Burden sharing sustains the alliance—equity is key
Keating 22 (Dave, American-European journalist writing for the World Politics Review, “NATO Finds a New Sense of Purpose in an Old Mission” 6/30/22 https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/trend-lines/30648/to-counter-russia-nato-gets-back-to-basics)
NATO leaders gathered this week at a summit in Madrid to adopt a New Strategic Concept, a framework that sets out the alliance’s core priorities for the next decade. But the Madrid gathering was in other ways historic, ushering in further expansion of the alliance after Turkey lifted its veto of Sweden’s and Finland’s membership bids. The U.S. also pledged to deploy more troops, warplanes and naval vessels as part of the alliance’s largest military buildup since the Cold War, in response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The ramifications of the summit will be most obvious on NATO’s eastern flank, with the announcement of a new, permanent headquarters in Poland and the bolstering of rotational deployments to the Baltic states. The dizzying details of NATO’s buildup in Europe mark a remarkable turnaround for an alliance that looked listless and even near collapse just a few years ago, when former U.S. President Donald Trump raised doubts about Washington’s commitment to NATO and French President Emmanuel Macron declared it “braindead.” Over the past few years, many expected the new strategic concept to pivot away from NATO’s original focus on defending Europe against Russia and instead turn the alliance’s sights on China and international terrorism. There was also considerable talk of building a European Defense Union that would give Washington’s European allies the autonomous capability to defend themselves without U.S. assistance. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24 changed all that, making it clear that in practical terms, Washington’s security umbrella is the only real defense option Europe has at this time. In the span of a few months, NATO went from being considered a Cold War relic badly in need of a reboot to being an essential collective defense alliance that must double down on its original intent. The New Strategic Concept adopted yesterday by NATO leaders mentions Russia 17 times. By comparison, it mentions China 10 times and terrorism seven times, while Afghanistan is mentioned only once. The last strategic concept, signed in 2010 in the presence of then-Russian President Dimitry Medvedev, referred to Russia as a “strategic partner.” Fast forward 12 years, and the new strategic concept has reclassified Russia as a major threat to world peace. As for China, it is deemed a source of “systemic challenges” with which the alliance “remain[s] open to constructive engagement,” as some alliance members objected to labeling it a “threat.” Nevertheless, the newfound enthusiasm for NATO will not paper over difficult realities that the war in Ukraine has done nothing to ameliorate. European leaders appear to know that Biden’s Atlanticism is more likely a blip for Washington than a “return to normal,” as Trump or someone just as skeptical of U.S. security commitments like NATO could win the presidency in 2024. Former Trump aides have said he planned to withdraw the U.S. from NATO had he won reelection to a second term in office. For their part, Western European leaders were keen to stress at the Madrid summit that proposals for an autonomous European defense are not being abandoned, nor are they meant to compete with NATO. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen noted that NATO will become “more European” with the accession of Finland and Sweden into the alliance. If their bids are successful, only four EU member states will not also be members of the alliance: Ireland, Austria and Malta, all of which have longstanding positions of neutrality, and Cyprus, because of Turkey’s veto. The EU’s eastern members, however, remain wary of an autonomous European defense mechanism for fear that it will undermine NATO. They were likely reassured by this week’s summit, which gave new impetus to getting NATO back to its core mission of countering Russian aggression. For those who harbor the long-term ambition of creating an equitable alliance, rather than one that effectively functions as a U.S. protectorate, more work on European defense will be needed.