Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hegemonic Masculinity locks in the gender binary, essentialism, and hierarchies that make militarism and gendered violence inevitable

Sjoberg and Via 2010 Gender, War, and Militarism: Feminist Perspectives By Laura Sjoberg, Sandra Via. https://books.google.com/books?id=om3yy1JoS34C&printsec=frontcover&dq=Gender,+War,+and+Militarism:+Feminist+Perspectives:+Feminist+Perspectives&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiltpftm8HjAhWGXc0KHYOLAwMQ6AEIKjAA#v=onepage&q=Gender%2C%20War%2C%20and%20Militarism%3A%20Feminist%20Perspectives%3A%20Feminist%20Perspectives&f=false. Laura Sjoberg is Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Florida. Her research addresses issues of gender and security, with foci on politically violent women, feminist war theorizing, sexuality in global politics, and political methodology. Sandra E. Via Assistant Professor of Political Science. B.A., Ferrum College M.A., Virginia Tech Ph.D., Virginia Tech. ADW

MILITARISM AND HEGEMONIC MASCULINITY Feminists have identified the realm of international security as being dominated by masculine values and norms (Tickner 2001; Sjoberg 2009). Particularly, in the international security realm, values associated with masculinities (e.g., strength, rationality, autonomy) are prized over values associated with femininities (weakness, emotion, interdependence) (Tickner 1992). Within this dichotomy, there is a power hierarchy between different masculinities and different femininities such that an ideal-typical masculinity sits on top of a gendered hierarchy of traits in the international arena (Connell 1995; Hooper 2001). Feminist scholars have identified this ideal-typical masculinity as "hegemonic masculinity" (Connell 1995). Hegemonic masculinity refers to certain masculine norms and values that have become dominant in specific institutions of social control and remain in those institutions to maintain patriarchal social and political orders (Kronsell 2005, 281; Tickner 1992, 6). The dominance of hegemonic masculinity in international security is related to but not reliant on the overrepresentation of men in positions of political and defense leadership (Pettman 1996). Masculinities are prized in political and military leadership, even when that leadership is performed by women. The dominance of hegemonic masculinity relies on its opposition to and competition with subordinated masculinities and femininities. Hegemonic masculinities at once promote a particular organization of the political order and reinforce unequal relationships between men and women in order to promote the legitimation of masculine authority (Tickner 1992, 6). Charlotte Hooper explains, "as masculinity is the valued term, it can be argued that femininity is merely a residual category, a foil or Other for masculinity to define itself against" (Hooper 2001, 43). Values associated with masculinity are prized only insomuch as they are superior to values associated with femininity (Hooper 2001, 43). A man's (or anyone's) claim to masculinity, therefore, is a positional claim in opposition to a feminine other that society has constructed to be the lesser of the two binaries. Without the existence of an individual or group that can be labeled as the weaker party, masculine social norms would be without content. Masculine social norms in international politics are particularly evident in militarized institutions, which are structured around gendered, hierarchical relationships both within the institutions and in their accomplishment of their missions (Tickner 1992). The term "militarization" is used to denote when "militaristic values (e.g., a belief in hierarchy, obedience, and the use of force)" are adopted by states, organizations, individuals, corporations, and so on (Enloe 2007, 4). Feminists have associated militarism, masculinity, and wartime hero narratives, arguing that militaristic behavior is a path by which men and masculine states can prove their masculinity (Huston 1983, 271; Sjoberg 2006b). Idealized masculinities for soldiers throughout history have included characteristics associated with aggression, bravery, courage, service, precision, and protection (Hooper 2001, 81). Idealized militarized masculinities are social, but they are also physical, where militarics emphasize the soldiers' physical strength, particularly upper body strength, by means of training exercises and certain areas of specialization within militaries (i.e., the Navy SEALS, Army Rangers). Many militaristic cultures emphasize the physical and social traits of a soldier in opposition to femininity. These accounts emphasize the importance of physical and upper body strength, framing soldiering in opposition to women's "natural" lack of upper body strength and other physical capabilities (Miller 1998). If "men" are physically capable of soldiering and physical incapacity to soldier is feminized, then both the "sex" (male / female) and "gender" (masculine/ feminine) compositions of militaries are overdetermined. Other characteristics associated with masculinity and valued by the process of militarization (such as stoicism and rationality) also masculinize militarism. Ultimately, soldiering is related to and inseparable from masculinity, where masculinity is proved by soldiering, which is reliant on preexisting (assumed) masculinity. The conceptual and actual interdependence of masculinity and soldiering does not mean women are excluded from the practice or profession of soldiering. As feminists have noted, women are increasingly both professional and recruited soldiers (Enloe 2004; Sasson-Levy 2003). Still, women do not enter militaries that are suddenly degendered or gender- neutral because of their presence (Enloe 2000; Sjoberg 2007). Instead, like their male counterparts, many women soldiers are being asked to prove their masculinity in terms of physical prowess and military-favored social characteristics (Cohn 2000). At the same time, military recruiting ads that feature women show a double standard, where women are required to exhibit the capabilities and traits associated with masculinity while maintaining feminine appearance (including high heels, makeup, and jewelry) (Brown 2006). As several female soldiers have described, they are expected to emulate (and even exceed) masculine gender characteristics, and challenged not to show any of the perceived weaknesses associated with femininity, all while walking a gender-role tightrope where they do not deconstruct the gender dichotomies on which sociopolitical relation- ships are founded. Many militaries remain gendered not only in the personality characteristics they select for but also in the experiences of women who are a part of those organizations. Many military organizations exclude women from combat roles (Komblum 1984; l-lorrigan 1992). Many militaries have high levels of sexual violence perpetrated by male soldiers against female soldiers and other implicit and explicit sexually discriminatory policies (Morris 1996). Other military organizations construct soldiering in opposition to militarized feminized roles, such as military wives (Enloe 1990; Horn, chapter 4, this volume) and civilians (Elshtain 1987; Kinsella 2005; Sjoberg 2006a). The role of military wife involves a willingness to relocate quickly and frequently, self-sufficiency to raise children and take care of the home when the soldier is sent on a tour of duty, support for male troops and other military wives, and service as motivation for the soldier to fight well and return home safely. In these militarized feminine roles, women must act and perform as (stereotypical) women (Enloe 1990). Cynthia Enloe documents the extent to which women, "acting as women," are essential to the success of a military. A large part of the gendered roles in and around militarization can be accounted for by understanding the centrality of hero narratives to both soldiering and Citizenship. In these narratives, the heroic warrior defends the feminized other for the good of self, family, and country (Huston 1983; Elshtain 1987; Young 2003). In this social structure, men are not only honored as citizen-warriors but are also bound to fight when called upon (Goldstein 2001), while women serve as biological and social reproducers of the nation generally and soldiers specifically (Yuval-Davis 1987).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.