Lack of burden sharing causes entrapment—encourages allies to act aggressively because they don’t bear the cost
Zannella, 20 [Anthony Zannella Seton Hall University, majored in Political Science and Philosophy, 4-7-2020 "An Analysis of Burden Sharing in NATO and the Problem of Free Riding," Political Analysis: Vol. 21 , Article 5, https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1058&context=pa# /alundy]
Discussions of free riding within NATO on the American side argue that the United States is simply being fooled into providing defense. They believe the U.S. should be wary of supporting wealthy European nations that don’t want to spend as much on their militaries. Alan Tonelson’s early 2000s article highlighted this mood as he explored how changes in international geo-politics appear to be putting the U.S. at greater risk. Tonelson conveyed the risk associated with NATO through both material and non-material causes. He argued that U.S. actions leave the country exposed to more precarious situations. Tonelson mentioned that there is a greater risk that the U.S. can be dragged into “non-article 5” conflicts even though America’s original objective was to keep the power of Russia in check through its military presence. Tonelson pointed to the example that U.S. troops stationed in European countries are at risk of injury in an attack (particularly from terrorists or irregular forces) and could be stuck in the middle of an unnecessary conflict. Tonelson also pointed to Kosovo as an example: the U.S. was influenced to become involved simply to strengthen NATO’s credibility even though its European member nations were contributing far less to the alliance operations in comparison to those of the U.S. (Tonelson 2000). From a financial perspective, an earlier article written by Jyonni Khana and others indicates that alliance members in NATO, and in the U.N., are in fact free riding on larger nations such as the United States. The authors concluded that there is a wide gap in the equity of burden sharing. Their analysis focused heavily on peace keeping expenditures between 1976 and 1996. Jointproduct models and collective action theory were employed to study the financial contributions of the various countries. The level of fiscal support from the larger countries far outweighed those of the smaller nations and indicated a great level of free riding (Jyonni Khanna et al 1998). More recent studies have tried to take a more mixed methods approach; this is apparent in Jo Jakobson’s article. Jakobson attempted to draw on the collective action approach and the risk-responsibility sharing school. Jakobsen ultimately factored in the different variables both schools use, but he comes to differing conclusions. He started the study with the standard input measure, (where one looks at what countries put into the alliance alone) and it became obvious that European NATO free rides from this analytical perspective. Furthermore, Jakobsen found that non-material free riding can occur when a U.S. presence in the country of operations is significant as compared to its allies. A further observation demonstrated that other allied countries showed a low willingness to fight. He also mentioned that the importance of United States military spending has to do with other variables. The United States was engaged in various operations throughout the world, especially in Europe. The United States’ projection of power could essentially outweigh the lessened spending of European NATO allies. Jakobsen’s conclusion is to remain cautious when attempting to decipher whether European NATO in fact free rides (Jakobsen 2018).