Doing both collapses credible leverage – that encourages free-riding and risk-taking from NATO members, increases the risk of war
Blankenship 18 (Professor of Political Science at the University of Miami in Coral Gables, PhD political science at Columba, MPhil & MA political science at Columbia “Promises under Pressure: Reassurance and Burden-Sharing in Asymmetric Alliances,” Columbia University PhD dissertation, https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/download/fedora_content/download/ac:b8gtht76k9/content/Blankenship_columbia_0054D_14562.pdf, Published 2018)
In a May 2017 visit to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) headquarters, U.S. President Donald Trump declined to affirm his support of NATO’s Article 5, which obligates its members to come to each others’ defense.4 Indeed, this was no accident; in his speech, Trump deliberately removed a passage expressing his support for Article 5.5 U.S. allies – as well as members of Trump’s own administration – were taken aback, with German Chancellor Angela Merkel arguing that it was time for Europeans to “really take our fate into our own hands.”6 In the wake of the uproar surrounding Trump’s speech – and his treatment of allies more generally – one question that has largely been neglected is why one should even expect the United States to reassure its allies in the first place. Indeed, reassurance is fundamentally puzzling because it surrenders a key source of bargaining power: the threat of abandonment. Bargaining leverage within an alliance depends on the credibility of states’ threats to abandon their partners, and thus great power patrons should limit the extent to which they are perceived as committed to their allies (Snyder, 1997; Jervis, 1997: ch. 5; Crawford, 2003).7 Reassurance measures, however, are intended to have exactly the opposite effect. Why, then, would a patron deliberately weaken its bargaining position? Other stands of literature similarly suggest that reassurance can have undesirable consequences. Theories on defense burden-sharing in asymmetric alliances stress that as long as a great power’s protection is relatively assured, allies have little incentive to increase their military contributions (Olson and Zeckhauser, 1966; Oneal, 1990; Palmer, 1990a,b; Sandler, 1993). By reassuring them, the patron effectively encourages its allies to free-ride. Furthermore, reassuring allies can run the risk of moral hazard. Allies confident in their patron’s support may be prone to take risks such as confronting their adversaries because they expect that the patron will bail them out, thus increasing the probability that the patron will be entrapped or entangled in allies’ conflicts (Christensen and Snyder, 1990; Fearon, 1997; Posen, 2014). In the years leading up to World War I, for example, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Sazonov cautioned against reassuring Serbia of Russia’s support too strongly, lest the Serbian government be encouraged to take a more intransigent stance vis-à-vis its territorial disputes with Austria-Hungary. He lamented that this was rendered more challenging by the attitudes of other senior Russian officials – including the ambassador to Serbia – whose support for Serbia’s pan-Slavic ambitions in the Balkans ran the risk of encouraging Serbian adventurism (Jelavich, 1991: 244-245, 250). The puzzle of reassurance is only magnified in asymmetric alliances. In his seminal book, Waltz (1979) argues that unlike in symmetric alliances between great powers, where each ally is a crucial component of the overall balance of power, in asymmetric alliances weak states are comparatively much less important, as their allegiance is less likely to influence the course of a war. Recent scholarship suggests that great powers can shape their alliance treaties and withhold support from their allies as a means of reducing the risks of moral hazard (Kim, 2011a; Benson, 2012; Mattes, 2012). Beckley (2015: 19), for one, claims that the United States “is unlikely to incur major costs to display loyalty to allies that depend on U.S. protection and patronage for their survival,” as none of its allies are inherently important for its own security. This asymmetry becomes even more pronounced in bipolar and unipolar systems, where the gap between the capabilities of the superpowers and other states is even wider and small states have even fewer patrons to choose from (Snyder, 1997; Kim, 2016). It may be understandable, then, that Walt (2005: 242) would conclude: “the credibility of U.S. commitments is not [the United States’] problem”; rather, it is “a problem for those who are dependent on U.S. help.” Yet Trump’s treatment of allies has come as such a surprise because reassuring allies has, in fact, been historically common in U.S. foreign policy. Former U.S. Secretary of Defense James Schlesinger, for one, argued that “both the size and the specific elements of [American] forces are driven more by the need to reassure those that we protect under the nuclear umbrella than by U.S. requirements alone” (Murdock et al., 2009: 9). Since 1945, the United States has stationed hundreds of thousands of troops on allied soil, and U.S. officials make countless foreign visits and public statements to demonstrate interest in and support for American partners (Lebovic and Saunders, 2016). Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter, for example, made such an effort to communicate U.S. commitment through numerous overseas trips that the New York Times dubbed him the “secretary of reassurance” in the summer of 2015.8Indeed, the historical record is replete with examples of weaker allies extracting support despite their patron’s reluctance. U.S. policymakers during the early years of the Cold War, for example, did not envision the U.S. troop presence in Europe as permanent, with Dwight Eisenhower arguing that “If in ten years, all American troops stationed in Europe for national defense purposes have not been returned to the United States, then this whole project will have failed” (Sheetz, 1999: 32). Nevertheless, allies resisted American withdrawal, leading to what Zimmermann (2009) calls the “improbable permanence” of the U.S. troop presence. Similarly, East Germany was able to pressure a reluctant Soviet Union into building the Berlin Wall by threatening to align itself more closely with China (Harrison, 2005; Crump, 2015). However, reassurance remains understudied in the scholarly literature. Academic studies often treat great power patrons’ use of reassurance as a byproduct of deterrence, where the primary intended audiences are adversaries (Schelling, 1966; Morgan, 1983; Benson, Meirowitz, and Ramsay, 2014; McManus, 2017). To the extent that the academic literature has considered reassurance, it has largely been in the context of how states reassure their allies rather than why. Policy prescriptions, for their part, tend to either deny the importance of reassurance (e.g., Posen, 2014) or assume its importance and focus on how to reassure allies (e.g., Flournoy and Davidson, 2012).9 As a result, existing literature has not offered a theory of reassurance. 1.2 ArgumentIn this dissertation, I address the following questions: What explains variation in great powers’ use of reassurance measures toward allies? And under what conditions can patrons make their protection conditional on allied burden-sharing? Here, I define reassurance as acts made by a patron that are intended to convince an ally that its assistance will be forthcoming in the event of an attack from another state. In other words, assurances are intended to reduce allies’ fears of patron abandonment.10 The theory I present here is intended to be generalizeable; however, for reasons discussed below I focus on American alliances. Thus I use the terms “patron” and “United States” interchangeably. Although reassurance can have adverse consequences, patrons have incentives to reassure to the extent that allies can credibly threaten to exit the alliance. By exit, I refer to attempts by states in an alliance to loosen themselves from the partnership by pursuing outside options. In its most extreme form, alliance exit can take the form of treaty abrogation, allying with a hostile third party, or a refusal to provide support in wartime. More commonly, patrons fear that their allies will take more incremental steps that allow them to distance themselves from the alliance by exploiting outside options. The more credible an ally’s threat to pursue outside options, and the more costs that doing so would impose on the patron, the more incentive patrons have to reassure allies. Patrons face a dilemma, trading off between withholding reassurance to drive hard bargains and reduce free-riding, on the one hand, and reassuring allies to discourage them from pursuing outside options, on the other. This dilemma can be mitigated, however, if a patron can make its assurances conditional on allied burden-sharing by combining its assurances with threats of abandonment. Like those of its allies, the patron’s threats are more potent to the extent that they are both credible and salient to its allies. Thus, reassurance and burden-sharing are the product of bargaining, where each side’s leverage is shaped by its threat of exit. Studying the effects of exit, however, is difficult owing to the issue of endogeneity. An ally’s desire for outside options may be a function of its patron’s behavior – including its use of reassurance (or lack thereof) – and states are also likely to anticipate the risk of exit and tailor their actions accordingly. As such, I look at factors affecting the propensity of patrons and allies to exit.