Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Knowledge of and from space is part of an enlightenment project which privileges the white masculine perspective and violently crowds out all others

Deerfield, 2016. (Kat, PhD in Critical and Cultural Theory, Cardiff University UK, “Heavenly Bodies: Gender and Sexuality in Extra-Terrestrial Culture,” Dissertation, http://orca.cf.ac.uk/93157/ spp)

The concept that Rose employs of the ‘master subject’ of geographical knowledge is an important basis for my theoretical approach. Donna Haraway elucidates the meaning of this figure in her ‘Situated Knowledges’, in which Haraway describes it as possessing a ‘cyclopian, self-satiated eye’.15 As Haraway argues, the construction of the ‘master subject’ as the possessor of exhaustive and objective scientific knowledge is limited both in that it is imbued with a particular race (white) and gender (male) and also in that the goal of exhaustive objectivity is not achievable.16 Haraway claims that ‘only partial perspective promises objective vision’.17 In ‘Situated Knowledges’, Haraway calls for a feminist reclamation of the concepts of vision and perspective. Haraway argues that such reclamation can reincorporate the corporeality and the diversity of experience from which the ‘master subject’ of traditional scientific perspective attempts to distance itself. As I will explore later in this chapter, the perspective of spaceflight provides both examples of the construction of the ‘master subject’, and also opportunities to destabilise this concept, which I argue can contribute to the Haraway’s project of ‘Situated Knowledges’. Rose’s Feminism and Geography further elaborates on the way the ‘master subject’ figure has impacted upon the development of geography and the geographic subject. Toward this end, in Feminism and Geography Rose makes a clear and succinct statement of her approach as one which concerns the gender of geography, rather than the subject of gender within traditional geographic discourse.18 In other words, Rose is interested in analysing the discipline itself for gendered attributes, not using the discipline as its stands to discuss gender issues. This is an important distinction not only for this chapter, but also for all that follows it, as I will discuss in my introduction to Part Two. For the purposes of this chapter however, it is particularly important because it relates to Rose’s further discussion of the ‘master subject’ of the geographic discipline. Rose and the Gender of Geography[:] In applying the concept of the ‘master subject’ to geography specifically, Rose illuminates how the field itself has insidiously privileged one particular perspective at the expense of all others. The key problem with this which Rose identifies is the construction of all perspectives, save the privileged ‘master subject’, as primarily characterised by their difference from the norm. Rose defines this subject in relation to geography as ‘a white, bourgeois, heterosexual man’, who, in the development of the discipline, sought primarily to ‘render the world amenable to the operation of masculinist reason’.19 The ideal of this geographic ‘masculinist reason’ is a way of knowing, and a knowledge, which can be generally applied. Rose writes: ‘Geographers desire knowledge of the whole world, but, more importantly for their claims to power through knowledge, they also desire a whole knowledge of the world.’20 This ‘knowledge of the whole world’ has clear implications for spaceflight; for, as I will discuss further in this chapter, what better way to see the whole Earth than to see it from outer space? The goal of ‘whole knowledge of the world’ reveals the privileging of one, unmarked perspective; through the construction of the ‘master subject’, this can only ever be a masculine perspective, and a perspective which intrinsically denies the value of any other.21 I argue that both of these aspects of what Rose terms ‘masculinist reason’ have important implications for analyses of the discourse of spaceflight. This also has a clear relationship to Harvey’s claim about ‘the globe as a knowable totality’. Taking both Harvey and Rose into account along with Haraway, it is clear that the subjectivity which seeks what Rose calls ‘knowledge of the whole world’ and ‘whole knowledge of the world’ is historically coded as a masculine subject. That the perspective granted to an extra-terrestrial observer is discussed in such similar ways as the traditional construction of geographic subjectivity contributes, I argue, to the male dominance of human spaceflight. In addition, in Rose’s work on the history of the masculinist geographic subject, she argues that ‘denial of...corporeality’ is central to the subject’s self-definition. As she further argues, this denied corporeality is applied to the construction of the Other, including women, and the denial functions to reinforce the masculinity of this subject.22

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.