Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Mutually exclusive – the aff mobilizes the nation state towards battle – our alt tries to zap that militaristic energy

D’Costa, 2021 (Bina D'Costa is a Professor at the Department of International Relations, Coral Bell School of Asia-Pacific Affairs at the Australian National University. At the height of Europe’s refugee emergency, she moved to the UNICEF Office of Research-Innocenti to build its Migration and Displacement program (2016-2018). As a UN staff member, Bina has worked in South and Southeast Asia, Eastern and Southern Africa, and the Middle East. “Learning/unlearning in International Relations through the politics of margins and silence,” Australian Journal of International Affairs, 2021, Vol. 75, No. 6, 591-603; accessed through lib.umich.edu – Taylor and Francis Database; spp)

Feminist scholars observed that nationalist movements have extensively used gendered imagery that appeals to masculine heroes to defend their motherland (Elshtain 1987; Enloe 1990; Tickner 1994; Pettman 1996). Ann Tickner wrote, ‘Our identity as citizens depends on telling stories about and celebrating wars of independence or national liberation and other great victories in battle’ (Tickner 1994, 33). In Tickner’s articulation, national anthems are frequently war songs, just as holidays are celebrated with military parades and uniforms that recall great feats in past conflicts. Telling stories is central to the creation of this sort of identity where a common heroic past provides a symbolic meaning that supersedes all other memories in order to evoke loyalty only to the nation-state (Tickner 1994).2 Inspired by Pettman and Tickner’s framing, I turned my gaze to gendered violence in South Asia’s nationbuilding stories. I analysed 1947 Partition of India and 1971 War of Bangladesh through a gender justice lens. In my comparative analysis, I argued how pain, sadness and humiliation have a symbolic place in the formation of a heroic past. Past/present pain and humiliation are used to mobilise the nation, with individual pain being appropriated for the community’s political purposes. The experiences of marginalised group of people (for example, women, minorities, and young people) are either appropriated or completely erased in this dominant story. Neither their participation in national movements nor their suffering in wars has been recorded with a gender-sensitive tone; on the contrary, both have been subsumed in the construction of the official histories of their countries. Women, particularly those, who were subjected to rape and sexual violence, were marginalised, restricted and their bodies regulated for the nationbuilding project. Struggles over history, not only about how and what to remember, but also how and what to forget, have been manifested in official narratives of the nation-state. Women’s stories have been excluded from textbooks, and careful state propaganda about national wars and history is used to reconstruct memory. A pronounced departure from previous scholarship in feminist IR for me had been to describe nationbuilding processes as spontaneous and local community-driven, and distinct from statebuilding initiatives supported by the international community. I was more invested in learning about gender justice. The experiences of feminist scholars in IR have been one of persistent struggles not only in terms of exploring the role of gender in global politics but also in probing the ‘so what’ question. The exclusionary approaches by traditional IR contribute to the conceptualisation of ‘East and West’ that simultaneously tells the story of ‘who we are’ and ‘who is not us’. While a number of critical IR scholars are attentive to this bias, the gendered political discourse marginalises minorities, particularly women (but also colonised and therefore, feminised men) for a second time. Critical feminist scholars from Asia and the Pacific wrote about marginality of poverty-stricken communities, refugees, internally displaced populations, and religious and ethnic minorities (for a discussion, see D’Costa 2006). These groups are marginal because of their location on the boundaries of marginalised states, and are often silenced because of power inequality. The dual marginalisation of women (as members of marginalised communities and as members of the disadvantaged gender) makes the struggle for emancipatory and empowered ‘feminist futures’ even more complex. While critical feminist international relations expose women’s experiences of violence in conflicts, it may not always offer a framework of redress for victims and survivors. Crossing over to critical feminist international law we are better able to grasp how gender sensitive and gender responsive trial processes could provide women with some healing and some sense of justice.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.