And, our knowledge production is disruptive - exposes and opposes the hegemonic masculinity of dominant IR theory
Marks, 2011 (Michael Marks, Professor of Politics at Willamette University, PhD in Government from Cornell, Metaphors in International Relations Theory, 2011, pp. 3-8; spp)
It is increasingly apparent that what is known about international relations is not so much a universally shared agreement about objective realities but rather a reflection of dominant ways of knowing that frame issues and debates not to mention the empirical bases of international affairs. The constructivist paradigm is probably the most prominent and most explicit school of thought in its acknowledgement that the empirical bases of world affairs can be conceptualized theoretically such that different visions of reality can be constructed. However, it is not the only approach in the study of international relations that advances claims about the discursive framing by which the facts of international relations are conceived. As Jim George (1994) asserts, all of the major theoretical perspectives in IR advance a discursive project that sets out what is conceivable in the study of international relations. Metaphors are just one set of discursive tools with which the factual bases of international relations can be represented in the theories that are used to conceptualize world affairs. As John Agnew (2007, 138) observes, knowledge about any subject (but for Agnew’s purpose as well as ours, knowledge about international relations) can be defined as “explanatory schemes, frames of reference, crucial sets of assumptions, narrative traditions, and theories.” Agnew (ibid.) further states that “a great deal of interpretive projection is the result of the imposition of intellectual/political hegemonies from some places onto others.” Thus, whether they are metaphors or any of the other means for constructing knowledge available to scholars, what is known at any given time or in any given place about international relations is reflective of how knowledge about a subject is formulated. One of the main theses of this book is that metaphors in international relations theory do far more than simply supply evocative imagery to explanatory frameworks. Instead, a major contention of this study is that the generally accepted paradigms that are used to analyze international relations are built on metaphorical imagery that provides the very theoretical propositions these paradigms use to hypothesize and make predictions about international affairs. It is now generally agreed that metaphors play an integral role in human cognition. Most, if not all, human thought is metaphorical in the sense that humans use metaphors to recognize patterns and relationships among concrete and conceptual categories. Language reflects the inclination of humans to use metaphors in understanding the world, and thus both everyday language and the vocabulary of theoretical reasoning alike are built on the metaphorical images that people use to recognize similarities and differences in what they encounter in both the old and the new. Metaphors in theory of any sort can be casual, for example, the image of a metaphorical “big bang” that physicists employ to visualize the origins of the “universe” (itself, a metaphor), or integral, for example, the metaphor of economic “cycle” on which entire schools of thought are devoted in the field of economics. In international relations theory, the ontological assumptions and epistemological methods of the various paradigmatic approaches are suffused with metaphors. For example, Vincent Pouliot (2007, 362) observes that the structure-functionalist approach to the study of international relations is distinguished by its “talk of systems, equilibriums, and structures,” each of which is a metaphorical image that constructs what is knowable using this approach. By the same token, Pouliot (362) points out that the contending Constructivist approach “has its own dialect full of social constructions, norms, and identities,” which are also metaphorical in nature Some of these metaphors are obvious, while others, due to either their repeated use or mundane quality, go largely unnoticed and undetected by scholars in the field. Metaphors in IR theory used deliberately to generate hypotheses can eventually become reified to the extent that they lose their heuristic nature, while metaphors used casually often are not investigated with regard to their validity for giving insight into the subject matter at hand. Throughout the course of this book readers will discover that the vast majority of the terms cataloguing, defining, and naming theories, concepts, and analytical tools pertaining to the study of international relations are metaphorical in nature. The reader may then be prompted to ask, if that is the case, what is not a metaphor in international relations theory and, if the answer is very little to nothing, what is the point of highlighting what could then be thought of as unavoidable elements in the scholarly discipline at hand? As the next chapter will explain, it is a fact that no realm of human cognition is devoid of metaphorical imagery, including every academic discipline. It is because of this that the choice, conscious or not, of metaphors that aid in any theoretical process has consequences for what empirical topics are studied, what assumptions underlie these inquiries, and what theoretical propositions are put to the test. Since no sustained attention has been paid to this endeavor in the past, it is helpful to undertake an examination of metaphors in IR theory to see what impact they have on the field. To give the reader a sense of how metaphors operate in international relations theory it is useful to start with an example that demonstrates the ubiquity of metaphor in IR though. International relations are said to be governed by certain “structures.” “Structure” is a term that typically implies physical qualities. Thus, initially, “structure” was simply a way to suggest certain metaphorical physical constraints on states and other international actors. Today, however, it is used literally as a descriptor for that which defines world affairs. Continual use of metaphorical term in any context tends to give what once was a metaphor the appearance of being literally true. Regardless of the intentions of scholars, and leaving entirely aside the question of whether or not there is an objective reality that people agree on, as long as individuals have a choice in what language to use to describe something, the language that eventually is chosen is both inevitably metaphorical and influences the way concepts in international relations theory are framed. WHY METAPHORS MATTER Many of the metaphors that have been devised by scholars to frame the study of international relations are self-consciously seen as contrivances that help observers make inferences about how international relations works. For example, in introductory international relations classes, college students are frequently taught to think of the world metaphorically as a “billiard table” with states imagined as metaphorical “balls.” These billiards images ostensibly introduce students to the basic elements of traditional international relations theory. States are thought of metaphorically as “hard-shelled and impenetrable