary for the long-term wellbeing of human societies. (Crawford 2005: 260)