Conditional alliance management avoids entrapment
Porter and Shifrinson 20, *Joshua R. Itzkowitz Shifrinson, an Assistant Professor of International Relations, Boston University, *Patrick Porter, Professor of International Security and Strategy at the University of Birmingham, also Senior Associate Fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, London and a Fellow of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft, “Why We Can’t Be Friends with Our Allies”, https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/10/22/why-we-cant-be-friends-with-our-allies-431015)
By falsely equating alliances with friendships, Biden and his team run serious risks. The rhetoric of friendship obscures the reality of U.S. foreign policy to the American people. For a campaign that prides itself on restoring the public’s trust in government, this is a serious problem, risking public backlash if Biden is elected while forgoing an opportunity to improve the quality of policy discussions.
Equally important, the approach risks undermining international stability by giving U.S. partners ill-placed faith in U.S. commitments. After four years of the Trump administration’s bullying, allies from Canada to Germany to South Korea worry about American reliability and seek a course correction. In pledging fidelity to its “friends,” however, the Biden approach risks going too far in the opposite direction. It could create a false expectation among allies of a restored friendship with Washington without conditions. It could even tempt allies to take U.S. support for granted and behave recklessly.
At a time of geopolitical change, a sounder approach instead would acknowledge the reality that alliances hinge on common interests and, as such, are neither permanent nor inviolate. One does not need to support Trump’s foreign policy to accept this point. Ultimately, America’s allies would be foolish to expect that under a Biden presidency, America would replace self-interest with friendship.
Likewise, Americans should not expect their allies to align their interests with Washington consistently. The underlying goal should be to embrace a prudent alliance-management strategy, one that avoids bullying allies at the drop of a hat yet recognizes that—unlike friendships—coercion, pressure, and threats of abandonment are often the coin of the realm. Only if policymakers act upon this messy reality can we hope for a more peaceful world and sounder American policy.