Space observation is the male gaze – masculine astronauts are observers with agency whereas the feminine is observable
Deerfield, 2016. (Kat, PhD in Critical and Cultural Theory, Cardiff University UK, “Heavenly Bodies: Gender and Sexuality in Extra-Terrestrial Culture,” Dissertation, http://orca.cf.ac.uk/93157/ spp)
As I will show, much of space discourse assumes that viewing the earth from outside it is a new phenomenon, unique to the field of spaceflight. Frank White’s book The Overview Effect: Space Exploration and Human Evolution is a prominent investigation of the importance ascribed to astronautic vision in contemporary culture, although, as I will argue, White’s perspective is uncritical of this importance.10 White suggests that the experience of seeing Earth from a truly outside perspective is a new stage in human cultural evolution, and that this has a far- reaching, positive impact upon the development of human consciousness. Further, he claims that a perspective of Earth from space will lead people to ‘take for granted philosophical insights that have taken those on Earth thousands of years to formulate’, because their extra- terrestrial perspective will so deeply impact upon their ‘mental processes and views of life’.11 However, as I will show, the idealisation of an outside perspective on the Earth is not unique to the discourse of spaceflight. Further, I argue that its deep historical roots in the development of spatial subjectivity suggest that it is not, as White argues, inherently progressive. Toward this point, I will argue that the historical construction of extra-terrestrial perspective in geography and cartography relates to the gendered construction of the spatial subject, as identified by Rose and Kirby. As a further example of the effects of the discourse of astronaut perspective, I also analyse a creative image from the space industry: the image of a fictional woman astronaut, ‘Galactic Girl’, part of the visual branding of Virgin Galactic’s space tourism programme. In analysing this image, I will engage further with Rose’s work on gendered aspects of subjectivity, specifically within the context of astronautics. As I discussed in the Introduction, the incorporation of visual artefacts is an important aspect of my method of analysis, and Galactic Girl is a particularly interesting example in that it is situated firmly within the space industry. I discussed in Chapter Two how the lines between art and spaceflight can be unclear, and with Galactic Girl I maintain that as part of the design of spacecraft, this is an example of both how these lines can be blurred and how such artefacts can be an important part of a critical analysis of the broader culture of spaceflight. While I argue that aspects of astronaut experience problematize ideas of subjectivity and gaze for all astronauts (a topic to which I will return in Chapter Four), I further argue that the figure of the female astronaut represents a particular challenge to idealised subjectivity. In analysing the image of Galactic Girl, I aim to demonstrate how symbolism of women in space illustrates the impact of the ‘male gaze’ in the discourse of astronaut subjectivity.12 I argue that Rose’s discussion of a spatialised construction of masculine observer and feminine observee is represented in the discourse and visual culture of the space industry, particularly where gender is foregrounded. In exploring this figure I will additionally draw upon Debra Benita Shaw’s analysis of ‘The Space Suit as Cultural Icon’.13 Using Shaw’s work on space suits and the surrounding culture of spaceflight, I argue that the contrasts between real images of astronauts and the idealised image of Galactic Girl highlight the problematic nature of women in the popular discourse of spaceflight. I further argue that functional aspects of astronaut dress, particularly the space helmet, are symbolic of an unmarked, non-corporeal subject, and thus an idealised possessor of masculine gaze as identified by Rose.