Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Space Awareness both presumes and reinforces a hegemonic and masculine Cartesian subject

Deerfield, 2016. (Kat, PhD in Critical and Cultural Theory, Cardiff University UK, “Heavenly Bodies: Gender and Sexuality in Extra-Terrestrial Culture,” Dissertation, http://orca.cf.ac.uk/93157/ spp)

As I argue, the positioning of the astronaut as a scientific and exploratory figure is integrally linked to the positioning of this figure’s perspective, both literal and metaphorical. Much of the discourse of space culture is centred on the experiences of astronauts looking from space at Earth, an experience which evokes issues of the geographic and cartographic subject. For this reason, I contend that analysis of spatial subjectivity is a productive contribution to analysis of the influence of gender on space culture. To analyse this, I will employ work from spatial theory on observation, perspective, and the geographic and cartographic subject. Gillian Rose’s Feminism and Geography: The Limits of Geographical Knowledge forms an important part of my analysis, as does the work of Kathleen M. Kirby.1 Theoretical Grounding[:] Rose’s Feminism and Geography is a detailed account of the influence of gendered ideology in the discipline of geography. As such, Rose’s work seeks not the geographic distribution of women, nor even women’s use of space, but the underlying structural limitations which have historically led to the privileging of a male subject in spatial theory.2 Rose explains that her focus is not on ‘the geography of gender, but [...] the gender of geography’, a concept to which I will pay more critical attention later in this chapter.3 I argue that Rose’s work has important implications for the analysis of gendered structures in work on outer space. Kirby’s work on the cartographic subject similarly illuminates the underlying gendered structure of the field itself. Her ‘Re:Mapping Subjectivity: Cartographic Vision and the Limits of Politics’ expands upon broader scholarship on the hegemonic construction of the Cartesian subject to examine the spatial aspect of the development of this subject. This development, Kirby argues, ‘was – and continues to be – inextricably tied to a specific concept of space and the technologies invented for dealing with that space’.4 Kirby explores this concept through analysis of Enlightenment perspectives on the bounded self – the border between inner, bodily space, and the spaces outside.5 Kirby explores the construction of this border through analysis of the discourse of cartography and the concept of ‘getting lost’. Kirby argues that ‘getting lost’ is a violation of the strict boundary between bodily interior and exterior for the cartographic subject, and further, this has important gendered implications which construct this subjectivity as a masculine one.6 Both Rose and Kirby pay attention to questions of perspective in their studies of spatial theory, and it is these questions to which I dedicate this chapter. As I will show, the perspective of an astronaut looking back at Earth is an important construction within human spaceflight.7 This construction is part of what leads me to analyse these texts from the perspective of earthbound spatial theory. I will further argue, using work by David Harvey on the origins of modern mapping, that the perspective that an astronaut possesses – that of an observer fully separated from the Earth itself – is not a new concept in spatial theory.8 Harvey argues that Western spatial discourse has privileged extra-terrestrial perspective since long before humans travelled into space. He describes the importance of this exact perspective in the development of Renaissance mapping, and its roots in Ptolemaic thought: [...] in designing the grid in which to locate places, Ptolemy had imagined how the globe as a whole would look to a human eye looking at it from outside. A number of implications then follow. The first is an ability to see the globe as a knowable totality. [...] A second implication is that [...] it seemed as if space, though infinite, was conquerable and containable for purposes of human occupancy and action.9 Harvey argues that the very foundations of modern mapping can be traced to the concept that the ideal observer is one entirely separate from Earth, so that he can see and know every part of the planet. I refer to this figure as he knowingly, for as I will further explore using the work of Rose and Kirby, this construction of a detached observer is associated with masculine subjectivity. In this chapter I analyse cultural artefacts which span a fairly broad cross-section of space culture, including narratives of astronaut experience, philosophical work on astronautic vision, and some visual corporate branding from the commercial space company Virgin Galactic. I use my chosen theoretical texts to illustrate how gender, spatiality, and perspective inform the discourse around spaceflight at multiple sites within space culture. I argue that ultimately, the perspective occupied by astronauts is one that is so key to development of Western spatial theory that this perspective is not extricable from the historical male dominance of all of Western spatial thought.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.