Realism replicates a protector/protected relationship that sustains authoritarian state practices, masks protector violence, and justifies intervention by some to protect others from other others.
Claire Duncanson & Catherine Eschle (2008), University of Edinburgh and University of Strathclyde, “Gender and the Nuclear Weapons State: A Feminist Critique of the UK Government's White Paper on Trident , New Political Science, 30:4, 545-563, DOI: 10.1080/07393140802518120
Feminists in IR problematize the Realist approach to security on several grounds. Most obviously, they question why military threats from other states (or, more recently, from terrorist groups) are considered more important and immediate than the threat to human life posed by poverty, HIV/AIDS, environmental destruction or domestic abuse, all of which are claimed to disproportionately affect women. As a corollary, they challenge the Realist reliance on destructive military technology, insisting that welfare budgets do more to provide genuine security for women than increased defence spending.46 Feminists also seek to undermine the view that security is something which can be possessed or guaranteed by the state. Instead, they have urged us to understand security as a process, immanent in our relationships with others, and always partial, elusive, and contested. Conceived in this way, it must involve subjects—including women—in the provision of their own security.47 Two gendered aspects of Realist conceptions of security are particularly important for our purposes. First, Realists correlate security with invulnerability, invincibility and impregnability. This is strongly evident in the White Paper. It is claimed, for example, that: The rationale for continuous deterrent patrolling (which the UK has maintained since 1969) . . . is that the submarine on patrol is invulnerable to an attack. For example, we are confident that our SSBNs [Ballistic Missile Submarines] on deterrent patrol have remained completely undetected by a hostile or potentially hostile state. This means we have an assured nuclear deterrent available at all times.48 As Susannah Radstone has argued, however, invulnerability is an unachievable fantasy with obviously gendered connotations. It is the female body that is penetrated and impregnated while the male body remains, or ought to remain, intact and impermeable.49 Moreover, as argued above, nuclear technologies do not operate in a social vacuum. They are created and operated by humans and, as such, there can be no guarantees of infallibility. Indeed, the world may be decidedly less secure when submarines armed with nuclear missiles are continuously on patrol, but the emphasis in the White Paper on protection through superior technology makes this possibility unthinkable. Second, and perhaps more important, Realist views of security cast the state and its military wing as “protector” and civilians within the state as “protected,” a dichotomy which is profoundly gendered. Judith Hicks Stiehm, for instance, highlights the historical association of the protector role with men and the protected role with women; further, she claims that the protector role gains meaning and status precisely through its privileging over those who are feminised as vulnerable.50 As Iris Marion Young put it more recently: The role of the masculine protector puts those protected, paradigmatically women and children, in a subordinate position of dependence and obedience. To the extent that citizens of a democratic state allow their leaders to adopt a stance of protectors toward them, these citizens come to occupy a subordinate status like that of women in the patriarchal household. We are to accept a more authoritarian and paternalistic state power, which gets its support partly from the unity a threat produces and our gratitude for protection.51 Although recent years have seen the increasing integration of women into the armed forces in many developed states, the resistance to this process and the anomalies to which it gives rise demonstrate for many feminists that this gendering of roles around protection still runs deep.52 Furthermore, the gendered protector/protected dichotomy still works in symbolic terms. Thus discourses of state protection remain saturated with constructions of “masculine autonomy (freedom, control, heroics) and feminine dependency (passivity, vulnerability, woman as adored but also despised).”53 Moreover, feminists and others have pointed out that security discourse involves an enforced linkage between the protector and protected in the face of an external threat. For Stiehm this functions to mask the fact that the biggest danger to the protected may actually not come from outside the state but from the hyper- masculinised protectors themselves.54 More recent post-structuralist-influenced work has made this relationship between the state and an external threat in Realist thought, or between state identity and “the Other,” central to their analyses. Although “the Other” may seem radically different from “us,” for post- structuralists, it is our understanding of the Other which in part constitutes the self.55 As feminists then point out, the self – other dichotomy frequently has gendered, as well as sexualised and racialised, dimensions. That the Other is frequently feminised, serving to underpin a masculine or hyper-masculine response, can be seen in examples ranging from colonial conceptions of virgin territories populated by compliant, exotic populations, to the treatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib.56 Alternatively, “the Other” may be portrayed as having a deficient, gross masculinity in contrast to the rationality and restraint of “ourselves.”57 Thus different kinds of masculinities may be mobilised in security discourses, serving to differentiate a particular state government in the eyes of its population from its enemies and to legitimate its protector role.