territorially sovereign states” (Opello and Rosow 19999, 226), and are said to have “interests [tat] are defined exogenously” in a “process [that] is characterized by intergovernmental bargaining and unlimited state interest” (Sjursen 2001, n.p.). In the billiard ball model there are no “good” states or “bad” states (Mearsheimer 1994-1995, 48), and “[o]nly the hard exteriors touch, and heavier or faster moving ones push others out of the way” (Burton 1972,28). There are other metaphorical contrivances for the milieu of international relations as well. For example, the “billiard ball” metaphor can be compared to the similar-sounding, albeit theoretically opposed, “’egg-box’ conception of international society,” whereby “the sovereign states are the eggs, the box is the international society and the purpose of the box is to ‘separate and cushion, not to act’” (Wheeler 1996, 126). The “web” or “cobweb” model challenges the billiard ball image of states as hard-shelled actors by promoting the vision of an international society in which relations among a variety of global action resemble the intertwined threads of a web-like matrix (Burton 1972, 35-45). Sometimes it seems as if the billiard ball image of international relations is the target for every other metaphor that challenges the theoretical implications of the billiard ball model. In their 2006 article – “Billiard Balls or Snowflakes?” – for example, Benjamin Fordham and Victor Asal (2007, 48) suggest that major powers be seen less as hard shelled impenetrable objects and more like metaphorical “snowflakes” “with many potentially relevant internal characteristics.” Other metaphors include the “burning house” vision of the international system and the “forest” image of an international system comprising homogenous states pictured metaphorically as “trees.” In recent years scholars have become rather creative in contriving metaphors to capture what they see as the nature of the milieu that constitutes the world of international relations. Robert Kaplan (1994, 75), for example, suggests the metaphor of a “hologram” to describe what he sees as the multifaceted nature of international relations. Examining the role of metaphors that frame the context of international relations is not a purely academic exercise. There are real-world implications for foreign policymaking of these metaphors as well. During her keynote address at the Citizen Diplomacy Summit in 2005, former U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright made the following metaphorical observation that reflected her view of foreign policy: As you may have seen, there are also many other surveys showing that international support for US foreign policy is at the lowest level since the Vietnam War. The main complaint is that we don’t take the interests of other countries into account and that we are too quick to use military force. How do we explain these perceptions? What can we do to change them? I thought about this and then decided that it helps to compare foreign policy to a game of pool. Everybody always talks about foreign policy as a game of chess, but that doesn’t work for me because chess is a very deliberate and slow game where you take a lot of time to make decisions. I’ve always thought that a pool table makes more sense because when one ball is hit it smacks into others and each of them caroms around and hits some more, just like our policy makers that start out in one direction, but end up going in six. Everything that happens has an effect on everything else, all of which leads us to a lot of unintended consequences. In this case it’s the invasion of Iraq that has rearranged the balls on the table… The worst days in fact may well lie ahead – but we can help the situation overall by going back to that pool table and starting some balls moving in a different direction. (Albright 2005a, 23 emphasis added) The Realist metaphorical imagery of these statements is unmistakable and could be recognized by any first-year student in a college introductory international relations class. Albright was speaking not as an academic but as a former senior policymaker in the U.S. foreign policy establishment. However, she was speaking not as a politician trying to frame an issue or gain popular support, but rather as a policymaker schooled in the theories of international relations. Madeleine Albright was one of the major architects of U.S. foreign policy during the administration of President Bill Clinton. Scholars can argue about the motivations of Albright and others in the U.S. foreign policy establishment at that time, but what emerges from the former Secretary of State’s 2005 observations is that her own thinking about the world has been shaped by the theoretical conclusions that follow from the billiard ball metaphor so closely associated with realist theory. One can presume that Secretary Albright had given a good deal of thought to the way she imagines the nature of international relations and that her pool table reference was not just an off-the-cuff remark. Rather, we can reasonably infer that the action taken by the Clinton administration were a direct reflection of the theoretical lens Madeleine Albright carried with her as Secretary of State. Armed with clues found in Albright’s billiard ball comments, scholars who had puzzled over the motivations of the framers of U.S. foreign policy during the Clinton administration now have a better ability to understand the theoretical roots of this policy. The conclusion to be drawn from this discussion is that metaphors that frame the context of international relations are not solely part of a purely theoretical endeavor. What constitutes the field of inquiry that falls under the rubric of international relations depends on what metaphorical perspectives shape the field. In light of this observation, this book adopts a critical perspective in analyzing the central metaphors in international relations. The term “critical” often is associated with approaches in international relations that reveal relationships of power among international actors that are concealed by traditional theoretical perspectives. This book takes a different posture, directing its attention not at international actors but at theories of international relations themselves. While it is true that many critical IR scholars have as their immediate target what they see as deficiencies in existing theoretical frameworks, for many of them the ultimate aim is to direct attention at how international affairs are constructed in ways that are not revealed by traditional theoretical approaches. In this book I am less critical of the subject matter of international relations inquiry than I am of the nature of international relations theory used to study it. I neither know nor suspect that there is something about international relations that is not revealed to IR scholars via traditional theoretical perspectives, including critical ones. Rather, I assume that how international relations is revealed reflects scholars’ own conceptual impressions that they experience through metaphors and convey to others through metaphorical expression. My purpose in this book is to critically examine metaphorical expression in international relations to see what that reveals about the theoretical propositions that characterize diverse scholarly traditions.